Abstract:This panel was convened at 10:45 am, Friday, April 5, by its moderator, Wenhua Shan of Xi'an Jiaotong University, who introduced the panelists: Chen Fuli of the Ministry of Commerce, Embassy of China; Chen Huiping of the School of Law, Xiamen University; Mark Feldman of Peking University School of Transnational Law; and Won Kidane of Seattle University School of Law. * * Chen Fuli did not submit remarks for the Proceedings. REFLECTIONS ON CHINA-AFRICA BITS By Won Kidane ([dagger]) BACKGROUND The rise in the last decade of Chinese investment in Africa (1) continues to be a subject of curiosity. (2) Traditionally, the bulk of foreign investment flew North-South but rarely SouthSouth. (3) This is changing as China becomes an important player as a sender of foreign direct investment (FDI). In the 21st century, international investment agreements (IIAs), particularly bilateral investment treaties (BITs), have become the principal means of protection of foreign investment. (4) These investment treaties themselves lie along a spectrum representing the balance of power of their own era. Much like U.S. BITs, China's BITs are said to have gone through at least three generational modifications. (5) China has employed all three generations to protect its investment in Africa. Do China's BITs tell a story of a nation's rapid transformation from a recipient of FDI to a sender of FDI? Or do they paint a more complicated picture? China's approach to investment in Africa appears to be different from the approaches that Africa's traditional partners from Europe and North America have taken over the years. A 2010 UNCTAD report describes such difference in the following terms: [I]n contrast to Africa's relationship with traditional partners, the new partnerships ... often have established forums and dialogue platforms and are generally supported by frequent high-level official visits. Furthermore, they are based on the principle of noninterference in the internal affairs of partner countries. Consequently, they are not associated with policy conditionality as has been the case in relations with traditional partners. (6) The report states further that "[the] big Southern partners [mainly China] generally use official flows to promote trade and investment activities in Africa. Furthermore, Southern partners do not consider their financial contributions to other developing countries as aid. Rather they describe them as 'expressions of solidarity and cooperation borne out of shared experiences and sympathies.'" (7) Although the role of China's involvement in Africa remains a subject of great controversy and heated debate, (8) it is clear that Africa's recent and unprecedented growth is not entirely unrelated to Chinese investment and trade. (9) Be that as it may, China's economic interest in Africa is not all that different from Africa's traditional partners. Its means of pursuing the economic goals are also similar--although as Ambassador David Shinn puts it--China employs different tactics that might make it more acceptable to Africa. In his own words: [T]he United States and China use essentially the same political economic, military and cultural tools for implementing their relations with Africa. The emphasis the two sides place on these tactics, however, and the way they implement policy varies considerably. China presents itself more humbly in its interaction with Africa. Having served as the leader of the Western world since the end of the Second World War and the only superpower since the end of the Cold War, the United States often comes across in Africa as insensitive ... (10) The current China-Africa economic engagement is undoubtedly full of benefits and risks (11) arguably to both sides. The legal infrastructure for the management of such risks is in a state of development. …

Mechanism and Content of China-Ethiopia Cooperation in Science and Technology

China’s Promotion of Knowledge Diffusion in Africa — a Case Study on Ethiopia’s Manufacturing Sector

Chinese Economic and Trade Cooperation Zones in Africa

China–Africa science and technology collaboration: evidence from collaborative research papers and patents

China's agricultural assistance efficiency to Africa: Two decades of Forum for China-Africa Cooperation creation

Technology Transfer in China–Africa Relation: Myth or Reality

The New Achievements of the South-South Cooperation

Sino-African Cooperation and Africa's Poverty Alleviation

China-Africa Energy Development Cooperation under the Belt and Road Initiative

New Development of Sino-African Relations since the Founding of Forum on China-Africa Cooperation

Recent Developments in China–U.S. Cooperation in Science

African Shenzhen: China's Special Economic Zones in Africa

Management Economic Systems and Governance to Reduce Potential Risks in Digital Silk Road Investments: Legal Cooperation between Hainan Free Trade Port and Ethiopia

In-depth analysis on China’s international cooperation in science

China's Engagement in African Agriculture: “down to the Countryside”

China-Africa Investment Treaties and Dispute Settlement: A Piece of the Multipolar Puzzle

A New Milestone in History of Sino-African Relations

Integrating Africa to Global Economy: Seeking a Trilateral Partnership of Sino-US and European Union

Coopération agricole chinoise en Afrique subsaharienne. Dépasser les idées reçues

Research on technical cooperation path of renewable energy between China and South Africa

China-Africa Relations from the Perspective of the Belt and Road Initiative: Motivations, Characteristics and Prospects