The Application of Discrete Choice Model to the Analysis of Product Difference

袁诚

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-4565.2003.01.014

2003-01-01

Abstract:The paper introduces to the application of three scatter choosing model to describe consumer's choice, thereby to conduct the demand analysis by using the consumers' materials and the cross section materials of market quotation.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Analysis of Dynamic Travel Mode Choice: A Heterogeneous Hidden Markov Approach

Chenfeng Xiong,Xiqun Chen,Xiang He,Wei Guo,Lei Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-015-9658-2

IF: 4.814

2015-01-01

Transportation

Abstract:Discrete choices are often analyzed statically. The limitations of static models become more obvious when employing them in more long-term travel demand forecasting. The research gap lies in a theoretical model which is dynamically formulated, and in readily available longitudinal data sources. To address this, a heterogeneous hidden Markov modeling approach (HMM) is proposed in this paper to model dynamic discrete choices. Both longitudinal and cross-sectional heterogeneity are considered. The approach is demonstrated on a travel mode choice application using ten-wave Puget Sound Transport Panel data coupled with some other supplementary data sources. Results indicate that travelers’ long-term life-cycle stages have an enduring impact when shifted to different mode choice states, wherein sensitivities to travel time and cost vary. Empirical results are put in line with static discrete choice models. The paper demonstrates that the family of HMM models provide the best fitting model. The dynamic model has superior explanatory power in fitting longitudinal data and thus shall provide more accurate estimates for planning and policy analyses. The proposed approach can be generalized to study other short/mid-term travel behavior. The estimated model can be easily calibrated and transferred for applications elsewhere.
Research on The Theoretical Basis and Evolution of Discrete Choice Models

聂冲,贾生华

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-3894.2005.11.016

2005-01-01

Abstract:The boom of discrete choice models , which belong to the area of microeconometrics,were really beginning from the end of 1950s.The models can be used to analyse the behaviors of private and family experientially, and they are widely applied to economics and other social sciences. This paper begins with the theoretical basis and utility maximization, then demonstrates that there are three limitations of logit: it can not represent random taste variation; it implies proportional substitution across alternatives and cannot handle situations where unobserved factors are correlated over time, though logit is by far the easiest and most widely used discrete choice model. Other models, such as GEV (including nested logit), probit and mixed logit, have arisen largely to avoid these limitations.
Incorporating Reference Products into Modeling Consumer Choice Decision: A Mixtures-of-experts Model.

Ping Wang,Luping Sun,Rakesh Niraj,Jaihak Chung,Meng Su

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dss.2019.02.002

IF: 6.969

2019-01-01

Decision Support Systems

Abstract:Understanding the process of consumer decision making is important for many decision support systems. Consumers evaluate different alternatives and then come to a decision. Prior research suggests that consumer evaluations leading to choice are comparative in nature and can be affected by other alternatives or reference products. This study proposes a mixtures-of-experts model framework to examine the role of different reference products in consumer choice of multi-attribute products. While multiple external and internal reference points have been proposed, previous studies have very rarely investigated more than one reference point in the same model. Using data from a choice-based conjoint experiment, our empirical model enables us to identify which product consumers tend to use as the reference product by incorporating four different reference products and includes consumer characteristics to examine how consumers differ in their utilization of different reference products. The results show that our model outperforms other reference-dependent models in prior literature. In our empirical context of smartphone choices, the most commonly used reference product is the most preferred product in the choice set, while the least preferred product and the average product are rarely used. We also examine the role of consumer characteristics such as gender, product familiarity, and product interest in utilizing reference products. This paper provides insights into the unobserved comparison process in consumer choice, which can be applied to decision support systems such as recommendation engines.
The Analysis Framework Of Housing Demand: Comparison Among Three Views

Xiaoyu Guo,Shenghua Jia

2007-01-01

Abstract:According to the different descriptions of housing, this article reviews the analysis framework used in housing demand research. We find that, based on the neoclassical consumer behavior theory, the scholars construct utility functions and budget restrictions, and then get demand functions through maximizing course. Following the theoretical analysis are econometric modeling and parameter estimating. This framework has been stable and almost unchanged for more than half a century. While the research progresses have been achieved principally by the improvements of data quality and analysis techniques, such as modeling and variable specification.
A HYBRID DISCRETE CHOICE MODEL OF DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCT DEMAND WITH AN APPLICATION TO PERSONAL COMPUTERS

Minjae Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/iere.12102

IF: 1.418

2015-01-23

International Economic Review

Abstract:In this article, I consider a new discrete choice model of differentiated product demand that distinguishes a brand‐level differentiation from a product‐level differentiation. The model is a hybrid of the random coefficient logit model of Berry et al. (Econometrica 63 (1995), 841–90) and the pure characteristics model of Berry and Pakes (International Economic Review 48 (2007), 1193–1225) and describes markets where firms offer multiple products of different qualities under the same brand name. I compare the hybrid model with existing models using data on personal computers. Using the estimates of the hybrid model, I also provide empirical evidence that firms reposition their brands in a postmerger market.
Analysis of Discrete Choice Models: A Welfare-Based Framework

Guiyun Feng,Xiaobo Li,Zizhuo Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1503.01854

2015-03-06

Optimization and Control

Abstract:Based on the observation that many existing discrete choice models admit a welfare function of utilities whose gradient gives the choice probability vector, we propose a new representation of discrete choice model which we call the welfare-based choice model. The welfare-based choice model is meaningful on its own by providing a new way of constructing choice models. More importantly, it provides great analysis convenience for establishing connections among existing choice models. We prove by using convex analysis theory, that the welfare-based choice model is equivalent to the representative agent choice model and the semi-parametric choice model, establishing the equivalence of the latter two. We show that these three models are all strictly more general than the random utility model, while when there are only two alternatives, those four models are equivalent. In particular, we show that the distinction between the welfare-based choice model and the random utility model lies in the requirement of the higher-order derivatives of the welfare function. We then define a new concept in choice models: substitutability/complementarity between alternatives. We show that the random utility model only allows substitutability between different alternatives; while the welfare-based choice model allows flexible substitutability/complementarity patterns. We argue that such flexibility could be desirable in capturing certain practical choice patterns and expanding the scope of discrete choice models. Examples are given of new choice models proposed under our framework.
Research on the Influence of Time-honored Cross-border Product Market Matching Degree on Purchase Intention

Xu Yang,Li Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/fbem.v7i1.3967

2022-12-26

Abstract:With the development of society, the old brand face more consumer diversification demand and fierce market competition leads to the trend of product homogeneity, in order to ensure their products or service advantage, bring new added value, then began the "crossover" mode, use this way to bring consumers three-dimensional experience and demand, to enhance consumer brand awareness. This paper mainly uses the way of combining theory with empirical evidence to conduct analysis and research. The sorting and induction of cross-border products, market matching degree, brand recognition and purchase intention of old brands are made, the model research structure is determined, and the relationship between the cross-border market matching degree of time-honored brands and the purchase intention of the cross-border product is constructed. The intermediary variable introduces brand cognition and proposes assumptions. Then, a reasonable scale was developed based on other literature and the characteristics of the research object, and a questionnaire survey was used for data collection. Finally, the study used SPSS22.0, AMOS and other software to verify the proposed hypotheses, draw conclusions, and make relevant suggestions.
Mode choice behavior analysis by using a semi-compensatory discrete choice model

Chong Wei,Lin Xiao,Chunfu Shao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.838-841.3300

2014-01-01

Abstract:In this study we proposed a semi-compensatory model to analyze the mode choice behavior. The proposed model formulated the conjunctive rule through. a straightforward way. The proposed model can take into account the probability distribution of the threshold involved by the conjunctive rule. To estimate the parameters of the proposed model, we derived the posterior distribution of the parameters by using the Baye's theorem and developed a blacked Metropolis-Hastings algorithm to carry out the estimation based on the posterior distribution. We also employed the data augmentation technology to simplify the estimation procedure. The proposed model was validated by using a SP survey dataset. We compared the performance of the proposed model to that of the logit model.
Choice Models and Permutation Invariance: Demand Estimation in Differentiated Products Markets

Amandeep Singh,Ye Liu,Hema Yoganarasimhan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2307.07090

2024-02-20

Abstract:Choice modeling is at the core of understanding how changes to the competitive landscape affect consumer choices and reshape market equilibria. In this paper, we propose a fundamental characterization of choice functions that encompasses a wide variety of extant choice models. We demonstrate how non-parametric estimators like neural nets can easily approximate such functionals and overcome the curse of dimensionality that is inherent in the non-parametric estimation of choice functions. We demonstrate through extensive simulations that our proposed functionals can flexibly capture underlying consumer behavior in a completely data-driven fashion and outperform traditional parametric models. As demand settings often exhibit endogenous features, we extend our framework to incorporate estimation under endogenous features. Further, we also describe a formal inference procedure to construct valid confidence intervals on objects of interest like price elasticity. Finally, to assess the practical applicability of our estimator, we utilize a real-world dataset from S. Berry, Levinsohn, and Pakes (1995). Our empirical analysis confirms that the estimator generates realistic and comparable own- and cross-price elasticities that are consistent with the observations reported in the existing literature.

Econometrics,Machine Learning
A Fuzzy Set Model of Search and Consideration with an Application to an Online Market

Jianan Wu,Arvind Rangaswamy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.22.3.411.17738

2003-08-01

Marketing Science

Abstract:Several two–stage choice models (consideration stage plus choice stage) have been proposed in the marketing literature. We extend this literature by developing a more general model that incorporates how consumer search influences the degree to which they consider various brands. To test the validity and value of our model, we operationalized it with data obtained from Peapod, an online grocer, where we tracked consumers’ search processes. We demonstrate that our model performs better than competing models on all the key criteria. New choice models, such as the ones proposed here, are necessary for deriving managerially relevant understanding of choice behavior in online markets. Our empirical results suggest that consumers search both their internal memory and external information at the store to determine the degree to which they consider various brands. Consumers are also heterogeneous with respect to their capability to process external information. For some consumers, external information search dramatically increases the degree to which they consider various brands; but, for others, it has little impact on their consideration. We also find that certain features (e.g., personal lists) reduce consideration set sizes, whereas other features (e.g., sort) increase consideration set sizes.

business
Recent developments of consumer behavior stochastic models

杜荣,胡奇英

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-2400.2004.01.026

2004-01-01

Journal of Xidian University

Abstract:This paper makes a survey of recent developments in the area of consumer behavior stochastic modeling. We first outline some basic models including category choice, brand choice, and purchasing incidence models. Then, we formulate in detail some newly extended models for brand choice and purchasing rate, including the negative bi-nomial model and the Markovian model introducing explanory variables, the Markovian model introducing variety seeking, brand choice models considering dynamic consumer preferences and product attributes, the cyclical choice model and the household choice model, buying incidence models introducing explanory variables and consumer heterogeneity, and the comprehensive model integrating brand choice with buying incidence. Furthermore, we analyze the particular characteristics and common natures of the above mentioned extended models. After that, we point out the new trends of consumer behavior stochastic models. Finally, we conclude the survey by posing several problems needed to be studied further.
Modeling Spatiotemporal Heterogeneity of Customer Preferences With Small-Scale Aggregated Data: A Spatial Panel Modeling Approach

Yuyang Chen,Youyi Bi,Jian Xie,Zhenghui Sha,Mingxian Wang,Yan Fu,Wei Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4065211

IF: 2.3

2024-04-16

Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering

Abstract:Abstract Customer preferences are found to evolve over time and correlate with geographical locations. Studying the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of customer preferences is crucial to engineering design as it provides a dynamic perspective for understanding the trend of customer preferences. However, existing choice models for demand modeling do not take the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of customer preferences into consideration. Learning-based spatiotemporal data modeling methods usually require large-scale datasets for model training, which are not applicable to small aggregated data, such as the sale records of a product in several regions and years. To fill this research gap, we propose a spatial panel modeling approach to investigate the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of customer preferences. Product and regional attributes varying in time are included as model inputs to support demand forecasting in engineering design. With case studies using the dataset of small SUVs and compact sedans in China's automotive market, we demonstrate that the spatial panel modeling approach outperforms other statistical spatiotemporal data models and non-parametric regression methods in goodness of fit and prediction accuracy. We also illustrate a potential design application of the proposed approach in a portfolio optimization of two vehicles from the same producer. While the spatial panel modeling approach exists in econometrics, applying this approach to support engineering decisions by considering spatiotemporal heterogeneity and introducing engineering attributes in demand forecasting is the contribution of this work. Our paper is focused on presenting the approach rather than the results per se.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, manufacturing
Analysis of Cognitive Differences and Reasons Between Domestic and Imported Products with the Same Brand for Chinese Consumers

YUAN Sheng-jun,FU Guo-qun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-8409.2012.06.015

2012-01-01

Soft Science

Abstract:Based on literatures review and according to the network topic,this paper studies the reason of cognitive differences between domestic and with the same brand for Chinese consumers with the method of content analysis.The results show that:① over time,the Chinese consumers' cognitive strength for imported are better than domestic products show a downward trend;②for the product evaluated,richer knowledge of Chinese consumers,they have lower cognitive strength for imported are better than domestic products.
Differential Pricing Decision and Coordination of Green Electronic Products from the Perspective of Service Heterogeneity

Xiaodong Zhu,Lingfei Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/app8071207

2018-07-23

Applied Sciences

Abstract:Consumers focus on level of service while purchasing electronic products. This study focuses on consumer buying behavior. We determine the Stackelberg outcome for a market when a durable electronic product has three different forms: new product, remanufactured product and refurbished product. Under the dynamic game model, the optimal differential pricing strategy is implemented, and the double marginal effect is coordinated through a revenue-sharing contract and two toll contracts to increase the system’s revenue capacity. Our research shows that as the degree of consumer preference increases, the service differentiation of the three products is reduced. A lower level of consumer preference affects the pricing decision of new products and significantly affects the pricing of remanufactured products and refurbished products.
Discrete Choice Analysis: Theory and Application to Travel Demand

M. Ben-Akiva,S. Lerman

1985-12-18

Abstract:This book, which is intended as a graduate level text and a general professional reference, presents the methods of discrete choice analysis and their applications in the modeling of transportation systems. The first seven chapters provide a basic introduction to discrete choice analysis that covers the material needed to apply basic binary and multiple choice models. The chapters are as follows: introduction; review of the statistics of model estimation; theories of individual choice behavior; binary choice models; multinomial choice; aggregate forecasting techniques; and tests and practical issues in developing discrete choice models. The rest of the chapters cover more advanced material and culminate in the development of a complete travel demand model system presented in chapter 11. The advanced chapters are as follows: theory of sampling; aggregation and sampling of alternatives; models of multidimensional choice and the nested logit model; and systems of models. The last chapter (12) presents an overview of current research frontiers.

Economics,Computer Science,Business,Engineering
Modeling Store Choices with Cross-Sectional and Pooled Cross-Sectional Data: A Comparison

J-C Thill

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1068/a271303

1995-08-01

Abstract:Contrary to many other types of spatial decisions, shopping destination choice behavior is highly repetitive. For the practitioner looking for good predictors of store patronage, for reliable marginal utility estimates and reliable market share predictions, a central concern is with the type of data best suited to the research question, given the existing logistic and financial constraints. Different approaches can be recognized in the literature in which conventional discrete choice models are applied to shopping destination choice problems. In this paper, two of the most common practices are assessed and compared. First, the choice model is estimated with all choices of a relevant destination observed during a certain period of time (pooled cross-sectional data). The alternative approach consists in an estimation with the choice of the destination where the majority of purchases takes place (cross-sectional data). In the particular data set employed here, no evidence is found to support the idea that a multinomial logit model estimated with cross-sectional data does not perform as well as a model estimated with pooled cross-sectional data. Both models are found to be similar in their ability to identity the main predictors of store choice. Models developed on either data sets have marginal utility estimates that exhibit no statistically significant differences. Finally, market share predictions derived from both models are not statistically different. It appears, therefore, that there is no need to collect repeated patronage data over an extended period of time. The practitioner who wishes to use a conventional discrete choice model may avoid spending much time and money by gathering limited data on regular patronage patterns. In addition to this practical implication, the conclusions suggest that regular shopping destinations are chosen in accordance with the same behavioral motives as ancillary destinations are.
Discrete Choice Modelling of Urban Housing Markets: A Critical Review and an Application

Judith Yates,Daniel F. Mackay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00420980500533695

2006-03-01

Urban Studies

Abstract:The housing choice literature is a vast area of housing research which has resulted in giant leaps forward in recent years in terms of its econometric modelling. This is due in large part to the significant increases now available in computing power allowing researchers to combine the latest advances in theory with empirical application. This paper brings together and critically reviews the housing choice literature and techniques that have been used to model the household's housing choice decision. The basic multinomial logit model is reviewed alongside the more recent advances in discrete choice modelling-the nested multinomial logit model and the heteroscedastic extreme value model. The various techniques are illustrated using data from the Australian census of 1986 and 1996 to model housing choice in Sydney. The results show that careful consideration must be given to the assumptions underlying any chosen modelling technique if one is not to draw misleading conclusions from the analysis.

environmental studies,urban studies
Product differentiation design under sequential consumer choice process

Xiao-Feng Shao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2014.951091

IF: 9.018

2014-09-09

International Journal of Production Research

Abstract:We consider a product variety design problem with respect to both vertical and horizontal differentiation dimensions under a sequential consumer choice process. Consumers have heterogeneous valuations for product quality as well as different preferences for product type. We consider two sequential consumer choice processes: a quality-based choice model where consumers consider product quality first and then product type, and a type-based choice model with the reversed order. Under the quality-based model, the category manager can either adopt vertical differentiation strategy or bi-dimensional differentiation strategy, whereas under the type-based model, the category manager can either adopt horizontal differentiation strategy or bi-dimensional differentiation strategy. We characterise the structure of optimal product category and prices for each product differentiation strategy and develop efficient algorithms for the quality-based consumer choice model. We find that under the quality-based choice model, vertical differentiation strategy is more profitable than bi-dimensional differentiation strategy, whereas under the type-based choice model, horizontal differentiation strategy is preferred over bi-dimensional differentiation strategy. The result is robust considering the impact of heterogeneity in consumer choice process. Thus, further differentiation in quality or type is actually not preferred when consumers follow a sequential consumer choice process.

engineering, manufacturing, industrial,operations research & management science
The application of the analyzing model for consumer relationship value

zhao minxiang,zhang daliang

2004-01-01

Abstract:This paper develops a set of measures to analyze and evaluate the customer relationship value (CRV) according to the diversity of different kinds of customer relationship by means of cash discounting method. As this set of measures calculates different kinds of customer relationship value aiming at different situations, it could indicate the CRV more exactly and pertinently, thus providing a basis for the enterprises to make decisions on marketing strategy. The value increment measures of customer combination management according to different spectrums of customers could be the good reference for enhancing the efficiency of marketing management.
A dynamic multiple-variety choice adaption model

zhongsheng hua,hingpo lo,geoffrey tso,lianlian song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03610918.2014.970695

2014-01-01

Communications in Statistics - Simulation and Computation

Abstract:The choice of a product on one purchase occasion by one consumer could be multiple varieties and influenced by past usage experience of this product. To mimic the real situation, this article proposes a new dynamic multiple-variety choice (DMC) model which incorporates quantitative and qualitative dynamics into an additive utility function. This model exhibits three major features of consumer purchase behavior: more than one variety purchased, learning behavior from use experience, and forgetting with the passage of time. All these are achieved by combining a simultaneous demand model with Bayesian learning theory embedded in an exponential function. The model is tested and validated using Hong Kong television viewing data. Empirical results show that including Bayesian learning in a multiple-choice model significantly improves model performance and prediction accuracy, and consideration of the effect of forgetting when studying learning behavior renders the Bayesian learning model much more accurate in practical application.

The Application of Discrete Choice Model to the Analysis of Product Difference

The Analysis of Dynamic Travel Mode Choice: A Heterogeneous Hidden Markov Approach

Research on The Theoretical Basis and Evolution of Discrete Choice Models

Incorporating Reference Products into Modeling Consumer Choice Decision: A Mixtures-of-experts Model.

The Analysis Framework Of Housing Demand: Comparison Among Three Views

A HYBRID DISCRETE CHOICE MODEL OF DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCT DEMAND WITH AN APPLICATION TO PERSONAL COMPUTERS

Analysis of Discrete Choice Models: A Welfare-Based Framework

Research on the Influence of Time-honored Cross-border Product Market Matching Degree on Purchase Intention

Mode choice behavior analysis by using a semi-compensatory discrete choice model

Choice Models and Permutation Invariance: Demand Estimation in Differentiated Products Markets

A Fuzzy Set Model of Search and Consideration with an Application to an Online Market

Recent developments of consumer behavior stochastic models

Modeling Spatiotemporal Heterogeneity of Customer Preferences With Small-Scale Aggregated Data: A Spatial Panel Modeling Approach

Analysis of Cognitive Differences and Reasons Between Domestic and Imported Products with the Same Brand for Chinese Consumers

Differential Pricing Decision and Coordination of Green Electronic Products from the Perspective of Service Heterogeneity

Discrete Choice Analysis: Theory and Application to Travel Demand

Modeling Store Choices with Cross-Sectional and Pooled Cross-Sectional Data: A Comparison

Discrete Choice Modelling of Urban Housing Markets: A Critical Review and an Application

Product differentiation design under sequential consumer choice process

The application of the analyzing model for consumer relationship value

A dynamic multiple-variety choice adaption model