Participant??s Perspective and Observer??s Perspective:Hegel on the Application of Self-Determination Criterion to Arbitrariness

Hao CHEN
2016-01-01
Abstract:Hegel distinguishes concrete reason from formal reason.He claims that concrete reason is a social property which can only be actualized in the course of self-development,and has not yet come in-to being in arbitrariness stage.For this reason,Hegel cannot apply his Self-determination Criterion to arbitrariness.In order to apply Self-determination Criterion to arbitrariness stage,two conditions have to be satisfied:(I)both formal reason and concrete reason should be presented at the same time;(II) only concrete reason can be taken as the very element with which an agent identifies.Owe to his doub-le-perspective theory,Participant??s Perspective and Observer??s Perspective,Hegel satisfies these two conditions by using concrete reason in advance,and overcomes the difficulty that Self-determination Criterion cannot be applied to arbitrariness.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?