The Impact of Different Parenting Styles on First-Year College Students' Adaptation to College.
Gregory J. Smith
Abstract:The present study was undertaken to determine the impact of different parenting styles on college students’ adaptation to college. During the second week of college, 80 first-year students from two-parent families completed the Tests of Reactions and Adaptations to College, English version and the Parental Authority Questionnaire. Authoritative parenting was related to more positive characteristics in the students studied than either authoritarian or permissive parenting. While permissive parenting was related to better emotional adjustment than authoritarian parenting, the behavioral and belief differences resulting from those two parenting styles were negligible. Comparing mothers and fathers, the fathers’ parenting styles had a greater impact on the students than the mothers’ parenting styles. Method The present study was undertaken to determine the impact of different parenting styles on college students’ adaptation to college. Early research into the impact of parenting styles on children’s behavior, personality development, and other factors was largely limited to studies involving younger children. Research completed over the past decade or more has extended those investigations into the adolescent and college years (Gonzalez, 2001). Among other factors, parenting styles have been found to be related to perfectionism (Flett, Hewitt, & Singer, 1995), goal orientation (Gonzalez, 200 1 ), self-esteem (Buri, Cooper, & Kircher, 1992), and self-rated happiness (Furnham & Cheng, 2000) in college students. While the influence of parenting styles has not always been uniform, with varying results depending on the gender of the student and the parenting styles of fathers versus mothers is considered, the overall results suggest that different parenting styles should play an important role in the initial adaptation to college of first-year college students. The present research utilized the three parenting styles originally proposed by Baumrind (1971): authoritative, authoritarian, and permissive. Authoritative parents are parents who are both demanding and emotionally responsive, assertive, but not intrusive or restrictive; authoritarian parents are parents who are highly demanding and directive, but not emotionally responsive, they set rules and expect them to be followed without exception; and permissive parents are parents who set few rules and demand little of their children. While modifications to Baumrind’ s original parenting styles have been proposed (e.g., Maccoby & Martin, 1983), the original three parenting styles continue to be used in research settings investigating the impact of parenting on a variety of characteristics in children. It was predicted that students whose parents were rated higher in authoritative parenting, showing support while maintaining high expectations, would exhibit more positive characteristics relative to college adjustment during the first weeks at college than students whose parents were rated higher in either authoritarianism or permissiveness. It was expected that students of parents higher in authoritarianism would have difficulty adjusting to the freedom evident at college once the highly demanding structure provided by their parents is removed. It was also expected that students of parents higher in permissiveness would also have difficulty adjusting to college because of the lack of developed personal structure in those students. Participants A total of 80 first-year college students (24 men and 56 women) attending a private liberal arts college volunteered to participate in the present research. All participants reported being from intact, two-parent families.
Psychology,Education