Divergent Scaling of Fine-Root Nitrogen and Phosphorus in Different Root Diameters, Orders and Functional Categories: A Meta-Analysis

Zhiqiang Wang,Heng Huang,Buqing Yao,Jianming Deng,Zeqing Ma,Karl J. Niklas
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2021.119384
IF: 3.7
2021-01-01
Forest Ecology and Management
Abstract:Fine-root nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) concentrations play an important role in driving ecological processes such as nutrient cycling in terrestrial ecosystems. Previous studies have demonstrated that the N versus P scaling relationship for fine roots (<2 mm in diameter) on average follows a 0.82-power law across plant functional groups and ecosystems. However, little is known about the N versus P scaling relationships for different fine-root classification groups (classes of diameters, branch orders, and functional categories, e.g., absorptive and transport roots). We used a dataset comprising 1037 N-P paired observations for a total of 227 woody species to explore N versus P scaling relationships in different fine-root groups. The overall means of fine-root N and P concentrations and N:P ratios across all of the woody species were 12.27 mg g-1, 1.01 mg g-1, and 15.14, respectively. N and P concentrations, N:P ratios, and the numerical values of the N versus P scaling exponents differed significantly within and across the different fine-root classes. The numerical values of absorptive roots N versus P scaling exponents varied within plant functional groups (e.g., life-form, phylogenetic and mycorrhizal groups). The numerical values of absorptive roots scaling exponents declined from 0.89 in boreal regions to 0.61 tropical regions. These results indicate that fine roots (<2 mm in diameter) should be carefully classified into different groups/categories when N and P scaling relationships need to be determined to predict plant growth and vegetation productivity. Our results shed important light on attempts to modeling fine-root biogeochemical processes in terrestrial ecosystems.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?