The Conflicts and the Resolution Mechanism of Stratiifed Rights of Construction Land Use Right

ZHU Yan,WANG Yi-bai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11994/zgtdkx.20171115.150646
2017-01-01
Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to clarify the nature, characteristics and the conflicts of stratified rights of construction land use rights and to propose the legislation resolution and the mechanism of civil law interpetation. The methods of comparative analysis and civil law interpretation are used in the paper. The research results show that 1) the spatial right is under the protection of the stratified right of construction land use right in the Chinese Real right legislation rather than under the the independent institution of spatial right; 2) although the stratified right of construction land use right has its own special characteristics, it is still compatible with the basic structure principles in the Chinese Real Rights Law; 3) the current legislation on the conflicts of the right and the resolution mechanism is oversimplified, thus it is of importance to reconsider it from the perspective of legislation and interpretation doctrine. In conclusion, the spatial right under and above land can be well protected in the framework of the stratified right of construction land use right; in order to find out the resolution for the conflicts of stratified right, some improvements must be made at the aspect of the relevant legislation, e.g. modifying the article 136 of the Chinese Real Right Law. Besides, other resolutions for these conflicts can also be found based on the current stipulations from the interpretation perspective, which are supported by the institutions of neighborhood, easement and real rights claim.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?