A Demarcation between the Masses and the EIite and between Entertainment and EnIightenment-Comments on Li Jinghui′s Being Criticized in China′s Modern History of Music Criticism

Xu-guang CHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-0012.2015.06.008
2015-01-01
Journal of Aesthetic Education
Abstract:In China′s history of music criticism of the 21st century, the criticism and controversy surrounding Li Jinghui′s composition of musicals for children and pop songs, including his expounding, rebuttal and eventual self-criticism, have re-sulted in an important phenomenon of long duration in music criticism and of a significance that transcends the domain of music.Moreover, the criticism of Li by composers such as Nie Er and He Luting is one of the important marks of the rise of left-wing music criticism .By rereading and objectively analyzing this controversy in the light of the May Fourth Movement′s ethos of a new culture, we can see that Li Jinghui′s ideas on music contain germs of the aforementioned movement′s spirit of the masses and his pop music is typical of the popularization, commercialization and catering to the masses of elitist mu-sic.It has a strong urban bourgeois flavor and is of a high entertainment and commercial value.Today, when mass culture is no longer seen as vulgar and pop music is so popular everywhere, it is necessary to reappraise Li Jinghui′s value as a reve-lation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?