Development of General Practice Education and Training in China.
Ren Wen,Liu Ying,Qiu Yan,Ren Jingjing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.0366-6999.20140503
IF: 6.133
2014-01-01
Chinese Medical Journal
Abstract:General practice as a discipline has largely evolved over the past 30 years in the field of primary health care. It originated in the 18th century in Europe. It was established in the United States in the 1960s and introduced to China in the late 1980s. In earlier times, medicine was not specialized, and general physicians dominated the medical field.1 At the end of the 19th century, with the development of basic medical disciplines, such as biology and anatomy, the development of more specialized medical practices began. Medical specialists increased in number while general physicians declined. By the late 1980s,2 an aging population, increased urbanization, increased incidence of infectious diseases, and rising healthcare costs made the practice of family medicine more common.3 Preparation for the establishment of the academic discipline of family medicine began officially in 1989 with the foundation of the General Practice Training Center (GPTC) in Beijing. In 1999, family medicine achieved formal status as an academic discipline. Key policies regarding general practice in China were issued by the Ministry of Health as "The Guideline on the Education of General Practice" in 2000.4 The guideline stated that in 2000, the basic framework of the general medical education system should be established, with a focus on on-job training in large and medium-sized cities; there should also be pilot work for general practitioner (GP) education after medical graduation. In 2005, the general medical education system was established. With the help of on-job training, the GP residency training program was initiated. By 2010, a more mature general medical education system was established throughout the country. This included the creation of a high-quality community health service team with GPs as the backbone to meet the needs of health reform and community health service. Based on the guidelines, 29 provinces performed on-job training of GPs by the end of 2010. A total of 21 provinces performed standard training for GPs. More importantly, there were 630 clinical teaching training bases that recruited more than 6 000 students. In 2009,5 the Central Committee of the State Council issued "The Guidelines for Furthering the Reform of Health Care System," which emphasized improving the healthcare system to better serve both urban and rural residents. The proposal states that a large number of high-quality GPs are necessary for the continued improvement of community health services. In July 2011,6 "The Guidelines for Establishing GP's Professional System" was issued. It marked the institutionalization of GP training. The construction, development, and training of GPs had become key strategic issues for the development of healthcare enterprise and reform. The release of the document also led to the unification of GP training. In addition, the document put forward that up until the year 2020, there would be approximately two to three qualified GPs per million urban residents. In 2013, Secretary Chen Zhu told reporters that during the medical reform, the most important thing is to strengthen the services of all general hospitals; communities and hospitals should also increase communication via the National People's Congress and the Chinese Political Consultative Conference. There is now sufficient evidence that having general practice as an integral part of the health-care system saves money and provides better health outcomes for patients. However, this outcome is only possible if GPs are formally trained to a very high level. General practice education and training mode in China The education and training of GPs in mainland of China include undergraduate education, graduate education, postgraduate education, and continued education throughout the individual's career. Undergraduate education General medicine teaching in Chinese medical schools has significantly increased over the last decade, expanding from none to 59 schools.7 Undergraduate medical students learn the basic theory and concepts of general practice through "Introduction of General Practice" and "General Practice and Community Health Service." Currently, 49.2% of medical schools that have professional clinical medicine have established general practice courses. In 2010, the National Development and Reform Commission proposed general medical student training in higher medical colleges and schools for a 3-year period. The system should promote the cultivation of medical health personnel for primary medical institutions. Students have free accommodations during the training period and enjoy certain subsidies each year. This helps to solve the problem of expensive tuition fees and may also help improve the lack of doctors in primary communities. Unfortunately, many students have little knowledge of general medicine and are largely uninterested in the topic. Some students sign a directional employment agreement with the health administrative department, which impairs student motivation and can affect the quality of the general training.8 Traditional training schemes for general practice do not adequately prepare trainees for independent practice. Graduate education In compliance with the requirement of the system of GPs, China will gradually standardize and unify the training modes for GPs. In principle, they should first receive a 5-year undergraduate education in clinical medicine, followed by a 3-year standard training in general practices, namely the "5+3" mode. Specific course and rotation outlines have been published. Training includes general concepts of primary care for the first 3 months, followed by 27 months of clinical rotations in the hospital and 6 months of training in the community and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). This format allows students to spend more time gaining experience practicing outside the hospital. Table 1 shows the residency training components and the periods in general practice. The training is planned in accordance with the specialist training regulation, and residents' performances are assessed according to the opinions of the department heads, who usually consult with other faculty and staff. Besides the traditional medical curriculum, some medical schools in Shanghai have experience in problem-based learning and role playing. Standard patient medical education, Mini-Clinical Evaluation Exercise, and objective structural clinical examination were used to improve the trainees' clinical skills and communication abilities. A preceptorship was implemented in Zhejiang province. The opportunity to see a concentrated number of cases under the supervision of a preceptor was highly valued. An integrated system to evaluate the trainee makes the assessment more comprehensive.Table 1: Residency training components and the periods in general practicePostgraduate education To attract more GPs, Fudan University selects outstanding trainees in the "5+3" system for postgraduate education (general practice emphasis). Students at this level can obtain the Fudan University graduate diploma and master's degree except in general practice after passing the final examination. Forty-eight people among 108 graduates were selected in the Shanghai Medical College of Fudan University in 2010. Another method of acquiring a master degree depends on scores that applicants receive on their national examinations. Students who are admitted to 5-year programs cannot automatically join the longer program after they receive their bachelor's degree. Instead, they must take a national examination for postgraduate study. If they receive a passing score along with an institutional recommendation, they can train for three additional years in research for a master's degree. In 2007, the Chinese National Degree Council set up the application system of family medicine for master's degrees. Some leading universities in the field of family medicine education in China, including the Shanghai Medical College of Fudan University, Capital Medical University, and Zhejiang University School of Medicine, really initiated the establishment of family medicine.9 However, the reality is that family medicine education is often delivered by public health lecturers who have never been formally trained in family medicine. As a result, most medical students have little constructive education in family medicine while in medical school.10 On May 7, 2012, the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Health held a joint national work conference on medical education reform and released "The Opinions of the Comprehensive Reform of Clinical Medicine Education," which put forward additional guidelines for the training of GPs. In order to train high-level GPs, the professional master's degree of clinical medicine in general medicine will be established in 2013. On-job training For training of GPs, standard training is the core of the general practice medical education system. It also provides the highest quality of training for GPs. Because of the current circumstances, standard training of GPs is limited to only a few developed areas. By the end of 2011, although only about 2 000 GPs were trained per year, more than 20 provinces had carried out the training. On-job training is the response to "The Guideline on the Education of General Practice" issued by the Ministry of Health. It is being adopted to increase the number of GPs that can be successfully trained. The trainees from grassroots medical and health institutions were given 600 cycles of parttime training, including introduction to general practice, general practice and community health service, medical treatment, disease prevention, health care, health education, rehabilitation, and other aspects of traditional Chinese medicine.11 They have clinical knowledge and practical experience, can grasp the clinical techniques easily, but usually lack the "people-skills" required for successful general practice. Problems in general practice training In China, general medical education has continued to evolve over the past 30 years to create the standard Chinese general practice education system and training model. According to "The Guidelines for Establishing GP's Professional System," the "one mode, two patterns, three facets of unification" will be gradually implemented (Table 2). Additionally, teachers of general practice have been recruited, and more than 1 000 specialty doctors have now been trained in general practice at the Center of General Practice Training of Ministry of Health in 2005. In 20 provinces and municipalities, courses and rotations conducted over a 10-month period were designed to train teachers in general practice.12 Despite significant improvements in general medicine education, there is still plenty of room for further improvements.Table 2: The general practitioner's professional systemShortage of high-quality general practitioners According to the international criteria, there should be 1 GP for every 5 000 residents. Thus, there should be at least 100 000 GPs in China, the country of 500 million city dwellers. Despite these recommendations, the proportion of GPs in China is only about 5%.13 The data provided by the Ministry of Health showed that there were only 78 000 GPs registered in China. However, from 2006 to 2009, 2 102 people participated in standard training, and 200 000 participated in on-job training. Where did these trainees wind up? Some stayed in comprehensive hospitals and some became specialists. Thus, it is not only the training of GPs that is an issue, but it is also keeping individuals in the field of general medicine which is a problem. In order to adapt to China's national conditions, on-thejob training is being adopted to increase the number of GPs. However, this is not enough to completely improve the level of clinical practice and quality of service of those doctors after short-term training. Shortage of high-quality teachers and outpatient treatment experience Lack of teachers is an important factor limiting general practice training. A team of general practice teachers has been created by the Ministry of Health in China.14 Unfortunately, teachers with comprehensive knowledge of general practice are rare. Another problem is that after training, many teachers returned to their jobs and did not become GPs. Many times, training is performed at comprehensive teaching hospitals, most times at the inpatient level. Trainees typically see patients with relatively uncommon and complicated disorders. However, GPs who work at the community level need outpatient experience of common disorders after certification. Because of their lack of outpatient experience, GPs may be confused regarding patient/disease management. Outpatient experiences at different healthcare levels must take place in general practice training. In addition to ethics, communication skills, critical thinking, scientific research planning and statistics, health management, and economics should be included in the standard training process. Advice on grneral practice training Increase the attraction of general medicine The terms "general medicine" and "general practitioner" are not usually understood by the public. This low societal status is likely damaging the future of general medicine in our country. This limits not only the sources of GPs, but also on-job enthusiasm of GPs. General medicine must be considered alongside medical specialties and helps establish a solid connection between doctors and patients. Importantly, GPs, especially those receiving "5+3" training, can manage a wide array of medical problems. Improving the treatment of general practitioners The average salary of GPs in Sweden is 2.2 times the national average. Similarly, salaries of GPs are 4.2 times higher than the national average in the United Kingdom, 3.3–3.7 times higher in the United States, and four times higher in Australia. In contrast, the income of GPs in China is relatively low. Only about half of the doctors work in comprehensive hospitals. After graduation, students face many practical issues, such as getting married.15 Three years of standard training is time consuming. This, coupled with poor treatment and low social status, prevents many undergraduate students from choosing a career in general practice. Strengthen the construction of general teachers At present, selection and training of general practice teachers is a necessity in China. Whether in the early or mature stages of development of general practice, specialists play an important role;16 many of them are trained in general practice and can become valuable teachers. The most important changes should be based on the needs of the community. Those interested in general practice can be sent abroad to take part in regular community health services and to carry out academic communication and examination.17 Adopt a system to make general practice a first option "Gatekeeping" means mandated referral by a GP. Thus, patients do not have direct access to specialists. Evidence from western medicine shows that highly trained GPs can manage 80% of patients without the involvement of specialists. Shenzhen Hospital affiliated with the Hong Kong University pioneered the "general practitioner first option of outpatient service." The Shanghai Government encourages residents to be under the care of a GP and set up "green channel" between generalist and specialist. General medicine was developed to improve the deficiencies of specialized medicine. However, only a "gatekeeping" system can truly promote the development of general medicine.