Abstract:NUREG report CR-6909 [1] proposed in 2007 new rules for evaluating environmental effects in fatigue analyses of new reactors components. These new rules, based on simple correlations, consider that Fen penalty factors (ratio of fatigue life in air at room temperature to that in water at service temperature) are mainly function of strain rate, temperature, sulfur content and dissolved oxygen concentrations. In order to evaluate the conservatisms included in the NUREG report CR-6909, discriminating Low Cycle Fatigue (LCF) tests were performed on a 304L austenitic stainless steel in PWR environment using various modified loading signals deduced from a representative loading strain history as close as possible to actual transients. Using the strain rate integral method recommended in the NUREG/CR-6909, the expected Fen penalty factors evaluated for each modified representative loading signal was close to 6, while the experimental Fen penalty factors measured were strongly dependent of the shape of the loading signals. Experimental Fen penalty factors obtained for the various modified loading signals vary from ∼ 1.5 to ∼ 4. These discriminating LCF tests performed on polished specimens demonstrate that the detailed strain integral method cannot correctly predict the actual environmental effects for the various shapes of loading signals deduced from a representative loading strain history. Other LCF tests were also performed for various constant strain amplitudes using fully reverse triangle signals for comparison purpose with tests performed by other laboratories. It appears that, contrary to published results, environmental effects decrease when the strain amplitude decreases from 0.6% until 0.2%. In the case of the strain amplitude of 0.6%, the Fen penalty factor formulation proposed in the NUREG report CR-6909 is accurate while, for lower strain amplitude of 0.2%, the Fen penalty factor formulation is very severe. It appears that the application of the NUREG/CR-6909 including the Fen model proposed by ANL (Argonne National Laboratory) for austenitic stainless steel provides excessive margins compared to penalty factors as observed experimentally. From this experimental program, conservatisms included in the NUREG/CR-6909 methodology appear to be excessive and can lead to fatigue design issues.

Environmental Fatigue Correction Factor Model for Domestic Nuclear-Grade Low-Alloy Steel

Corrosion Fatigue Mechanism of Nuclear-Grade Low Alloy Steel in High Temperature Pressurized Water and Its Environmental Fatigue Design Model

Environmentally Assisted Fatigue Evaluation Model of Alloy 690 Steam Generator Tube in High-Temperature Water

CORROSION FATIGUE OF NUCLEAR-GRADE STAIN- LESS STEEL IN HIGH TEMPERATURE WATER AND ITS ENVIRONMENTAL FATIGUE DESIGN MODEL

Corrosion Fatigue Model of Austenitic Stainless Steels Used in Pressurized Water Reactor Nuclear Power Plants

An Approach to Estimate the Low Cycle Fatigue Probabilistic Curves of PBF-LB/M 316L Steel from Small Size Datasets Using the Remora Optimization Algorithm

Characterization of Low Cycle Fatigue Performance of New Ferritic P92 Steel at High Temperature: Effect of Strain Amplitude

Fatigue model of domestic 316LN steel in simulated primary coolant environment of CAP1400

Low Cycle Fatigue Behavior of Original Ferritic P92 Steel at High Temperature: Experiments and Simulations

Fatigue life modeling for a low alloy steel after long-term thermal aging

A New Empirical Life Prediction Model For 9-12%Cr Steels Under Low Cycle Fatigue And Creep Fatigue Interaction Loadings

Effects of Loading Factors on Environmental Fatigue Behavior of Low-Alloy Pressure Vessel Steels in Simulated Bwr Water

A REVIEW OF CORROSION FATIGUE OF STEELS FOR LWR PLANT IN HIGH TEMPERATURE AND HIGH PRESSURE WATER

Effect of Loading Signal Shape and of Surface Finish on the Low Cycle Fatigue Behavior of 304L Stainless Steel in PWR Environment

Experimental and Numerical Study of Combined High and Low Cycle Fatigue Performance of Low Alloy Steel and Engineering Application

Assessment of Environmental Fatigue in Nuclear Power Plants: A Comparative Analysis of the Effects of Plasticity Correction

Corrosion Fatigue Behavior of 316LN Stainless Steel Hollow Specimen in High-Temperature Pressurized Water

Environmentally Assisted Fatigue Behavior of 308L Weld Metal in Borated and Lithiated High-Temperature Water

The dynamic compressive behavior and constitutive model of SA508-3 steel at high strain rates under elevated temperatures

A general energy-based model for fatigue life prediction of high-temperature structural materials

Synergistic Effect of Mechanical and Environmental Damages of 316LN Stainless Steel under Different Fatigue Strain Amplitudes in High-Temperature Pressurized Water