A Normative Chart for Cognitive Development in a Genetically Selected Population

Ania M. Fiksinski,Carrie E. Bearden,Anne S. Bassett,René S. Kahn,Janneke R. Zinkstok,Stephen R. Hooper,Wanda Tempelaar,Donna McDonald-McGinn,Ann Swillen,Beverly Emanuel,Bernice Morrow,Raquel Gur,Eva Chow,Marianne van den Bree,Joris Vermeesch,Stephen Warren,Michael Owen,Therese van Amelsvoort,Stephan Eliez,Doron Gothelf,Celso Arango,Wendy Kates,Tony Simon,Kieran Murphy,Gabriela Repetto,Damian Heine Suner,Stefano Vicari,Joseph Cubells,Marco Armando,Nicole Philip,Linda Campbell,Sixto Garcia-Minaur,Maude Schneider,Vandana Shashi,Jacob Vorstman,Elemi J. Breetvelt
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41386-021-00988-6
2021-01-01
Neuropsychopharmacology
Abstract:Certain pathogenic genetic variants impact neurodevelopment and cause deviations from typical cognitive trajectories. Understanding variant-specific cognitive trajectories is clinically important for informed monitoring and identifying patients at risk for comorbid conditions. Here, we demonstrate a variant-specific normative chart for cognitive development for individuals with 22q11.2 deletion syndrome (22q11DS). We used IQ data from 1365 individuals with 22q11DS to construct variant-specific normative charts for cognitive development (Full Scale, Verbal, and Performance IQ). This allowed us to calculate Z-scores for each IQ datapoint. Then, we calculated the change between first and last available IQ assessments (delta Z-IQ-scores) for each individual with longitudinal IQ data (n = 708). We subsequently investigated whether using the variant-specific IQ-Z-scores would decrease required sample size to detect an effect with schizophrenia risk, as compared to standard IQ-scores. The mean Z-IQ-scores for FSIQ, VIQ, and PIQ were close to 0, indicating that participants had IQ-scores as predicted by the normative chart. The mean delta-Z-IQ-scores were equally close to 0, demonstrating a good fit of the normative chart and indicating that, as a group, individuals with 22q11DS show a decline in IQ-scores as they grow into adulthood. Using variant-specific IQ-Z-scores resulted in 30% decrease of required sample size, as compared to the standard IQ-based approach, to detect the association between IQ-decline and schizophrenia (p < 0.01). Our findings suggest that using variant-specific normative IQ data significantly reduces required sample size in a research context, and may facilitate a more clinically informative interpretation of IQ data. This approach allows identification of individuals that deviate from their expected, variant-specific, trajectory. This group may be at increased risk for comorbid conditions, such as schizophrenia in the case of 22q11DS.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?