Identifying “sleeping Beauties ” and the Princes Who Woke Up Sleeping Beauties in Terms of Citation Speed Measures:A Case Study of the Key Publications by Stefan W . Hell

Du Jian,Wu Yishan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3772/j.issn.1000-0135.2015.005.008
2015-01-01
Abstract:Objective:Based on citation curve and citation speed,which measures how fast a paper accumulates its citations,we try to investigate whether a paper by Nobel laureate Stephan W . Hell,hereafter noted as Hell ( 1994 ) ,is a Sleeping Beauty document and identify the Princes who wake up the Sleeping Beauty,if that’s the case. Methods:T w o pairs of indicators,i. e. Citation Speed and Delayed Recognition Index ( DRI) as well as Co-Citation Speed and co-Delayed Recognition Index(cDRI) are proposed for rapidly discovering Sleeping Beauties and their Princes. CitNetExporler is used to reveal direct citation networks composed of the concerned documents. Results :There was a significant pattern of delayed recognition revealed by three aspects: Hell' 1994 $ ’ citation distribution over 1994 - 2014 period,a very slow citation speed and very high DRI. W e did not only find that Hell' 2000 $ is the first prince,but also detected another prince i. e. Hell' 2003 $ and two “retinues” of the prince i. e. Betzig'2006 $ and Rust & Z h uang' 2006 $ . It seems that these four documents 'two princes and two retinues) led more authors to refer to Hell' 1994 $ . Conclusions :Citation Speed and D R I are proved effective metrics for distinguishing “sleeping beauties” citation patterns from “flash in the p a n ” patterns. By examining the reference list of articles citing Sleeping Beauties,one can discern ‘Prince ’articles characterized by the following features :1 $ They were published not long after Sleeping Beauty’s awakening; 2 $ They are highly co-cited with Sleeping Beauty ;3 $ They have almost the same co-citation speed and co-Delayed Recognition Index with Sleeping Beauty. A Sleeping Beauty m ay need a prince plus other agents to wake her u p ,and those documents with awakening function tend to be highly cited articles also and published in journals with higher impact than the journals publishing sleeping beauties. Publications belonging to so-called transformative research,when less cited,m a y be given special attention,because they may almost suddenly attract a lot of attention after a period of time,as reflected in our case.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?