Information Technology and the Puzzle of Firms' Declining Labor Demands in China
Wenbo Shao,Dan Sheng
2017-01-01
Abstract:The past 30 years have witnessed sustained rapid economic growth in China. However,with urbanization lagging behind industrialization,the labor income share has continued to decline in an even more pronounced way since the 1990s. More surprisingly,media often report that big companies such as Haier,Sany Heavy Industries,Foxconn and Huawei are laying off employees with the expansion of output. In the wake of the financial crisis and European debt crisis,it is natural to blame this on reduced external demand. However,further investigation reveals that the decline in employment demand for Chinese enterprises started well before the crises. Chinese industrial enterprise database data show that the average employment of enterprises has continued to decline at least since 1998,and more significantly in large companies,while the average business size has continued to expand. This is a puzzle that has nothing to do with the financial crises,as labor demand decreases with firm size. According to the related research on employment and wages,most of the attention has largely focused on labor income share,ignoring the facts of a sustained downward labor demand at the firm level,especially for large firms. We find that the rapid development of semiconductor technology lowered the price of information equipment,causing the wide application of information technology and equipment in production at the end of the last century. This informatization process brings about a profound change in the mode of production and results in changes in labor demand. To be specific,we develop a theoretical framework based on firm heterogeneity in information technology,and examine the impact of information and communication technology (ICT) on labor demand and labor income share. The results show that firms' information technology investment reduces their labor income share,but does not necessary cut down their quantity of labor demand, which hinges critically on the degree of competition. Furthermore,we prove that the adoption of ICT worsens firms' demand for labor if the degree of competition is sufficiently low. Otherwise,if the degree of competition is strong,then the adoption of ICT increases firms' demand for labor. We empirically examine these arguments using a large sample dataset and find strong evidence in support of the theoretical hypothesis. This result has profound implications for"ensuring economic growth and employment"and promoting the integration of information technology applications with industrialization. Compared with the current research,this paper makes the following main contribution. First,it is the first study to put forward and examine the issue of declining employment in enterprises from the perspective of informationization. Second,it develops a theory and unbundles the impact of information technology on enterprise employment demand into two effects: the"substitution effect"and"scale effect". Third,it deepens our understanding of the declining labor income share in China from the perspective of informationization. Fourth,instead of using aggregate data,this paper improves on the current research on labor income share by examining the issue based on a firm-level dataset. Fifth,this paper is the first to document the simultaneous reduction in labor income share and labor demand and examine two issues together in the same framework. It also shows that the impacts of ICT on labor demand and labor income share are different,as the latter is affected by not only labor demand but also wages. This paper makes three main suggestions. First,promoting employment has a crucial role in breaking the monopoly of industry,which may prevent a significant reduction in employment in the process of informationization. Second,it suggests that the labor income share decrease caused by enterprise resource allocation inequality may be partly offset by breaking the barriers of elements flow,which should promote income distribution more reasonably. Finally,it suggests that increasing labor force education and training expenditures may increase employment and improve income distribution.