Abstract:The pattern of increased nest defense effort over the course of a nesting season could result from three distinct (albeit non-exclusive) mechanisms: increased value of offspring to parents with progression toward independence (parental investment theory), decreased opportunity for renesting (renesting potential hypothesis), or decreased perceived costs of defense after repeated encounters with human observers (positive reinforcement hypothesis). To gauge relative empirical support for each of these mechanisms, we disentangle these three often-confounded hypotheses using multimodel inference with mixed-model ordinal regression applied to an extensive red-winged blackbird (Agelaius phoeniceus) nesting data set (4518 monitoring visits to 1330 nests). Parent aggression was rated on an ordinal scale (0–4) during repeated monitoring visits. Additionally, we assessed clutch/brood size, nest density, time of day, and nest concealment effects on aggression. In a preliminary analysis, including all three major hypotheses, male and female nest defense was most strongly explained by parental investment (nest age). Positive reinforcement (visit number) and renesting potential (Julian date) were also well-supported predictors in males. The interactions of decomposed nest age (within-individual and between-individual centered) with Julian date were particularly important in the top male model. Additional factors, such as clutch/brood size, nest density, and nest concealment, appeared to have larger predictive roles in explaining female aggression relative to males. These patterns are likely explained by different sexual reproductive roles within a polygynous mating system. Our study highlights the importance of interacting mechanisms involving parental investment theory and the use of within-individual standardization to help disentangle competing and empirically confounded hypotheses.Significance statementAvian nest defense generally increases over the course of a nesting season, potentially from the result of three different mechanisms: parental investment theory, renesting potential hypothesis, or positive reinforcement hypothesis from repeated nest visitation. We revisit this classic question through a comprehensive analytical approach with an extensive observational data set with red-winged blackbirds, employing multimodel selection and within-individual and between-individual centering techniques. We found that parental investment (nest age) was the strongest predictor of nest defense for both sexes; however, positive reinforcement and renesting potential also appeared to help explain additional variation in nest defense for males. Competitiveness of models with interactive effects indicated that these mechanisms do not operate independently for either sex, and additional covariates (e.g., clutch/brood size) especially aided female model competiveness. Our study highlights the importance of multiple and often interacting factors that influence avian nest defense.

Author Response for "female‐female Aggression in a Cooperatively Breeding Bird During the Non‐breeding Period: the Behavioral Strategy to Maintain Long‐term Partnerships"

Cooperation and Coordination in Socially Monogamous Birds: Moving Away From a Focus on Sexual Conflict

Sex Allocation and Paternity in A Cooperatively Breeding Passerine: Evidence for the Male Attractiveness Hypothesis?

MALE BEHAVIORS OF SOCIALLY MONOGAMOUS TIBETAN EARED-PHEASANTS DURING THE BREEDING SEASON

Female Ground Tits Prefer Relatives As Extra-Pair Partners: Driven by Kin-Selection?

Reproductive Skew in an Avian Cooperative Breeder: an Empirical Test for Theoretical Models

Bi‐parental Vs. Cooperative Breeding in a Passerine: Fitness‐maximizing Strategies of Males in Response to Risk of Extra‐pair Paternity?

Males and Females of a Polygamous Songbird Respond Differently to Mating Opportunities

Where are extra-pair offspring raised: the mother’s, the father’s or the others’ nest?

Female mate choice and the emergence of male coercion

Social Organization, Demography and Genetic Mating System of A Tibetan Cooperative Breeder

Agonistic Responses to Potential Co‐foundresses in a Cooperatively Brooding Quasi‐social Parasitoid

Cooperative Young-Caring Behaviour In A Hybrid Population Of White And Tibetan Eared-Pheasants In Tibet

Proximate perspectives on the evolution of female aggression: good for the gander, good for the goose?

Extra‐pair Paternity in Relation to Breeding Synchrony in Ground Tits: an Individual‐based Approach

Sex Differences in Response to Experimentally Induced Sexual Conflict in Cinereous Tits Parus Cinereus

Assessing the relationship between female aggression and male phenotype in two sister Malurus fairywren species

Alternative Mating Tactics in Socially Monogamous Prairie Voles, Microtus ochrogaster

Social Experience Shapes Fighting Strategies for Reproductive Success

Pair-bonding leads to convergence in approach behavior to conspecific vocalizations in California mice (Peromyscus californicus)

A classic question revisited in red-winged blackbirds: disentangling confounding hypotheses surrounding parental investment theory and nest defense intensity