Emotion-related Effects of Analogical Problem Solving of Surface Similarity

WANG Ru-fang,LI Hong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-0627.2005.02.009

2005-01-01

Abstract:Emotions play a significant role in analogical problem resolution and cognition of surface similarity. The article surveys several theories involved and finds that easy transfer arises from the emotion-related similarities between source and target problems.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The neuromechanism underlying verbal analogical reasoning of metaphorical relations: An event-related potentials study

Ming Zhao,Huishan Meng,Zhiyuan Xu,Fenglei Du,Tao Liu,Yongxin Li,Feiyan Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brainres.2011.09.041

IF: 3.61

2011-01-01

Brain Research

Abstract:Using event-related potentials (ERPs), this study investigated the neuromechanism underlying verbal analogical reasoning of two different metaphorical relations: attributive metaphor and relational metaphor. The analogical reasoning of attributive metaphor (AM-AR) involves a superficial similarity between analogues, while the analogical reasoning of relational metaphor (RM-AR) requires a structural similarity. Subjects were asked to judge whether one word pair was semantically analogous to another word pair. Results showed that the schema induction stage elicited a greater N400 component at the right anterior scalp for the AM-AR and RM-AR tasks, possibly attributable to semantic processing of metaphorical word pairs. The N400 was then followed by a widely distributed P300 and a late negative component (LNC1) at the left anterior scalp. The P300 was possibly related to the formation of a relational category, while the LNC1 was possibly related to the maintenance of a reasoning cue in working memory. The analogy mapping stage elicited broadly distributed N400 and LNC2, which might indicate the presence of semantic retrieval and analogical transfer. In the answer production stage, all conditions elicited the P2 component due to early stimulus encoding. The largest P2 amplitude was in the RM-AR task. The RM-AR elicited a larger LPC than did the AM-AR, even though the baseline correction was taken as a control for the differential P2 effect. The LPC effect might suggest that relational metaphors involved more integration processing than attributive metaphors.
Surface and structural similarity in analogical transfer

Keith J. Holyoak,Kyunghee Koh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/bf03197035

1987-07-01

Abstract:Two experiments investigated factors that influence the retrieval and use of analogies in problem solving, Experiment 1 demonstrated substantial spontaneous analogical transfer with a delay of several days between presentation of the source and target analogues. Experiment 2 examined the influence of different types of similarity between the analogues. A mechanism for retrieval of source analogues is proposed, based on summation of activation from features shared with a target problem. The results of Experiment 2 indicated that both structural features, which play a causal role in determining possible problem solutions, and salient surface features, which do not have a causal role, influence spontaneous selection of an analogue. Structural features, however, have a greater impact than do surface features on a problem solver’s ability to use an analogue once its relevance has been pointed out.

psychology, experimental
An experimental and simulation study of the impact of emotional information on analogical reasoning

Ariana A Castro,John E Hummel,Howard Berenbaum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2023.105510

IF: 4.011

Cognition

Abstract:We investigated whether and how emotional information would affect analogical reasoning. We hypothesized that task-irrelevant emotional information would impair performance whereas task-relevant emotional information would enhance it. In Study 1, 233 undergraduates completed a novel version of the People Pieces Task (Emotional Faces People Task), an analogical reasoning task in which the task characters displayed emotional or neutral facial expressions (within-participants). The emotional faces were relevant or irrelevant to the task (between-participants). We simulated the behavioral results using the Learning and Inference with Schemas and Analogies (LISA) model of relational reasoning. LISA is a neurally plausible, symbolic-connectionist computational model of analogical reasoning. In comparison to neutral trials, participants were slower but more accurate on emotion-relevant trials, and were faster but less accurate on emotion-irrelevant trials. Simulations using the LISA model demonstrated that it is possible to account for the effects of emotional information on reasoning in terms of how emotional stimuli attract attention during a reasoning task. In Study 2, 255 undergraduates completed the Emotional Faces People Task at either a high- or low-working memory load. The high working memory load condition of Study 2 replicated the findings of Study 1, showing that participants were more accurate on emotion-relevant trials than on emotion-irrelevant trials; in Study 2, this increased accuracy could not be accounted for by a speed-accuracy tradeoff. The working memory manipulation influenced the manner in which the congruence (with the correct answer) of emotion-irrelevant emotion influenced performance. Simulations using the LISA model showed that manipulating the salience of emotion, the error penalty, as well as vigilance (which determines the likelihood that LISA will notice it has attended to an irrelevant relation), could reasonably reproduce the behavioral results of both low and high working memory load conditions of Study 2.
Analogical Transfer of Problem-Solving Strategies in Children

CHEN Zhe,Wang Rui-Ming,Mo Lei

2008-01-01

Advances in Psychological Science

Abstract:Analogical transfer of problem-solving strategies, which refers to the generalization of problem-solving strategies across isomorphic tasks, is a fundamental issue in the study of children cognitive development. Until fairly recently, analogical transfer has received little sustained attention in child development research. However, numerous studies have been conducted over the past decade, thus providing insights into issues central to children’s thinking and analogical problem solving. This article describes recent advances in the research on children’s analogical transfer. Several trends in research focus have emerged: from performance to early competencies, from age differences to facilitative factors, from abilities to underlying processes, from demonstration of skills to generalization to various domains, and from near to remote transfer. Finally, directions for future research in this field are suggested.
Having the memory of an elephant: long-term retrieval and the use of analogues in problem solving.

Zhe Chen,Lei Mo,Ryan Honomichl

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-3445.133.3.415

2004-01-01

Abstract:The authors report 4 experiments exploring long-term analogical transfer from problem solutions in folk tales participants heard during childhood, many years before encountering the target problems. Substantial culture-specific analogical transfer was found when American and Chinese participants' performance was compared on isomorphs of problems solved in European versus Chinese folk tales. There was evidence of transfer even among participants who did not report being reminded of the source tale while solving the target problem. Comparisons of different versions of a target problem indicated that similarity of solution tool affected accessing, mapping, and executing components of problem solving, whereas similarity of goal object had only a moderate effect on accessing. High school students also evidenced greater transfer than did middle school students.
Theoretical Issues in Analogical Problem Solution:A Survey

CHEN Ying-he,ZHAO Xiao-mei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-0209.2008.01.006

2008-01-01

Abstract:Analogy is thought to be a powerful mechanism for acquiring new knowledge and solving problems,and has a fundamental and priority function in human cognition.Researchers have managed to reach a commonplace in the function of analogical problem solution,but disagree in its mechanism,process,agent and developing trends.There are four main theories on the mechanism of analogical problem solution,namely,structure-mapping theory,pragmatic schema theory,exemplar theory,and path-mapping theory,each having its own merits.As for the process,researchers have argued for three phases,four phases,or even five phases.As for the agent,there are three dominating theories,respectively focusing on the ability,knowledge and their reciprocity.The trends of the development are also discussed from a stage-like perspective,whether linear or non-linear perspectives.All these issues need to be addressed in future empirical researches.
Analogical reasoning during hypothesis generation: the effects of object and domain similarities on access and transfer

Leandro E. Rivas,Máximo Trench

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13546783.2024.2409467

2024-10-04

Thinking & Reasoning

Abstract:In two experiments on analogical hypothesis generation, we factorially manipulated the presence of domain and object similarities between a base situation and a target phenomenon, and assessed their effects on the transfer of the source's explanatory structure before and after an indication to use the base analog as a source for analogical explanations. The absence of any kind of surface similarity led to very low rates of spontaneous transfer. In both experiments, however, either kind of surface similarity sufficed to enhance the spontaneous transfer of the base explanation during the formulation of plausible hypotheses for the target. The transfer advantage of object and domain similarity cannot be attributed to the effect of these variables on post-access processes, since experimental conditions did not differ with regard to the ability to transfer the base explanation upon explicit request. The effect of domain similarity on spontaneous analogical explanation constitutes a relevant finding, especially given the lack of attention received by this dimension of similarity in behavioural studies and computer simulations of analogical retrieval.

psychology, experimental
Analogical Transfer in Mathematics Learning

Xi-lian FU,Yu-feng ZHANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-9894.2006.04.009

2006-01-01

Journal on Mathematics Education

Abstract:Analogical transfer was an important appearance of transfer.In mathematics,similar elements between two different knowledge systems or two different questions and cognitive structure of learner were the major elements that affect analogical transfer.There were direct relation and indirect relation between two similar systems,Two systems with direct relation had analogical relation of completely explicit meaning,so analogical reasoning could be carried on directly;about two systems with indirect relation,the analogical system needed to be alternated or arranged anew,a medium system was build.In process of analogical transfer,the similar elements between two systems were the reason;the process knowledge took controlling action.
In Search of the 'aha!' Experience: Elucidating the Emotionality of Insight Problem-Solving.

Wangbing Shen,Yuan,Chang Liu,Jing Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/bjop.12142

IF: 4.981

2015-01-01

British Journal of Psychology

Abstract:UNLABELLED:Although the experience of insight has long been noted, the essence of the 'Aha!' experience, reflecting a sudden change in the brain that accompanies an insight solution, remains largely unknown. This work aimed to uncover the mystery of the 'Aha!' experience through three studies. In Study 1, participants were required to solve a set of verbal insight problems and then subjectively report their affective experience when solving the problem. The participants were found to have experienced many types of emotions, with happiness the most frequently reported one. Multidimensional scaling was employed in Study 2 to simplify the dimensions of these reported emotions. The results showed that these different types of emotions could be clearly placed in two-dimensional space and that components constituting the 'Aha!' experience mainly reflected positive emotion and approached cognition. To validate previous findings, in Study 3, participants were asked to select the most appropriate emotional item describing their feelings at the time the problem was solved. The results of this study replicated the multidimensional construct consisting of approached cognition and positive affect. These three studies provide the first direct evidence of the essence of the 'Aha!'EXPERIENCE:The potential significance of the findings was discussed.
Analogical Symbols: The Role of Visual Cues in Long-Term Transfer

Zhe Chen,Lei Mo,Ryan Honomichl,Myeong-Ho Sohn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10926481003716000

2010-01-01

Metaphor and Symbol

Abstract:We are reminded of relevant stories, tales, or symbols from long-term memory when facing a novel problem our daily lives. Visual cues are 1 tool known to facilitate reminding. In 2 experiments, Chinese students, who had experienced a folk tale many years ago during childhood, were asked to solve an analogous problem. We tested the hypothesis that a visual cue can help bridge the gap between a novel problem and a source analogy experienced in the distant past. Different types of cues proved to have distinct influences on components of analogical problem solving. This research suggests that analogical representational features of a story or problem can be stored in long-term memory and can be activated by visual cues. The implications of these findings for theories that point to perceptual or grounded, rather than decontextualized structures in knowledge representation are discussed.
Study on Artificial Emotion and Its Application in the Behavior Selection Strategy of Agents

刘明,许力

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-7147.2003.06.004

2003-01-01

Abstract:In recent years, the fact that emotions are essential in human intelligence has been noticed. This suggests that emotions may play an important role in intelligent systems. The paper presents a fuzzy emotion model for an agent living in a virtual environment and combines the emotions with an associative learning strategy based on CMAC neural network to form the decision-making and self-learning system of the agent, in which the emotions provide reinforcements to direct the learning process. Computer simulation results show that the proposed method can improve the performance of the agent.
An Experiment on Children's Analogical Reasoning with Superficial Similarity and Structural Similarity

Feng Tingyong,Li Yu,Li Hong,Su Ti,Long Changquan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-6981.2006.05.015

IF: 10.172

2006-01-01

Psychological Science

Abstract:With self-designed classic analogical problems,three experiment conditions were taken to explore the superficial similarity and structure similarity analogical reasoning of children aged 3-5 years.It showed: the effects of superficial similarity and structure on children's analogy similarity were different.In general,the former was more conducive to analogical problem solving;children's ability to solve classic analogical problems with superficial similarity and structure similarity developed with age.However,the trend of development was different.In terms of superficial similarity,it developed slowly before 4 years old,and faster after 4 years old.In terms of structure similarity,it developed faster before 4 years old,and slowly after 4 years old.The age of 4 was a turning point;working memory effects on children's analogy with superficial similarity and structure similarity were not evident;the hint of mapping relations might prompt children's analogy with superficial similarity and structure similarity;however,the effect on age might be non-linear.
The Neural Substrate of Analogical Reasoning: an Fmri Study

Q Luo,C Perry,DL Peng,Z Jin,D Xu,GS Ding,SY Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0926-6410(03)00167-8

2003-01-01

Cognitive Brain Research

Abstract:This study investigated the anatomical substrate of analogical reasoning using functional magnetic resonance imaging. In the study, subjects performed a verbal analogy task (e.g., soldier is to army as drummer is to band) and, to control for activation caused by purely semantic access, a semantic judgment task. Significant activation differences between the verbal analogy and the semantic judgment task were found bilaterally in the prefrontal cortex (right BA 11/BA 47 and left BA45), the fusiform gyrus, and the basal ganglia; left lateralized in the postero-superior temporal gyrus (BA 22) and the (para) hippocampal region; and right lateralized in the anterior cingulate. The role of these areas in analogical reasoning is discussed.
Development of Analogical Reasoning: A Novel Perspective From Cross‐Cultural Studies

Stella Christie,Yang Gao,Qiuchen Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12380

IF: 6.16

2020-08-04

Child Development Perspectives

Abstract:<p>Analogical reasoning allows children to generate new abstractions from experience, which drives early learning. But our current understanding of analogical learning is based primarily on evidence from the West, and new data from Asia seem to call into question that information. In this article, we describe our finding that East Asian children do not share their Western peers' strong bias for object similarity—often cited as the major reason for difficulties in relational reasoning. We analyze how this difference affects the ways analogy shapes learning in different cultures, such as what children use as base analogs and their likelihood of using comparison that results in relational abstraction. We also address cross‐cultural differences, which are evident in classroom contexts, since teachers from the United States and East Asia use analogy differently. Overall, cross‐cultural data are necessary to answer critical questions in theories of analogical learning; in this article, we chart pressing research questions and look ahead at directions for the field.</p>

psychology, developmental
The Role of Object Similarity in Spatial-acted Relationship Mapping

Tong Xiuli,Mo Lei,Wu Jun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-6981.2007.01.003

IF: 10.172

2007-01-01

Psychological Science

Abstract:The role of object similarity in analogical mapping has been a controversial issue.In this study a new paradigm referring to the design of embedding and separating crossmapping was used to examine the role of object similarity in young children and adults.Study 1 was to investigate whether the role of object similarity might vary well at different developmental levels.Study 2 applied the eye tracking technique to detect the role of object similarity in the whole time course by comparing targeted areas.The results suggested that object similarity influenced children's analogical mapping performance rather than adults'.However,it affected the course of analogical mapping processing of adults when object similarity embedded in relationship structure shared with base-domain and target-domain pictures.The study underscored the importance of the view of primacy-constraint with alignment in explaining role of the object similarity in analogical mapping.
Life is a Circus and We are the Clowns: Automatically Finding Analogies between Situations and Processes

Oren Sultan,Dafna Shahaf

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2210.12197

2023-01-19

Abstract:Analogy-making gives rise to reasoning, abstraction, flexible categorization and counterfactual inference -- abilities lacking in even the best AI systems today. Much research has suggested that analogies are key to non-brittle systems that can adapt to new domains. Despite their importance, analogies received little attention in the NLP community, with most research focusing on simple word analogies. Work that tackled more complex analogies relied heavily on manually constructed, hard-to-scale input representations. In this work, we explore a more realistic, challenging setup: our input is a pair of natural language procedural texts, describing a situation or a process (e.g., how the heart works/how a pump works). Our goal is to automatically extract entities and their relations from the text and find a mapping between the different domains based on relational similarity (e.g., blood is mapped to water). We develop an interpretable, scalable algorithm and demonstrate that it identifies the correct mappings 87% of the time for procedural texts and 94% for stories from cognitive-psychology literature. We show it can extract analogies from a large dataset of procedural texts, achieving 79% precision (analogy prevalence in data: 3%). Lastly, we demonstrate that our algorithm is robust to paraphrasing the input texts.

Computation and Language,Artificial Intelligence
The Role of Perceptual Interference, Semantic Interference, and Relational Integration in the Development of Analogical Reasoning.

Xiao Yu,Liuna Geng,Yinghe Chen,Congcong Han,Xiaojing Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00756

IF: 3.8

2020-01-01

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:This study aimed to examine the role of perceptual interference, semantic interference, and relational integration (RI) in the development of analogical reasoning, and to compare the interactive pattern of interference and RI in children and adults. In Experiment 1, we tested 31 3- and 4-year-olds, 27 5- and 6-year-olds, and 40 adults for perceptual interference and RI in analogical reasoning. Perceptual interference emerged when proper mapping between analogically matching objects was incoherent with their perceptual features. RI was evaluated via manipulation of the number of objects in an analogical scene. Significant main effects of perceptual interference and RI were found in children and adults. In Experiment 2, we tested 30 3- and 4-year-olds, 27 5- and 6-year-olds, and 40 adults for semantic interference and RI in analogical reasoning. Semantic interference emerged when proper mapping between analogically matching objects was incoherent with their categorical features. Results showed significant main effects of semantic interference and RI in children and adults. The results of both experiments suggested different mechanisms of interference and RI in children and adults. For children, interference and RI depended on shared cognitive sources. If one factor (i.e., interference resolution) needed more cognitive demand, there would be limited resources available for another factor (i.e., RI). Furthermore, for adults, the increased load of RI and interference on adults' analogical reasoning exceeded the sum of their respective singular effects. For 3- and 4-year-olds, the degree of perceptual interference was larger than the degree of semantic interference in the Binary Relation condition, whereas there was no significant difference between the degree of two types of interference in the Quaternary Relation condition. Moreover, for 5- and 6-year-olds, the degree of semantic interference was larger than the degree of perceptual interference in both relation conditions. For adults, there was no difference between the degree of two types of interference in both relation conditions. The article also discusses the theoretical and practical implications of this research.
Neural Correlates of Analogical Reasoning on Syntactic Patterns

Zhongshan Li,Zhuqian Zhou,Xiaoling Wang,Jinshan Wu,Luyao Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_02115

2024-03-26

Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience

Abstract:Abstract Analogical reasoning is central to thought and learning. However, previous neuroscience studies have focused mainly on neural substrates for visuospatial and semantic analogies. There has not yet been research on the neural correlates of analogical reasoning on syntactic patterns generated by the syntactic rules, a key feature of human language faculty. The present investigation took an initial step to address this paucity. Twenty-four participants, whose brain activity was monitored by fMRI, engaged in first-order and second-order relational judgments of syntactic patterns as well as simple and complex working memory tasks. After scanning, participants rated the difficulty of each step during analogical reasoning; these ratings were related to signal intensities in activated regions of interest using Spearman correlation analyses. After prior research, differences in activation levels during second-order and first-order relational judgments were taken as evidence of analogical reasoning. These analyses showed that analogical reasoning on syntactic patterns recruited brain regions consistent with those supporting visuospatial and semantic analogies, including the anterior and posterior parts of the left middle frontal gyrus, anatomically corresponding to the left rostrolateral pFC and the left dorsolateral pFC. The correlation results further revealed that the posterior middle frontal gyrus might be involved in analogical access and mapping with syntactic patterns. Our study is the first to investigate the process of analogical reasoning on syntactic patterns at the neurobiological level and provide evidence of the specific functional roles of related regions during subprocesses of analogical reasoning.

psychology, experimental,neurosciences
High Emotional Similarity Will Enhance the Face Memory and Face-Context Associative Memory

Shu An,Mengyang Zhao,Feng Qin,Hongchi Zhang,Weibin Mao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.877375

2022-05-09

Abstract:Previous research has explored how emotional valence (positive or negative) affected face-context associative memory, while little is known about how arousing stimuli that share the same valence but differ in emotionality are bound together and retained in memory. In this study, we manipulated the emotional similarity between the target face and the face associated with the context emotion (i.e., congruent, high similarity, and low similarity), and examined the effect of emotional similarity of negative emotion (i.e., disgust, anger, and fear) on face-context associative memory. Our results showed that the greater the emotional similarity between the faces, the better the face memory and face-context associative memory were. These findings suggest that the processing of facial expression and its associated context may benefit from taking into account the emotional similarity between the faces.
Individual differences in transfer via analogy

Alice J. Corkill,Jennifer J. Fager

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/1041-6080(95)90009-8

IF: 3.897

1995-01-01

Learning and Individual Differences

Abstract:This study examined the relative contribution of four individual difference variables to ability to solve analogically related problems in four separate problem sequences and for spontaneous and assisted transfer. Experiment 1 investigated the relationships between problem sources and targets, the familiarity of problem sources and targets, and the degree to which subjects spontaneously provided a particular solution to two target problems. Experiment 2 tested whether combinations of individual difference variables served as significant predictors of problem solving success in four different source-target problem sequences. For both spontaneous and assisted transfer, the results indicated that under certain circumstances different combinations of the individual difference variables were contributing to ability to predict whether a subject would provide a particular solution to a target problem. The results are discussed in terms of why the individual difference variables enhance prediction for transfer only under certain conditions.

psychology, educational

Emotion-related Effects of Analogical Problem Solving of Surface Similarity

The neuromechanism underlying verbal analogical reasoning of metaphorical relations: An event-related potentials study

Surface and structural similarity in analogical transfer

An experimental and simulation study of the impact of emotional information on analogical reasoning

Analogical Transfer of Problem-Solving Strategies in Children

Having the memory of an elephant: long-term retrieval and the use of analogues in problem solving.

Theoretical Issues in Analogical Problem Solution:A Survey

Analogical reasoning during hypothesis generation: the effects of object and domain similarities on access and transfer

Analogical Transfer in Mathematics Learning

In Search of the 'aha!' Experience: Elucidating the Emotionality of Insight Problem-Solving.

Analogical Symbols: The Role of Visual Cues in Long-Term Transfer

Study on Artificial Emotion and Its Application in the Behavior Selection Strategy of Agents

An Experiment on Children's Analogical Reasoning with Superficial Similarity and Structural Similarity

The Neural Substrate of Analogical Reasoning: an Fmri Study

Development of Analogical Reasoning: A Novel Perspective From Cross‐Cultural Studies

The Role of Object Similarity in Spatial-acted Relationship Mapping

Life is a Circus and We are the Clowns: Automatically Finding Analogies between Situations and Processes

The Role of Perceptual Interference, Semantic Interference, and Relational Integration in the Development of Analogical Reasoning.

Neural Correlates of Analogical Reasoning on Syntactic Patterns

High Emotional Similarity Will Enhance the Face Memory and Face-Context Associative Memory

Individual differences in transfer via analogy