Abstract:Measurement of DNA contents of genomes is valuable for understanding genome biology, including assessments of genome assemblies, but it is not a trivial problem. Measuring contents of DNA shotgun reads is complicated by several factors: biological contents of genomes at species, individual and tissue or cell levels, laboratory methods, sequencing technology and computational processing for measurement and assembly. This compares, and shares, complications with cytometric (Cym) and related molecular measurements of genome size and contents. There is an obvious discrepancy between cytometric measurements and current long-read genome assemblies (Asm): genome assemblies average 12% below Cym measured sizes, differing in amounts of duplicated content. This report examines five DNA read types to see if they can be used for more precise and reliable discrimination of major genome contents and sizes. The read types are short, accurate Illumina, long Pacific Biosciences, of low and high accuracy, and long Oxford Nanopore Technology of low and high accuracy. Gnodes is the measurement tool used, which maps DNA to assembly, and measures DNA copy numbers for major genome contents of genes, transposons, repeats, and others, using as a measurement unit the single copies of unique conserved genes. Public data of five well studied genomes, human, corn, zebrafish, sorghum and rice, are used for the primary evidence of this work. Results of this are mixed and open to interpretations: In broad terms, all DNA types measure about the same genome contents, at or below 90% agreement, which is a level that the other complications can contribute. For precision above a 90% level, long read types differ in supporting larger cytometric sizes (low accuracy reads), or smaller assembly sizes (high accuracy reads), with accurate short-reads roughly between. The weight of evidence suggests that low accuracy long reads are less biased for genome measurement, that high accuracy long reads have a bias of reduced duplications introduced by computational averaging or filtering. The several complicating factors noted can produce discrepancies larger than this average Cym - Asm difference, and are a problem to control.

Mapping-based genome size estimation

LocoGSE, a sequence-based genome size estimator for plants

Genome size estimation from long read overlaps

Genome size and chromosome number are critical metrics for accurate genome assembly assessment in Eukaryota

genomesizeR: An R package for genome size prediction

Estimation of genomic characteristics by analyzing k-mer frequency in de novo genome projects

Whole Genome Mapping with Feature Sets from High-Throughput Sequencing Data

Arrayome: A Program for Estimating the Sizes of Microarray-Visualized Bacterial Genomes

A high-precision genome size estimator based on the k-mer histogram correction

Findgsep: Estimating Genome Size of Polyploid Species Using K-Mer Frequencies

Estimating the total genome length of a metagenomic sample using k-mers

Estimating chromosome sizes from karyotype images enables validation of de novo assemblies

Estimation of Genome Sizes of Speranskia tuberculata and Speranskia cantonensis

An Integrated Physical and Genetic Map of the Rice Genome.

A physical map of the human genome

Re-calibration of flow cytometry standards for plant genome size estimation

Analysis of Plant Pan-Genomes and Transcriptomes with GET_HOMOLOGUES-EST, a Clustering Solution for Sequences of the Same Species

Measuring DNA contents of animal and plant genomes with Gnodes, the long and short of it.

A 4-Gigabase Physical Map Unlocks The Structure And Evolution Of The Complex Genome Of Aegilops Tauschii, The Wheat D-Genome Progenitor

From Gigabyte to Kilobyte

Estimation of genome size using k-mer frequencies from corrected long reads