Abstract:The Chesapeake Bay watershed is representative of governance challenges relating to agricultural nonpoint source pollution and, more generally, of sustainable resources governance in complex multi-actor settings. We assess information flows around Best Management Practices (BMPs) undertaken by dairy farmers in central Pennsylvania, a subregion of the watershed. We apply a mixed-method approach, combining Social Network Analysis, the analysis of BMP-messaging (i.e. information source, flow, and their influences), and qualitative content analysis of stakeholders' interviews. Key strategic actors were identified through network centrality measures such as degree of node, betweenness centrality, and clustering coefficient. The perceived influence/credibility (by farmers) of BMP-messages and their source, allowed for the identification of strategic entry points for BMP-messages diffusion. Finally, the inductive coding process of stakeholders' interviews revealed major hindrances and opportunities for BMPs adoption. We demonstrate how improved targeting of policy interventions for BMPs uptake may be achieved, by better distributing entry-points across stakeholders. Our results reveal governance gaps and opportunities, on which we draw to provide insights for better tailored policy interventions. We propose strategies to optimize the coverage of policy mixes and the dissemination of BMP-messages by building on network diversity and actors' complementarities, and by targeting intervention towards specific BMPs and actors. We suggest that (i) conservation incentives could target supply chain actors as conservation intermediaries; (ii) compliance-control of manure management planning could be conducted by accredited private certifiers; (iii) policy should focus on incentivizing inter-farmers interaction (e.g. farmers' mobility, training, knowledge-exchange, and engagement in multi-stakeholders collaboration) via financial or non-pecuniary compensation; (iv) collective incentives could help better coordinate conservation efforts at the landscape or (sub-)watershed scale; (v) all relevant stakeholders (including farmers) should be concerted and included in the discussion, proposition, co-design and decision process of policy, in order to take their respective interests and responsibilities into account.

Exploring the Role of 'Intermediaries' between Non-Operating Landowners and Tenant Farmers in Promoting Conservation on Rented Farmland

The effect of engagement in private lands research on landowner conservation knowledge, attitudes, awareness, and behavioral intentions

The Micro Administrative Mechanism of Land Reallocation in Land Consolidation: A Perspective from Collective Action

Overcoming barriers to agri-environmental management at landscape scale: Balancing farmer coordination and collaboration with the aid of facilitators and pioneers

Effective Engagement Techniques Across the Agricultural Conservation Practice Adoption Process

Landowners’ Perspectives on Coordinated, Landscape-Level Invasive Species Control: The Role of Social and Ecological Context

On the influence of trust in predicting rural land owner cooperation with natural resource management institutions

Factors Impacting Agricultural Landowners' Willingness to Enter into Conservation Easements: A Case Study

Adoption of agricultural conservation practices in the United States: Evidence from 35 years of quantitative literature

Social Marketing Works: Results from Ten Years of Tools for Engaging Landowners Effectively Trainings

Does temporary land retirement promote organic adoption? Evidence from the conservation reserve program

Behavioural drivers of long-term land leasing adoption: application of an extended theory of planned behaviour

Collective land arrangements that decommodify land for agroecological transformations

Estimating landholders' probability of participating in a stewardship program, and the implications for spatial conservation priorities

Buy, sell or rent the farm: succession planning and the future of farming on the Great Plains

Navigating agricultural nonpoint source pollution governance: A social network analysis of best management practices in central Pennsylvania

Perceptions of the 'good farmer' and social licence to operate in Aotearoa New Zealand

Evaluating Soil Conservation Effectiveness: An Investigation of Spatial Targeting, Conservation Adoption, and Financial Incentives

Promoting equity in the Conservation Reserve Program across the southeastern US

From informal farmland rental to market‐oriented transactions: Do China's Land Transfer Service Centers help?

Spatially coordinated conservation auctions: A framed field experiment focusing on farmland wildlife conservation in China