Abstract:A number of hydrological studies have proven the superior prediction performance of hybrid models coupled with data preprocessing techniques. However, many studies first decompose the entire data series into components and later divide each component into calibration and validation datasets to establish models, which sends some amount of future information into the decomposition and reconstruction processes. As a consequence, the resulting components used to forecast the value of a particular moment are computed using information from future values, which are not available at that particular moment in a forecasting exercise. Since most papers don't present their model framework in detail, it is difficult to identify whether they are performing a real forecast or not. Even though several other papers have explicitly stated which experiment they are performing, a comparison between results in the hindcast and forecast experiments is still missing. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate and compare the performance of these hybrid models in the two experiments in order to estimate whether they are suitable for real forecasting. With the combination of three preprocessing techniques, such as wavelet analysis (WA), empirical mode decomposition (EMD) and singular spectrum analysis (SSA), and two modeling methods (i.e. ANN model and ARMA model), six hybrid models are developed in this study, including WA-ANN, WA-ARMA, EMD-ANN, EMD-ARMA, SSA-ANN and SSA-ARMA. Preprocessing techniques are used to decompose the data series into sub-series, and then these sub-series are modeled using ANN and ARMA models. These models are examined in hindcasting and forecasting of the monthly streamflow of two sites in the Yangtze River of China. The results of this study indicate that the six hybrid models perform better in the hindcast experiment compared with the original ANN and ARMA models, while the hybrid models in the forecast experiment perform worse than the original models and the performances of WA-based and EMD-based models vary largely across different extension methods. It can be concluded that the hybrid models are not suitable for monthly streamflow forecasting in this study. New extension methods and modified preprocessing techniques can improve the prediction performance of these hybrid models in forecast experiments. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

An Innovative Hourly Water Demand Forecasting Preprocessing Framework with Local Outlier Correction and Adaptive Decomposition Techniques

Study of Artificial Neural Network Model for Forecasting Urban Water Demand

Daily water supply prediction method based on integrated learning and deep learning

Hourly and Daily Urban Water Demand Predictions Using a Long Short-Term Memory Based Model

Short-term Water Demand Forecast Based on Automatic Feature Extraction by One-Dimensional Convolution

A Framework for Forecasting the Hourly Nodal Water Demand and Improving the Performance of Real-Time Hydraulic Models Considering Model Uncertainty

Evaluating the Performance of Several Data Preprocessing Methods Based on GRU in Forecasting Monthly Runoff Time Series

A Hybrid Framework for Multivariate Time Series Forecasting of Daily Urban Water Demand Using Attention-Based Convolutional Neural Network and Long Short-Term Memory Network

A Fine Grained Forecasting Method for Minute-Level Urban Water Demand

Multivariable Time Series Forecasting for Urban Water Demand Based on Temporal Convolutional Network Combining Random Forest Feature Selection and Discrete Wavelet Transform

Forecasting Short-term Water Demands with an Ensemble Deep Learning Model for a Water Supply System

A Hybrid Wavelet-CNN-LSTM Deep Learning Model for Short-Term Urban Water Demand Forecasting

Water Demand Forecasting in Multiple District Metered Areas Based on a Multi-Scale Correction Module Neural Network Architecture

Short-Term Water Demand Forecasting Using Machine Learning Approaches in a Case Study of a Water Distribution Network Located in Italy

Deep Learning with Long Short-Term Memory Neural Networks Combining Wavelet Transform and Principal Component Analysis for Daily Urban Water Demand Forecasting

Reliable multi-horizon water demand forecasting model: A temporal deep learning approach

Evaluating a Coupled Discrete Wavelet Transform and Support Vector Regression for Daily and Monthly Streamflow Forecasting

Are Hybrid Models Integrated with Data Preprocessing Techniques Suitable for Monthly Streamflow Forecasting? Some Experiment Evidences

Short-term Demand Forecasting for Distributed Water Supply Networks: A Multi-Scale Approach

Research on urban water demand prediction based on machine learning and feature engineering

Study on water quantity prediction method based on bidirectional long and short time neural network