High survival rate of kidney transplants in IgA nephropathy patients

Eduardo C. Lim,Paul I. Terasaki
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1399-0012.1992.tb00599.x
1992-04-01
Clinical Transplantation
Abstract:Background Patients with various diseases such as chronic glomerulonephritis (CGN), pyelonephritis (PN), polycystic kidney disease (PKD), etc., have had remarkably similar kidney graft survival rates. It was interesting to see if patients with IgA nephropathy (IgAN), who have associated immunologic dysfunctions, might have an unusual response to their kidney allografts. Methods The graft survival rates of 374 patients with IgAN were compared to those of patients with other diseases from data submitted the UCLA Transplant Registry by over 200 different centers. Results The 5‐year cadaver donor graft survival rate in patients with IgAN was 76%, compared to 60% for controls (PN, PKD and CGN). Matching IgAN for age, sex, and race at 4 yr still yielded significantly higher graft survival of 86% compared to 68% for controls. Functional graft survival, which counts death as lost‐to‐follow‐up, was also higher at 5 yr among IgAN patients (77%) compared to controls (66%). Grafts from HLA‐identical sibling donors and 1‐haplotype‐matched related donors also had higher survival in IgAN recipients than in patients with other diseases. Thirty‐four IgAN‐sensitized patients with preformed cytotoxic antibodies had a 97% 5‐year graft survival rate. Graft survival to 5 yr among 60 patients with IgAN who were not transfused was 90%. Transfusion reduced the graft survival to 84% at 1 yr and 73% at 5 yr. Conclusion Patients with IgAN have higher kidney allograft survival rates than patients with CGN, PN, PKD. Immunologic dysfunction in IgAN patients is probably responsible for higher kidney allograft survival in those patients, and may provide clues as to how similar results can be achieved for other patients.
surgery,transplantation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?