Regulating the Use of Electronic Evidence in Chinese Courts: Legislative Efforts, Academic Debates and Practical Applications
Zhiyuan Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clsr.2022.105774
IF: 2.707
2022-01-01
Computer Law & Security Review
Abstract:With the rapid development of science and technology, especially the popularization of the internet and social media, electronic evidence such as e-mails, blog posters, instant mes-sages, electronic trading records, communication records, and logon logs has become a new addition to the evidence family all over the world. China officially recognized electronic data as one of its legal evidence categories in 2012 when the Criminal Procedure Law and the Civil Procedure Law were revised.1 It is commonly held that the use of this new evidence should follow different evidential rules because electronic data has some different features than other traditional evidence. To regulate the use of electronic evidence in criminal cases, the Chinese Supreme People's Court (SPC), Supreme People's Procuratorate (SPP) and Ministry of Public Security (MPS) jointly issued the Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Col-lection, Taking, Examination, and Judgment of Electronic Data in the Handling of Criminal Cases in 2016. The Ministry of Public Security then issued a more detailed Rules of Obtain-ment of Electronic Data as Evidence in 2019, trying to solve practical problems encountered in collecting, taking, and inspecting electronic data. The SPC included some new provisions on using electronic evidence in handling civil cases when it revised the Civil Evidence Rules in 2019. These legal documents not only provide a general legal framework for using electronic evidence in both civil and criminal proceedings, but also provide helpful technical guidance and procedural rules on collecting and examining digital evidence. However, very few law researchers in China conduct in-depth research on this topic due to its interdisciplinary na-ture between law and technology, let alone English literature. This paper tries to overview the key issues on the collection, taking, examination and judgement of electronic evidence in criminal and civil cases, identify the weak points of current legislation, and put forward some legislative proposals for future reforms.(c) 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.