Performance Shortfall, Decision Makers’ Cognition, and the Directions of Problemistic Search
Zhi Cao,Feifei Jiang,Donghan Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2021.14333abstract
2021-01-01
Abstract:The problemistic search literature has recently inquired the directions of search, i.e., when and why performance shortfall leads to one type of search rather than the other. While extant studies suggest that factors such as slack resources, experience, and environmental contexts matter for the directions of search, they implicitly assume almost equal priority of different types of search for firms to choose ex ante. We argue that firms may assess the priorities of different types of search differently ex ante. As firm behavior is goal oriented, a particular type of search (e.g., R&D search) is driven by a specific organizational goal (e.g., R&D goal), and the priority of the specific goal is further determined by decision makers’ belief in the efficacy of the specific goal in achieving the primary goal of the firm (e.g., profitability). We focus on two types of search represented by R&D intensity and philanthropic donation intensity, which are mapped to the R&D and CSR goal, respectively. Based on data from publicly listed firms in China (2009-2018), we find that negative performance feedback leads to greater extent of R&D intensity, but has a non-significant relationship with donation intensity. However, the latter relationship is strengthened by decision makers’ belief in the linkage between CSR ratings and profitability.