Abstract:Background Metabolic scaling theory (MST) is still in debate because observed allometric exponents often deviate from MST predictions, and can change significantly depending on environment, phylogeny, and disturbance. We assembled published scaling exponents from literatures for three allometric relationships linked to biomass allocation: leaf biomass-diameter (L-D), stem biomass-diameter (S-D), and root biomass-diameter (R-D). We used data from natural forests and plantations across China to test the following hypotheses: 1) the allometric relationships of trees support the predictions of MST on a broad scale; 2) the observed deviations from MST predictions are caused by climate, biotic factors, and/or phylogeny; 3) abiotic and biotic factors influence allometric relationships in plantations and natural forests differently, and different allometric relationships (i.e. L-D, S-D, and R-D) are affected differently. We related these scaling exponents to geographic climate gradient, successional stage, stand density, leaf form and phenology, and phylogeny. We used mixed-effect models to examine the major factors affecting tree allometries. Results In natural forests, S-D and R-D scaling exponents were consistent with MST predictions in primary forests, but were significantly lower in secondary forests. Both S-D and R-D scaling exponents in plantations had a medium value that fell between those of the secondary and primary forests, despite plantations being similar in species characteristics and age to secondary forests. The S-D and R-D exponents were significantly affected by factors that are not yet considered in MST, including winter coldness which explained 2.76% – 3.24% of variations, successional stage (7.91% – 8.20% of variations), density (a surrogate for competition, 5.86% – 8.54% of variations), and especially phylogeny (45.86% – 56.64% of variations explained). However, the L-D scaling exponents conformed to MST predictions in primary, secondary, and plantation forests, and was not strongly explained by most factors. Conclusion MST is only applicable to primary (steady-state) forests, and climate, biotic factors and phylogeny are causes of the observed deviations of allometric relationships from MST predictions. Forest management practices in plantations have a strong influence on tree allometries. L-D allometry is more strongly controlled by biophysical constraints than S-D and R-D allometries, however, the mechanisms behind this difference still need further examinations.

Variance in Tree Growth Rates Provides a Key Link for Completing the Theory of Forest Size Structure Formation

Will Forest Size Structure Follow the -2 Power-Law Distribution under Ideal Demographic Equilibrium State?

Testing Predictions of the Energetic Equivalence Rule in Forest Communities

Different Performing Trees Manifest Varied Scaling Relationships at Individual and Branch Levels

Forest demography and biomass accumulation rates are associated with transient mean tree size vs. density scaling relations

Distribution of Biomass Dynamics in Relation to Tree Size in Forests Across the World

Allometric scaling relationships for morphology and biomass allocation are mediated by stand ages in Cyclobalanopsis glauca

Major axes of variation in tree demography across global forests

Scaling Relationship Between Tree Respiration Rates and Biomass

Assessing the Allometric Scaling of Vectorized Branch Lengths of Trees with Terrestrial Laser Scanning and Quantitative Structure Modeling: A Case Study in Guyana

Scaling Relationships Between Leaf Mass and Total Plant Mass Across Chinese Forests

Application of the Metabolic Scaling Theory and Water–energy Balance Equation to Model Large‐scale Patterns of Maximum Forest Canopy Height

Relative Growth Rate for Trees at the Growth Stage is Coordinated with Leaf Bulk Modulus of Elasticity and Osmotic Potential in a Subtropical Forest of China

Phylogenetic Structure of Tree Species Across Different Life Stages from Seedlings to Canopy Trees in a Subtropical Evergreen Broad-Leaved Forest.

Linkages between stem vulnerability curves and tree demography and their implications for plant physiological modeling

What Causes Greater Deviations from Predictions of Metabolic Scaling Theory in Earlier Successional Forests

Ontogeny influences tree growth response to soil fertility and neighbourhood crowding in an old-growth temperate forest

Quantifying the Variability of Internode Allometry Within and Between Trees for Pinus Tabulaeformis Carr. Using a Multilevel Nonlinear Mixed-Effect Model

Geographic variation in growth and reproduction trade‐offs: Implications for future tree performance

Dynamic allometric scaling of tree biomass and size

Effects of Climate, Biotic Factors, and Phylogeny on Allometric Relationships: Testing the Metabolic Scaling Theory in Plantations and Natural Forests Across China