Mobile cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia: analysis of factors affecting treatment prognosis

Jia Wei,You Xu,Hongjing Mao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-53119-8
IF: 4.6
2024-02-08
Scientific Reports
Abstract:This study aims to explore the factors that affect the prognosis of patients with insomnia who are treated with mobile cognitive behavioral therapy. Patients with insomnia who visited the sleep disorders clinic were selected and completed mobile Cognitive behavioral therapy. Patients completed at least three evaluations (including baseline, monthly evaluations thereafter, and a final evaluation at the end of one year) and responded well to treatment within one year of follow-up. Insomnia, anxiety, and depression symptoms were evaluated using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7-item (GAD-7) scale, and the 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), respectively. Treatment prognosis including relapse, recurrence, and remission group. These 339 patients were divided into three groups: 160 patients who remission, 100 patients who relapsed, and 79 patients who experienced recurrence after remission. Demographic characteristics of the 339 patients showed no significant difference in gender between the three groups ( P = 0.978). However, significant differences were found in age ( P = 0.006) and onset time (P = 0.000) among the three groups. The remission group had a higher average age than the recurrence group and the relapse group, and the onset time was slower than the other two groups. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that age and delayed onset time were protective factors for good treatment prognosis, while low educational level and high GAD-7 scores were independent risk factors for poor prognosis. There are many factors that affect the treatment prognosis of insomnia. Age, low educational level, high GAD-7 scores, and delayed onset time can be used to predict the prognosis of insomnia treatment.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the factors that influence the prognosis of insomnia patients treated with mobile cognitive - behavioral therapy (mCBT). Specifically, the study aims to predict which patients may experience relapse, recurrence or remission after using mobile cognitive - behavioral therapy to treat insomnia by analyzing factors such as patients' age, education level, anxiety level (GAD - 7 score), and onset time. ### Research Background - **Prevalence and Impact of Insomnia**: Approximately 25% of adults are dissatisfied with their sleep, 6% - 15% of people have insomnia symptoms, and 1.6% - 10% of people meet the diagnostic criteria for insomnia. Chronic insomnia can significantly increase the risk of depression, substance abuse, suicide, as well as medical conditions such as diabetes, hypertension, and myocardial infarction. Insomnia consumes a large amount of medical resources and reduces the quality of life, so it is regarded as a major global public health problem. - **Cognitive - Behavioral Therapy (CBT - I)**: Cognitive - behavioral therapy is a non - pharmacological treatment method. It improves sleep quality by using cognitive techniques to strengthen circadian rhythms, enhance sleep drive, and reduce anxiety related to insomnia. CBT - I has been widely recognized as the first - line treatment and long - term treatment of choice for insomnia. - **Advantages of Mobile CBT - I**: Traditional CBT - I is limited by factors such as a lack of professionals, high cost, and long duration, while mobile CBT - I can provide treatment anytime and anywhere via mobile phones. It is not only equally effective but also can cover more people, better target the factors that maintain insomnia, improve sleep efficiency, improve mood, and reduce daytime dysfunction. ### Research Purposes - **Explore Influencing Factors**: The study aims to explore the factors that influence the prognosis of insomnia patients treated with mobile CBT - I, and conduct real - world research in combination with drug treatment. - **Grouping and Evaluation**: The study subjects were divided into three groups: remission group, relapse group, and recurrence group. Through baseline assessment, monthly assessment, and final assessment (one year later), the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7 - item Scale (GAD - 7), and the 9 - item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ - 9) were used to assess patients' insomnia, anxiety, and depressive symptoms. ### Main Findings - **Multivariate Logistic Regression Analysis**: The results showed that age, high GAD - 7 score, delayed onset time, and low education level were related to treatment prognosis. - **Age**: For every 1 - year increase in age, the probability of patients changing from recurrence to relapse or from relapse to recurrence increased by 1.031 times, and the stability of treatment effect increased. - **GAD - 7 Score**: For every 1 - point increase in the GAD - 7 score, the probability of patients having an unstable treatment effect increased by 87.7%. - **Education Level**: For patients with only primary school education or below, the probability of non - relapse was only 0.345 times that of patients with postgraduate education. - **Onset Time**: For every 1 - week delay in onset time, the stability of the disease increased by 10.48%, that is, the longer the onset time, the relatively more stable the disease is in treatment. ### Discussion - **Impact of Age**: Although previous studies often regarded age as a negative predictor of sleep disorder treatment outcomes, this study found that the older the patient, the better the treatment prognosis. This may be because elderly patients trust doctors more and are more willing to adhere to treatment. - **Impact of Onset Time**: Delayed onset time may be a protective factor because these patients often experience more pain and dissatisfaction with previous treatments and are more likely to adhere to treatment. - **Impact of Anxiety**: A high GAD - 7 score is an independent risk factor for treatment prognosis, and anxiety may lead to the occurrence and persistence of insomnia symptoms. - **Impact of Education Level**: Patients with a low education level have a poorer treatment prognosis, which may be because they have a weaker ability to cope with negative life events. ### Conclusions - **Predictive Factors**: The study found that older age, lower education level, delayed onset time, and high GAD - 7 score can predict the treatment prognosis of insomnia patients. - **Clinical Applications**: Medical professionals can develop personalized treatment plans based on these factors to further improve treatment effects and long - term prognosis. ### Limitations - **Insufficient Long - term Follow - up**: Longer - term follow - up is required to verify the long - term impact of these factors. - **Data Limitations**: The study data were only from Zhejiang province, and the results may not be universal. - **No Control Group**: It is impossible to establish a causal relationship, and it is difficult to determine online.