Abstract:The measurement of thermal properties in partially frozen soil is crucial for global climate models. As the primary method for soil thermal property measurement, the Dual-Probe Heat-Pulse (DPHP) sensor experiences significant errors when used in partially frozen soils. The application of heat pulses leads to ice melting, and the existing DPHP theory, which does not consider phase changes, fails to accurately determine thermal conductivity (k) and heat capacity (C) in the temperature range of − 5 °C to 0 °C. There is a lack of DPHP theory specifically designed for use in partially frozen soils. The existing DPHP theory employs the Infinite Linear Source (ILS) approximation, which does not account for the melting process and the moving ice-liquid interface in transient heat conduction theory. Currently, there is no effective and reliable method to assess DPHP errors associated with measuring the thermal properties of partially frozen soil. To accurately determine k and C in frozen soil, it is essential to perform an error analysis regarding ice melting caused by a DPHP heat pulse input. In this study, (1) we considered the latent heat of ice melting and a moving ice-liquid interface in finite element simulations and compared the results with an analytical solution presented by Paterson (1952); (2) we performed simulations of DPHP measurements based on the temperature-dependent ice content, liquid water content, and melting latent heat of three frozen soils used by Watanabe and Wake (2009); (3) based on COMSOL simulation results for the three frozen soils, we determined the optimal heating parameter combinations (heating duration, t0, and accumulated heating energy, ΔQ) to minimize DPHP measurement errors in frozen soil. The results showed that (1) Simulations that included the melting phase changes were in agreement with the analytical solution by Paterson (1952). (2) Including the ice-liquid moving interface significantly altered the spatial distribution characteristics of temperature, which were not captured by the ILS model in terms of the temperature distribution near the interface. (3) Below a temperature of − 5.5 °C, the simulations that included phase changes were consistent with measured results; (4) For partially frozen soils with initial temperatures ranging from − 0.5 °C to 0 °C, the relative errors in thermal conductivity fitted by the ILS model exceeded 100 %. To mitigate the influence of ice melting, we recommend using 200 < ΔQ < 400 J m−1 for sand, loam, and silt loam soils with 8 s < t0 < 60 s. For a loam soil with t0 = 60 s, ΔQ = 800 J m−1 should be used. For a silt loam soil with t0 = 60 s, we recommend using ΔQ = 600 J m−1. If the ILS model is chosen to calculate soil thermal properties, we recommend using 200 < ΔQ < 600 J m−1 and 30 s < t0 < 60 s for sandy and silt loam soils. For a loam soil, we recommend using 400 < ΔQ < 800 J m−1 and 30 s < t0 < 60 s.

An Ice Correction Model for Dielectric Sensor to Improve Accuracy of Soil Water Potential Measurement in Frozen Soils

In-situ Estimation of Unsaturated Hydraulic Conductivity in Freezing Soil Using Improved Field Data and Inverse Numerical Modeling

Improvement in Modeling Soil Dielectric Properties During Freeze-Thaw Transitions

An improved model and field calibration technique for measuring liquid water content in unfrozen and frozen soils with dielectric probes

Measuring and Modeling the Dielectric Constant of Soil During Freezing and Thawing Processes: an Application on Silty Clay

Evaluation of Five Composite Dielectric Mixing Models for Understanding Relationships Between Effective Permittivity and Unfrozen Water Content

The Estimation of Dielectric Constant of Frozen Soil-Water Mixture at Microwave Bands

Optimized Measurement of Frozen Soil Thermal Properties Using a Heat-Pulse Sensor

Feasibility study on ice content measurement of frozen soil using actively heated FBG sensors

Experimental Study and Simulation of Thermal Conductivity of Saturated Frozen Soil

In-situ Determination of Soil Water Retention Curves in Heterogeneous Soil Profiles with a Novel Dielectric Tube Sensor for Measuring Soil Matric Potential and Water Content

Application of Multiphase Dielectric Mixing Models for Understanding the Effective Dielectric Permittivity of Frozen Soils

Pf Meter-based Research on Soil Freezing Characteristic Curves

An experimental study of the relationship between the matric potential, unfrozen water, and segregated ice of saturated freezing soil

An implicit Heat-Pulse-Probe method for measuring the soil ice content

Analytical model to predict unfrozen water content based on the probability of ice formation in soils

A novel soil water-heat-salt coupling model for freezing-thawing period in farmland with shallow groundwater

Improving Estimation of Evapotranspiration During Soil Freeze-Thaw Cycles by Incorporating a Freezing Stress Index and a Coupled Heat and Water Transfer Model into the FAO Penman-Monteith Model

A New Freezing Method for Soil Water Characteristic Curve Measurement

A Thermodynamic Model for Calculating the Unfrozen Water Content of Frozen Soil

Monitoring Near-Surface Soil Water Content Using an Innovative Perforated Cylinder Coaxial Dielectric Sensor