On Identiifcation Criteria of Regulatory Taking--Centering on German and American Theories and Their Judicial Precedents

Hua LIN,Qi YU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-0078.2013.04.018

2013-01-01

Administrative law review

Abstract:Whether the limitation formed by a certain measure of the state to citizens’ property right on earth belongs to the social obligation of the property right or regulatory taking is of great importance, because it relates to whether the state needs to provide certain compensation for it. Through the investigation of relevant German and American theories and judicial precedents, the distinguishing standard of them can mainly be divided into two aspects of form and essence. The form standard bases on principle of equality and emphasizes on‘special sacriifce’;while the essence standard is based on the form standard and distinguishes different degrees of regulatory measures’ limitation to the property right. Generally speaking, under the condition of counterpart’s special sacriifce, only when the government embezzles the counterpart’s property or leads to the total loss of the counterpart’s property value can this be judged as regulatory taking by courts.