Study of Z Bosons Produced in Association with Charm in the Forward Region

R. Aaij,A. S. W. Abdelmotteleb,C. Abellan Beteta,F. J. Abudinen Gallego,T. Ackernley,B. Adeva,M. Adinolfi,H. Afsharnia,C. Agapopoulou,C. A. Aidala,S. Aiola,Z. Ajaltouni,S. Akar,J. Albrecht,F. Alessio,M. Alexander,A. Alfonso Albero,Z. Aliouche,G. Alkhazov,P. Alvarez Cartelle,S. Amato,J. L. Amey,Y. Amhis,L. An,L. Anderlini,A. Andreianov,M. Andreotti,F. Archilli,A. Artamonov,M. Artuso,K. Arzymatov,E. Aslanides,M. Atzeni,B. Audurier,S. Bachmann,M. Bachmayer,J. J. Back,P. Baladron Rodriguez,V Balagura,W. Baldini,J. Baptista Leite,M. Barbetti,R. J. Barlow,S. Barsuk,W. Barter,M. Bartolini,F. Baryshnikov,J. M. Basels,S. Bashir,G. Bassi,B. Batsukh,A. Battig,A. Bay,A. Beck,M. Becker,F. Bedeschi,I Bediaga,A. Beiter,V Belavin,S. Belin,V Bellee,K. Belous,I Belov,I Belyaev,G. Bencivenni,E. Ben-Haim,A. Berezhnoy,R. Bernet,D. Berninghoff,H. C. Bernstein,C. Bertella,A. Bertolin,C. Betancourt,F. Betti,Ia Bezshyiko,S. Bhasin,J. Bhom,L. Bian,M. S. Bieker,S. Bifani,P. Billoir,M. Birch,F. C. R. Bishop,A. Bitadze,A. Bizzeti,M. Bjorn,M. P. Blago,T. Blake,F. Blanc,S. Blusk,D. Bobulska,J. A. Boelhauve,O. Boente Garcia,T. Boettcher,A. Boldyrev,A. Bondar,N. Bondar,S. Borghi,M. Borisyak,M. Borsato,J. T. Borsuk,S. A. Bouchiba,T. J. Bowcock,A. Boyer,C. Bozzi,M. J. Bradley,S. Braun,A. Brea Rodriguez,J. Brodzicka,A. Brossa Gonzalo,D. Brundu,A. Buonaura,L. Buonincontri,A. T. Burke,C. Burr,A. Bursche,A. Butkevich,J. S. Butter,J. Buytaert,W. Byczynski,S. Cadeddu,H. Cai,R. Calabrese,L. Calefice,L. Calero Diaz,S. Cali,R. Calladine,M. Calvi,M. Calvo Gomez,P. Camargo Magalhaes,P. Campana,A. F. Campoverde Quezada,S. Capelli,L. Capriotti,A. Carbone,G. Carboni,R. Cardinale,A. Cardini,I Carli,P. Carniti,L. Carus,K. Carvalho Akiba,A. Casais Vidal,G. Casse,M. Cattaneo,G. Cavallero,S. Celani,J. Cerasoli,D. Cervenkov,A. J. Chadwick,M. G. Chapman,M. Charles,Ph Charpentier,G. Chatzikonstantinidis,C. A. Chavez Barajas,M. Chefdeville,C. Chen,S. Chen,A. Chernov,V Chobanova,S. Cholak,M. Chrzaszcz,A. Chubykin,V Chulikov,P. Ciambrone,M. F. Cicala,X. Cid Vidal,G. Ciezarek,P. E. L. Clarke,M. Clemencic,H. Cliff,J. Closier,J. L. Cobbledick,V Coco,J. A. B. Coelho,J. Cogan,E. Cogneras,L. Cojocariu,P. Collins,T. Colombo,L. Congedo,A. Contu,N. Cooke,G. Coombs,I Corredoira,G. Corti,C. M. Costa Sobral,B. Couturier,D. C. Craik,J. Crkovska,M. Cruz Torres,R. Currie,C. L. Da Silva,S. Dadabaev,L. Dai,E. Dall'Occo,J. Dalseno,C. D'Ambrosio,A. Danilina,P. D'Argent,J. E. Davies,A. Davis,O. De Aguiar Francisco,K. De Bruyn,S. De Capua,M. De Cian,J. M. De Miranda,L. De Paula,M. De Serio,D. De Simone,P. De Simone,F. De Vellis,J. A. de Vries,C. T. Dean,F. Debernardis,D. Decamp,V Dedu,L. Del Buono,B. Delaney,H-P Dembinski,A. Dendek,V Denysenko,D. Derkach,O. Deschamps,F. Desse,F. Dettori,B. Dey,A. Di Cicco,P. Di Nezza,S. Didenko,L. Dieste Maronas,H. Dijkstra,V Dobishuk,C. Dong,A. M. Donohoe,F. Dordei,A. C. dos Reis,L. Douglas,A. Dovbnya,A. G. Downes,M. W. Dudek,L. Dufour,V Duk,P. Durante,J. M. Durham,D. Dutta,A. Dziurda,A. Dzyuba,S. Easo,U. Egede,V Egorychev,S. Eidelman,S. Eisenhardt,S. Ek-In,L. Eklund,S. Ely,A. Ene,E. Epple,S. Escher,J. Eschle,S. Esen,T. Evans,A. Falabella,J. Fan,Y. Fan,B. Fang,S. Farry,D. Fazzini,M. Feo,A. Fernandez Prieto,A. D. Fernez,F. Ferrari,L. Ferreira Lopes,F. Ferreira Rodrigues,S. Ferreres Sole,M. Ferrillo,M. Ferro-Luzzi,S. Filippov,R. A. Fini,M. Fiorini,M. Firlej,K. M. Fischer,D. S. Fitzgerald,C. Fitzpatrick,T. Fiutowski,A. Fkiaras,F. Fleuret,M. Fontana,F. Fontanelli,R. Forty,D. Foulds-Holt,V. Franco Lima,M. Franco Sevilla,M. Frank,E. Franzoso,G. Frau,C. Frei,D. A. Friday,J. Fu,Q. Fuehring,E. Gabriel,G. Galati,A. Gallas Torreira,D. Galli,S. Gambetta,Y. Gan,M. Gandelman,P. Gandini,Y. Gao,M. Garau,L. M. Garcia Martin,P. Garcia Moreno,J. Garcia Pardinas,B. Garcia Plana,F. A. Garcia Rosales,L. Garrido,C. Gaspar,R. E. Geertsema,D. Gerick,L. L. Gerken,E. Gersabeck,M. Gersabeck,T. Gershon,D. Gerstel,L. Giambastiani,V Gibson,H. K. Giemza,A. L. Gilman,M. Giovannetti,A. Gioventu,P. Gironella Gironell,L. Giubega,C. Giugliano,K. Gizdov,E. L. Gkougkousis,V. V. Gligorov,C. Gobel,E. Golobardes,D. Golubkov,A. Golutvin,A. Gomes,S. Gomez Fernandez,F. Goncalves Abrantes,M. Goncerz,G. Gong,P. Gorbounov,I. Gorelov,C. Gotti,E. Govorkova,J. P. Grabowski,T. Grammatico,L. A. Granado Cardoso,E. Grauges,E. Graverini,G. Graziani,A. Grecu,L. M. Greeven,N. A. Grieser,L. Grillo,S. Gromov,B. R. Gruberg Cazon,C. Gu,M. Guarise,M. Guittiere,P. A. Gunther,E. Gushchin,A. Guth,Y. Guz,T. Gys,T. Hadavizadeh,G. Haefeli,C. Haen,J. Haimberger,T. Halewood-leagas,P. M. Hamilton,J. P. Hammerich,Q. Han,X. Han,T. H. Hancock,E. B. Hansen,S. Hansmann-Menzemer,N. Harnew,T. Harrison,C. Hasse,M. Hatch,J. He,M. Hecker,K. Heijhoff,K. Heinicke,A. M. Hennequin,K. Hennessy,L. Henry,J. Heuel,A. Hicheur,D. Hill,M. Hilton,S. E. Hollitt,R. Hou,Y. Hou,J. Hu,W. Hu,X. Hu,W. Huang,X. Huang,W. Hulsbergen,R. J. Hunter,M. Hushchyn,D. Hutchcroft,D. Hynds,P. Ibis,M. Idzik,D. Ilin,P. Ilten,A. Inglessi,A. Ishteev,K. Ivshin,R. Jacobsson,H. Jage,S. Jakobsen,E. Jans,B. K. Jashal,A. Jawahery,V Jevtic,F. Jiang,M. John,D. Johnson,C. R. Jones,T. P. Jones,B. Jost,N. Jurik,S. H. Kalavan Kadavath,S. Kandybei,Y. Kang,M. Karacson,M. Karpov,F. Keizer,D. M. Keller,M. Kenzie,T. Ketel,B. Khanji,A. Kharisova,S. Kholodenko,T. Kirn,V. S. Kirsebom,O. Kitouni,S. Klaver,N. Kleijne,K. Klimaszewski,M. R. Kmiec,S. Koliiev,A. Kondybayeva,A. Konoplyannikov,P. Kopciewicz,R. Kopecna,P. Koppenburg,M. Korolev,I Kostiuk,O. Kot,S. Kotriakhova,P. Kravchenko,L. Kravchuk,R. D. Krawczyk,M. Kreps,F. Kress,S. Kretzschmar,P. Krokovny,W. Krupa,W. Krzemien,M. Kucharczyk,V Kudryavtsev,H. S. Kuindersma,G. J. Kunde,T. Kvaratskheliya,D. Lacarrere,G. Lafferty,A. Lai,A. Lampis,D. Lancierini,J. J. Lane,R. Lane,G. Lanfranchi,C. Langenbruch,J. Langer,O. Lantwin,T. Latham,F. Lazzari,R. Le Gac,S. H. Lee,R. Lefevre,A. Leflat,S. Legotin,O. Leroy,T. Lesiak,B. Leverington,H. Li,P. Li,S. Li,Y. Li,Z. Li,X. Liang,T. Lin,R. Lindner,V Lisovskyi,R. Litvinov,G. Liu,H. Liu,Q. Liu,S. Liu,A. Lobo Salvia,A. Loi,J. Lomba Castro,I Longstaff,J. H. Lopes,S. Lopez Solino,G. H. Lovell,Y. Lu,C. Lucarelli,D. Lucchesi,S. Luchuk,M. Lucio Martinez,V Lukashenko,Y. Luo,A. Lupato,E. Luppi,O. Lupton,A. Lusiani,X. Lyu,L. Ma,R. Ma,S. Maccolini,F. Machefert,F. Maciuc,V Macko,P. Mackowiak,S. Maddrell-Mander,O. Madejczyk,L. R. Madhan Mohan,O. Maev,A. Maevskiy,D. Maisuzenko,M. W. Majewski,J. J. Malczewski,S. Malde,B. Malecki,A. Malinin,T. Maltsev,H. Malygina,G. Manca,G. Mancinelli,D. Manuzzi,D. Marangotto,J. Maratas,J. F. Marchand,U. Marconi,S. Mariani,C. Marin Benito,M. Marinangeli,J. Marks,A. M. Marshall,P. J. Marshall,G. Martelli,G. Martellotti,L. Martinazzoli,M. Martinelli,D. Martinez Santos,F. Martinez Vidal,A. Massafferri,M. Materok,R. Matev,A. Mathad,V Matiunin,C. Matteuzzi,K. R. Mattioli,A. Mauri,E. Maurice,J. Mauricio,M. Mazurek,M. McCann,L. Mcconnell,T. H. Mcgrath,N. T. Mchugh,A. McNab,R. McNulty,J. Mead,B. Meadows,G. Meier,N. Meinert,D. Melnychuk,S. Meloni,M. Merk,A. Merli,L. Meyer Garcia,M. Mikhasenko,D. A. Milanes,E. Millard,M. Milovanovic,M-N Minard,A. Minotti,L. Minzoni,S. E. Mitchell,B. Mitreska,D. S. Mitzel,A. Modden,R. A. Mohammed,R. D. Moise,S. Mokhnenko,T. Mombacher,I. A. Monroy,S. Monteil,M. Morandin,G. Morello,M. J. Morello,J. Moron,A. B. Morris,A. G. Morris,R. Mountain,H. Mu,F. Muheim,M. Mulder,D. Muller,K. Muller,C. H. Murphy,D. Murray,P. Muzzetto,P. Naik,T. Nakada,R. Nandakumar,T. Nanut,I Nasteva,M. Needham,I Neri,N. Neri,S. Neubert,N. Neufeld,R. Newcombe,E. M. Niel,S. Nieswand,N. Nikitin,N. S. Nolte,C. Normand,C. Nunez,A. Oblakowska-Mucha,V Obraztsov,T. Oeser,D. P. O'Hanlon,S. Okamura,R. Oldeman,F. Oliva,M. E. Olivares,C. J. G. Onderwater,R. H. O'Neil,J. M. Otalora Goicochea,T. Ovsiannikova,P. Owen,A. Oyanguren,K. O. Padeken,B. Pagare,P. R. Pais,T. Pajero,A. Palano,M. Palutan,Y. Pan,G. Panshin,A. Papanestis,M. Pappagallo,L. L. Pappalardo,C. Pappenheimer,W. Parker,C. Parkes,B. Passalacqua,G. Passaleva,A. Pastore,M. Patel,C. Patrignani,C. J. Pawley,A. Pearce,A. Pellegrino,M. Pepe Altarelli,S. Perazzini,D. Pereima,A. Pereiro Castro,P. Perret,M. Petric,K. Petridis,A. Petrolini,A. Petrov,S. Petrucci,M. Petruzzo,T. T. H. Pham,A. Philippov,L. Pica,M. Piccini,B. Pietrzyk,G. Pietrzyk,M. Pili,D. Pinci,F. Pisani,M. Pizzichemi,P. K. Resmi,V Placinta,J. Plews,M. Plo Casasus,F. Polci,M. Poli Lener,M. Poliakova,A. Poluektov,N. Polukhina,I Polyakov,E. Polycarpo,S. Ponce,D. Popov,S. Popov,S. Poslavskii,K. Prasanth,L. Promberger,C. Prouve,V Pugatch,V Puill,H. Pullen,G. Punzi,H. Qi,W. Qian,J. Qin,N. Qin,R. Quagliani,B. Quintana,N. Raab,R. I. Rabadan Trejo,B. Rachwal,J. H. Rademacker,M. Rama,M. Ramos Pernas,M. S. Rangel,F. Ratnikov,G. Raven,M. Reboud,F. Redi,F. Reiss,C. Remon Alepuz,Z. Ren,V Renaudin,R. Ribatti,S. Ricciardi,K. Rinnert,P. Robbe,G. Robertson,A. B. Rodrigues,E. Rodrigues,J. A. Rodriguez Lopez,Rodriguez,A. Rollings,P. Roloff,V Romanovskiy,M. Romero Lamas,A. Romero Vidal,J. D. Roth,M. Rotondo,M. S. Rudolph,T. Ruf,R. A. Ruiz Fernandez,J. Ruiz Vidal,A. Ryzhikov,J. Ryzka,J. J. Saborido Silva,N. Sagidova,N. Sahoo,B. Saitta,M. Salomoni,C. Sanchez Gras,R. Santacesaria,C. Santamarina Rios,M. Santimaria,E. Santovetti,D. Saranin,G. Sarpis,M. Sarpis,A. Sarti,C. Satriano,A. Satta,M. Saur,D. Savrina,H. Sazak,L. G. Scantlebury Smead,A. Scarabotto,S. Schael,S. Scherl,M. Schiller,H. Schindler,M. Schmelling,B. Schmidt,S. Schmitt,O. Schneider,A. Schopper,M. Schubiger,S. Schulte,M. H. Schune,R. Schwemmer,B. Sciascia,S. Sellam,A. Semennikov,M. Senghi Soares,A. Sergi,N. Serra,L. Sestini,A. Seuthe,Y. Shang,D. M. Shangase,M. Shapkin,I Shchemerov,L. Shchutska,T. Shears,L. Shekhtman,Z. Shen,V Shevchenko,E. B. Shields,Y. Shimizu,E. Shmanin,J. D. Shupperd,B. G. Siddi,R. Silva Coutinho,G. Simi,S. Simone,N. Skidmore,T. Skwarnicki,M. W. Slater,I Slazyk,J. C. Smallwood,J. G. Smeaton,A. Smetkina,E. Smith,M. Smith,A. Snoch,M. Soares,L. Soares Lavra,M. D. Sokoloff,F. J. P. Soler,A. Solovev,I Solovyev,F. L. Souza De Almeida,B. Souza De Paula,B. Spaan,E. Spadaro Norella,P. Spradlin,F. Stagni,M. Stahl,S. Stahl,S. Stanislaus,O. Steinkamp,O. Stenyakin,H. Stevens,S. Stone,M. Straticiuc,D. Strekalina,F. Suljik,J. Sun,L. Sun,Y. Sun,P. Svihra,P. N. Swallow,K. Swientek,A. Szabelski,T. Szumlak,M. Szymanski,S. Taneja,A. R. Tanner,M. D. Tat,A. Terentev,F. Teubert,E. Thomas,D. J. D. Thompson,K. A. Thomson,V Tisserand,S. T'Jampens,M. Tobin,L. Tomassetti,X. Tong,D. Torres Machado,D. Y. Tou,E. Trifonova,C. Trippl,G. Tuci,A. Tully,N. Tuning,A. Ukleja,D. J. Unverzagt,E. Ursov,A. Usachov,A. Ustyuzhanin,U. Uwer,A. Vagner,V. Vagnoni,A. Valassi,G. Valenti,N. Valls Canudas,M. van Beuzekom,M. Van Dijk,H. Van Hecke,E. van Herwijnen,C. B. Van Hulse,M. van Veghel,R. Vazquez Gomez,P. Vazquez Regueiro,C. Vazquez Sierra,S. Vecchi,J. J. Velthuis,M. Veltri,A. Venkateswaran,M. Veronesi,M. Vesterinen,D. Vieira,M. Vieites Diaz,H. Viemann,X. Vilasis-Cardona,E. Vilella Figueras,A. Villa,P. Vincent,F. C. Volle,D. Vom Bruch,A. Vorobyev,V. Vorobyev,N. Voropaev,K. Vos,R. Waldi,J. Walsh,C. Wang,J. Wang,M. Wang,R. Wang,Y. Wang,Z. Wang,J. A. Ward,N. K. Watson,S. G. Weber,D. Websdale,C. Weisser,B. D. C. Westhenry,D. J. White,M. Whitehead,A. R. Wiederhold,D. Wiedner,G. Wilkinson,M. Wilkinson,I Williams,M. Williams,M. R. J. Williams,F. F. Wilson,W. Wislicki,M. Witek,L. Witola,G. Wormser,S. A. Wotton,H. Wu,K. Wyllie,Z. Xiang,D. Xiao,Y. Xie,A. Xu,J. Xu,L. Xu,M. Xu,Q. Xu,Z. Xu,D. Yang,S. Yang,Y. Yang,Z. Yang,Y. Yao,L. E. Yeomans,H. Yin,J. Yu,X. Yuan,O. Yushchenko,E. Zaffaroni,M. Zavertyaev,M. Zdybal,O. Zenaiev,M. Zeng,D. Zhang,L. Zhang,S. Zhang,Y. Zhang,A. Zharkova,A. Zhelezov,Y. Zheng,T. Zhou,X. Zhou,Y. Zhou,V Zhovkovska,X. Zhu,Z. Zhu,V Zhukov,J. B. Zonneveld,Q. Zou,S. Zucchelli,D. Zuliani,G. Zunica
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.128.082001
IF: 8.6
2022-01-01
Physical Review Letters
Abstract:Events containing a Z boson and a charm jet are studied for the first time in the forward region of proton-proton collisions. The data sample used corresponds to an integrated luminosity of 6  fb^{-1} collected at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV with the LHCb detector. In events with a Z boson and a jet, the fraction of charm jets is determined in intervals of Z-boson rapidity in the range 2.0<y(Z)<4.5. A sizable enhancement is observed in the forwardmost y(Z) interval, which could be indicative of a valencelike intrinsic-charm component in the proton wave function.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?