Controversy about Cao Xue-Qin's Hometown

苗怀明

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-8008.2001.04.005

2001-01-01

Abstract:The controversy about Cao xue-qin's hometown in recent years is hot and in a higher degree. There are some places to be improved for both sides of the argument, The standard of study is a serious problem in this controversy. The scholar should pay attention to it.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Dispute of ″Jinwen″ and ″Guwen″ and Orientation of Confucianism under the Background of ″National Calamity″

Zhang Kai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2012.08.051

2013-01-01

Abstract:In the Late Qing and the Republic of China,scholars had developed different paths in transforming traditional academics and bridging Sino-Western and old-new in the context of the evolution of Classical Studies and Historiography.Two distinct schools of Confucianism came into being in the Republic of China: one was the historical ″Guwen″ represented by Zhang Taiyan and his students,the other was the philosophic Jinwen represented by Liaoping and his students.With the aggravation of the National Calamity in the 1930s and revival of Confucianism,it was a common practice to promote Chinese culture and national spirits.Thus the transformation and practice of Confucianism became the focus in the discussion between the two different schools.During the dispute Meng Wentong and Li Yuancheng,Liao Ping's students,argued with Zhang Taiyan and Huang Kan constantly about sinology and Neo-Confucianism,″Jinwen″ and ″Guwen,″ and ″Classical Studies″ and ″Historiography″ to clarify the origin and development of Confucian philosophy. After a careful study of Qing's academic history and looking into the relations between Dai Zhen's philosophy and Xun Zi,Zhang Taiyan emphasized the unique significance of Dai Zhen in Qing's Academic history.On the contrary,Meng Wentong and Li Yuancheng resorted to traditional sinology and Confucian theories to question the construction of Dai Zhen's theory.Based on the examination of Examine Goodness,Li Yuancheng criticized Dai Zhen's doctrine of Ethics,Desire and Goodness as a misunderstanding of Mencius.Based on Guwen and centreing around the separation of Confucianism and Buddhism,Zhang Taiyan stressed the reliability of the historical account of the Six Classics to respond to the Skeptical School and illustrated the ideological and cultural tradition of China in the past two thousand years.Li Yuancheng had developed Liao Ping's theory and discussed with Zhang Taiyan the Rites and Spring and Autumn aiming to link ″Jinwen″ and ″Guwen″ and to reiterate the Great Righteousness of Spring and Autumn.Meng Wentong,through his study of the development of Confucian philosophy in Zhou dynasty,Qin dynasty and the two Han dynasties,attempted to find the succession of Confucianism and Mencius's thoughts,to analyze the philosophy of ″humanity and destiny,″ to interpret the controversies over Mencius and Xun Zi,to clarify the origin of sinology,and to challenge Cheng Zhu Confucian Orthodoxy.In short,Liao Ping's students had constructed a Confucian system based on the ″Goodness″ of Mencius,theoretically paving the way for for Jinwen and Confucian historiography. The school of Zhang Taiyan-Huang Kan purported to explore the development of national cultures,focused on the language and history,and advocated the cultivation of mind and behavior.Thus,it had associated moral ethics with political and social pragmaticism and had started the practical academics of Classical Studies and Historiography.In contrast,Liao Ping's students emphasized on constructing an dynamic interaction between the meanings of Classics,institution,and historical facts,carrying forward the ″New Confucianism of Qin and Han,″ and elucidating the revolutionary spirit of Jinwen and system design.Dispute of ″Jinwen″ and ″Guwen″ manifested the core difference of the academic interests between the schools of Zhang Taiyan-Huang Kan and Liao Ping's students.A clarification of their differences and disputes is of importance in interpreting the diversification of modern Confucianism and providing intellectual resources for the building of a nation-state or a civilization-state.
To "Cai ", "Hu" about A Dream of Red Mansions Another Research That Dispute ——And Concurrently Talks about the Friendship between Two People

Miao Huai-ming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-6320.2005.03.011

2005-01-01

Abstract:Cai Yuanpei, disputed which Hu Shi carried on around A Dream of Red Mansions were a significant incident that academy made the transition in the course in modern times of China in the 1920s, confrontation that must be carried on that it is the new or old academy while replacing. Cai Yuanpei failed, his studies studied own characteristic and contribution, should offer overall, objective appraisal. The attitude and way of the participants of both sides of disputants merit attention to this, dispute and go on under the atmosphere with friendly equality and communicating with each other. This is a modern academic controversy with model meaning.[JP]
A Historical Investigation and Classification Analysis of Seven Controversies on the Reform and Abolition of the 1300-Year Chinese Imperial Examination System

Muzhou Li,Haifeng Liu,Wei-Chiao Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2022.101976

IF: 2.845

2022-01-01

International Journal of Educational Research

Abstract:The Chinese imperial examination system has witnessed seven controversies on its reform and abolition throughout its 1300-year-old history. With a historical investigation and classification analysis, result showed that the seven controversies mainly focused on three pairs of contradictions. They are controversies on the content and format of imperial examinations, controversies on choosing talents through imperial examination or recommendation, and controversies on selecting talents through imperial examination or schooling system. The main implications include that the content of national examination should be beneficial to talent selection, the format of national examination should be conductive to efficient talent selection, and the national examination should uphold social equity and fairness and especially should be conducive to social class mobility.
The Local Chinese Community's Doubt and Confusion From Lu Yao's Fiction

QIN Xiang-li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-5856.2010.06.016

2010-01-01

Abstract:Lu Yao's fictions focus on "cross-urban and rural areas",which reflects the local Chinese community's doubt and confusion in the conversion of the modern society.In the escaping and returning reincarnation,Lu Yao's moral criticisms is called "reasonable but not fair" to the "modern" behaviors.This reflects that the local writers were anxious about social modern changes in essence.
Discussion on Three Issues about Hong Xue——Preface of What is Hong Xue

YING Bi-cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-9617.2007.03.002

2007-01-01

Abstract:Discusses three issues in Hong Xue research.First,what is Hong Xue Puts forward researching the Dream of a Red Mansion and researching the origin,life of Cao Xueqin,as well as edition are organic,indivisible.Don't agree to limit Hong Xue in Cao Xue,Edition Xue,Rough Xue,Finding Lose.Second,the relations between Geng chen Edition and Jimao Edition of the Dream of a Red Mansion,queries the opinion that Gengchen Edition didn't copy Jimao Edition.Third,on the basis of analyzing the concepts and methods of school of searching for hidden meaning and new school of Hong Xue,puts forward how to further understand and research the historic value and significance of the dream of a red mansion aesthetic,apperceive the world behind the artistic images and significant world.
China's new Towns in Controversy: A Literature Review

Boqian Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/08854122211051614

2021-10-29

Journal of Planning Literature

Abstract:In the past forty years, more than 3,800 new towns emerged and accommodated over 150 million urban inhabitants in China, which drew much attention since they were reported as “ghost cities” by media in the late 2000s. This literature review examines existing research and synthesizes current discussions through a meta-analysis. It concludes that existing literature, led by environmental scientists and designers, exhibits two polarized debates around the new towns’ uniqueness and the future of ghost cities. Gaps exist in national-scale surveys, criticism of planning methodology, and theories that can explain the current disputes.

urban studies,regional & urban planning
An Inspiration of Theoretical Awareness in Translation Assessment and Research——On the significance of the dispute over Chinese translations of Le Rouge et le Noir

XU Jun

2011-01-01

Abstract:This paper argues that the nationwide debate,in the 1990s,about the Chinese translation of Stendal's Le Rouge et le Noir was a significant,historic event.The event has drawn attention to the ethical aspect of translation and inspired Chinese scholars with theoretical awareness in their translation research and criticism.It is and will long be remembered for its contribution to the building of new scaffoldings for Chinese translators and critics to perform translation criticism.To a remarkable degree,it provoked thinking,on the part of the then enthusiastic reading community of foreign literature,about literary translation.
Hometown in the Memory of Literature Writing

Zhang Yong-jie

Abstract:As the bridge between modern writers and contemporary writers, Wang Zeng-qi inherits the tradition of writing hometown started by some famous writers in modern literature such as Nu Xun, Sheng Cong-wen, etc.. For Wang, writing about 'hometown' is his deliberate choice both in terms of his writing techniques and of his purpose. Hometown is the resource of thought as well as the resource of writing. He has the feeling of "home" in the text about Kunming, which fill in the role of a spiritual hometown. Meanwhile, there was a shift from narrating the present to recalling of the past in the way of narrating. In this way, the writer has brought about a lasting aesthetic effect.

Philosophy,History
LU Xun's Verdict about JIN Sheng-tan's Cutting the Water Margin in Half Should Not Be Reversed

Zhang Guo-guang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-4799.2001.01.010

2001-01-01

Abstract:LU Xun's theory about JIN Sheng-tan's cutting the Water Margin in half has been acknowledged in academic circles. But a paper written by ZHOU Ling, which called the theory in question, was published in Literature Review in 1998 and was then widely reprinted in journals and newspapers, thus maing a strong impact. The author of this article agrees that even if a final academic conclusion is reached, it is still open to question. But in ZHOU Ling's paper, much of the evidence is not irrefutable, and there are even indications of plagiarism. That it has been published in authoritative journals is a serious problem of academic discipline. By refuting ZHOU Ling's errors and criticizing the academic discipline involved, this article attempts to ensure a correct understanding of the facts.
The "Ku-shih-pien" School, "Method of Dual Evidence" and correlated problems:an interview with Mr.Qiu Xigui

Qiu Xigui,Cao Feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0511-4721.2007.04.001

2007-01-01

Abstract:Mr. Qiu Xigui is generally acknowledged throughout the academia as an accomplished scholar in the fields of ancient philology, ancient documents and early history of China. In March 2007, he accepted the interview of the special correspondent of the Journal of Literature, History and Philosophy. During the interview, Mr. Qiu looked back upon the course of his studies and research, and talked freely on the problems of the "Ku-shih-pien" School, early Chinese history, the studies of excavated documents, "the Method of Dual Evidence", "Times of the Five Lords", etc. From his viewpoint, the "Ku-shih-pien" School is correct in the general orientation on the knowledge of the early history, but needs much redress in textual criticism, therefore nowadays, we should assimilate its historical skepticism with discrimination. Since the 1970s, there has emerged a large amount of excavated books and records, yet to the studies of the excavated documents, the handed-down ancient Classics and the studies of the Classics done by scholars through the ages are still the foundation. The main problem with the current Chinese classical studies, including the studies of excavated documents, does not lie in the lack of theory or method, but in the lack of scientific attitude on the part of the researchers. We must advocate academic morality and conscience, as well as a realistic and matter-of-the-fact attitude that holds everything for the purpose of the academics itself.
THE METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES OF HUMAN GEOGRAPHY RESEARCHES IN MAINLAND CHINA

Tang Mao-lin

Abstract:Great progress has been made in the research and education of human geography in mainland China.With the rapid development of human geography in the world and the further advance of reform in other spheres in China,some methodological problems in the research of human geography emerged,including the lack or absence of five kinds of academic consciousness(problem consciousness,academic historical consciousness,dialogue consciousness,theoretical consciousness and consciousness of academic norms).Such a situation hinders the development of human geography in China.The reason why there is lack of problem consciousness of human geography researches in mainland China is that there are many papers which are not problem-oriented.The lack is due to the poor postgraduate education,the wrong academic evaluation system and the tradition of the absence of discuss on problems existing in the society and academia.Many Chinese human geography papers cite limited literatures although great progress has been made in the last three decades.This indicates that many human geographers in China lack of the academic historical consciousness and dialogue consciousness,because they just state their own opinions and findings,and pay little attention to the researches of others,and they cannot make a strong academic base of the consulting service.Besides the above substantial academic issues,there are still some formal issues in the academic writings by Chinese human geographers,compared with the national standard or the Anglo-American counterparts.China needs its own 'Chicago Manual of Style'.In order to take part in the world competition of academy,economic development and institution,it is necessary for China to strengthen the consciousness of academic history,dialogue,theory problems and academic norms to make the researches being problem-oriented and theory-oriented,and have enough local bases as well as have original findings.

Political Science,Geography
On the Remaining Problems of the Editor of Yutai Xinyong

WU Guan-wen,ZHANG Pei-heng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0257-0289.2011.03.002

2011-01-01

Abstract:Through analyzing the catalogues of history records such as the new and old Book of Tang,the description of the relationship between Xu Ling and Chen Shubao,Zhang Lihua in the Book of Chen and some other historical and literary works,and the habits of people addressing each other in the Southern Dynasties,this paper makes a further investigation on some remaining problems in discussion of the editor of Yutai Xinyong began in 2004.Thus the authors stress their point that Yutai Xinyong was impossibly edited by Xu Ling.
Also on the Relationship Between Land Surveys and the Community Self-Monitoring System in Huizhou in Late Ming and Early Qing

夏维中,王裕明

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-7278.2002.04.016

2002-01-01

Abstract:In his Land Surveys and the Community Self-Monitoring System in Huizhou in Late Ming by Examining the ' Conflict of the Xie Family' in Qimen County ( History Studies , 2000. 1), Quan Rongyan touched on the relationship between land surveys and the community self-monitoring system in Huizhuo in Late Ming from the perspectives of land measure units and the choice and transfer of personnel, and to a certain degree clarified some long-time misunderstandings in the Ming studies. However, his analyses and conclusions concerning the choice and transfer of personnel , organization, division of duties and document filing and signature seem oversimplified and subjective .
An Analysis on 2007 Hot Spots in Study of Art and Literature

Wang Zhenglong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-9853.2008.03.022

2008-01-01

Abstract:The year 2008 marks the 30th anniversary of China's reform and opening up,and many scholars have made conclusion and introspection on the study of art and literature during 30 years.With this academic background,there are several hot spots: how to evaluate the achievement and the limitation of literary theoretics,whether there is an academic tradition in modern Chinese literary theoretics,what the predicament in constructing the academic system is,and what the solution should be.In researching field,the relationship between media and literature is emphasized,the discussion about editing teaching materials of literary theoretics and education reform goes deeper and further,and the discussion about literary forms and narrative style is in a lively atmosphere.
A New Study on the Nationality Issue Concerning the Creation of Chinese Novels in 1990s of the Twentieth Century

Wenqing Li

2004-01-01

Abstract:The issue, as a writing hotspot of Chinese literature in the 20th century has been given a significant attention by writers. The several literature trends of thought in the 1900s have inherited the fine tradition to concern about and reform nationality causing the research and exploration of the issue of to manifest a large number of new traits and laying a solid theoretical foundation for the final raising of the national characters.
The Study on "xiaoshi": a Sample of Critisism

陈均

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-6320.2003.06.012

2003-01-01

Abstract:Ever since it was born,the discourse Model of the Chinese New Poetry has concentrated so much on Xiaoshi - as a typical modality of the Early Poetry,from it's popularity to it's downturn.The critisisms that ever refer to Xiaoshi ,are not only rooted in the self-designing and the self-image that the early New Poetry ever made for but also have embodied the mechanism that how modern literature was brought into forth.
A New Study on OUYANG Xiu's Suppression towards "the Literary Style in Imperial College"

Xie Yan

Abstract:This paper discusses OUYANG Xiu's suppression towards "the literary style in Imperial College" from the perspective of political history.It argues that the main motive of OUYANG Xiu was not only literary renovation,but also risisted the political habits of the impatient students who often discussed current affairs in a bad manner.This manner came from the scholar-officials who intensely participated in political affairs from Qingli Age to Jiayou Age.OUYANG Xiu tried his best to maitain the appropriate order of the government and took great pains in mediating between the passionate officials who could easily go to extremes.Although pinned hopes on the next generation,OUYANG Xiu ultimately failed to hold back the radical political manner.His political attitude and experiences were considerably representative at that time.

History,Political Science,Engineering
A STUDY ON DIFFERENCES OF SENSE OF PLACE BETWEEN TOURISTS AND LOCALS:A CASE STUDY OF TUNXI OLD STREET,HUANGSHAN

QIU Hui,ZHOU Qiang,ZHAO Ning-xi,CHENG Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2012.06.024

2012-01-01

Human Geography

Abstract:While the rapid development of tourism industry brings considerable income for the locals,it also causes more and more conflicts between local people and tourists.However,there exists a close relationship between the emerging conflicts and tourists and locals' cognition and emotion of the destination.The great impacts of tourism development are mainly reflected in the differences of sense of place between tourists and locals.This paper selects the Tunxi Old Street as the study area,and designs the questionnaire from three dimensions: place cognition;place attachment and place behavioral intension.The three parts are subdivided into 12 factors: 1) self pole;2) self-others pole;3) others pole;4) other-environment pole;5) environment pole;6) environment-self pole;7) place identity;8) place dependence;9) use of ancient architecture;10) life style;11) space utilization;and 12) atmosphere.Under the framework of measuring system,a questionnaire survey had been carried out aiming to tourists and locals in Tunxi Old Street,on a sample pool of 450 representative tourists and 229 locals to carry out a comparative analysis of behavioral differences between tourists and local people.The study three key finds.Firstly,at the place cognition level,tourists pay more attention to destination and their interaction,while residents are more concerned about the "self" and "environment" aspects.This difference is largely due to the different cognitive styles of the streets.Secondly,at the place attachment level,tourists have a more great sense of place attachment than the local residents.This finding is contrary to the usual research findings.Because commercial is the street's core cultural,so residents are more concerned about that if the street can bring more economic profits for them.Thirdly,at the place behavioral intension level,though both are in favor of the street protection,there is a significant difference as to the "modernization" factor.This difference is largely caused by their different demand of life.
Disciplinary Contemplation and Exploration:About an Understanding of "A History of Chinese Modern & Contemporary Literature and Ecological Field"

YAO Xiao-lei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-8254.2011.01.003

2011-01-01

Abstract:A History of Chinese Modern Contemporary Literature and Ecological Fieldby Wu Xiu-ming is his years'accumulation in his research of Chinese modern contemporary literature.In this book,there is rational analysis of pioneering problems as well as his personal experience in independent compilation of the book.It is worthwhile reading in that an exploration is made of the understanding of Chinese modern contemporary literature with the help of ecological literature creation practice and ecological criticism theory both at home and abroad.
The Dilemmas and Main Issues in the Research of the Historical Documents of Contemporary Chinese Literature

Wu Xiuming,Zhang Tao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2012.12.261

2013-01-01

Abstract:The research on the historical documents of contemporary Chinese literature has long been neglected,which has directly affected the construction and development of the discipline.This phenomenon is inevitable,considering the various factors in history,reality,research subjects,etc.that have exerted their influence on the research.Firstly,the research on the historical documents of contemporary literature is faced with the pressure from history.Since contemporary literature has long been subjected to the literature-politics ″integration,″ the production,preservation,dissemination,discovery and interpretation of historical documents have been greatly influenced and regulated by political ideology,and the case was especially true in the first three decades(1949-1979).On the other hand,the historical documents which have secured a place in the political ideology arena may have strong subjective assumptions.What is worse,some even confuse right and wrong.The historical documents and their research in the new era(after 1979) have not yet completely broken away from the control and influence of ideology.Some of them involve sensitive issues and have been sealed in the archives,and the long delay of disclosure leads to a number of artificially-constructed blanks in historical documents.Secondly,the ″openness of post-modernization″ of contemporary literature brings brand-new issues to its historical documents.First of all,although new technology has been introduced to facilitate document storage,retrieval and sorting,it has also challenged previous approaches,expediting the shift from the traditional textual criticism to modern historical document science.Next,under the influence of marketization,some vulgar historical documents are just intended to appeal with sensational content,blurring the distinction between serious research and public entertainment.This finds evidence in the composition and even fabrication of private historical documents without any careful research,as well as the vulgarization and re-narration of ″Red Literature.″ Finally,in the context of globalization,the research,preservation and distribution of literature in Hong Kong,Macau,Taiwan and overseas should also be an object of study and become an important part of the historical documents of contemporary Chinese literature.Thirdly,research subjects are the ultimate causes of problems in the research of historical documents.The lack of awareness of the importance of historical materials in contemporary literature is intimately related with the ″pan-theorization″ in 1980s.This ″intransitive″ trend(historical documents) played a dynamic role in the ″theory mode;″ meanwhile,it intentionally or unintentionally contributed to the academic orientation of over-interpretation and under-empiricism.As a consequence,academic research is diverged considerably from the realistic context and is heavily reliant on the excessive import of western theories,which is partly responsible for the fickleness in contemporary literature research.To promote and develop the discipline,it is necessary for researchers in historical documents to reflect on and improve their subject cognition and literary qualities.

Controversy about Cao Xue-Qin's Hometown

Dispute of ″Jinwen″ and ″Guwen″ and Orientation of Confucianism under the Background of ″National Calamity″

To "Cai ", "Hu" about A Dream of Red Mansions Another Research That Dispute ——And Concurrently Talks about the Friendship between Two People

A Historical Investigation and Classification Analysis of Seven Controversies on the Reform and Abolition of the 1300-Year Chinese Imperial Examination System

The Local Chinese Community's Doubt and Confusion From Lu Yao's Fiction

Discussion on Three Issues about Hong Xue——Preface of What is Hong Xue

China's new Towns in Controversy: A Literature Review

An Inspiration of Theoretical Awareness in Translation Assessment and Research——On the significance of the dispute over Chinese translations of Le Rouge et le Noir

Hometown in the Memory of Literature Writing

LU Xun's Verdict about JIN Sheng-tan's Cutting the Water Margin in Half Should Not Be Reversed

The "Ku-shih-pien" School, "Method of Dual Evidence" and correlated problems:an interview with Mr.Qiu Xigui

THE METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES OF HUMAN GEOGRAPHY RESEARCHES IN MAINLAND CHINA

On the Remaining Problems of the Editor of Yutai Xinyong

Also on the Relationship Between Land Surveys and the Community Self-Monitoring System in Huizhou in Late Ming and Early Qing

An Analysis on 2007 Hot Spots in Study of Art and Literature

A New Study on the Nationality Issue Concerning the Creation of Chinese Novels in 1990s of the Twentieth Century

The Study on "xiaoshi": a Sample of Critisism

A New Study on OUYANG Xiu's Suppression towards "the Literary Style in Imperial College"

A STUDY ON DIFFERENCES OF SENSE OF PLACE BETWEEN TOURISTS AND LOCALS:A CASE STUDY OF TUNXI OLD STREET,HUANGSHAN

Disciplinary Contemplation and Exploration:About an Understanding of "A History of Chinese Modern & Contemporary Literature and Ecological Field"

The Dilemmas and Main Issues in the Research of the Historical Documents of Contemporary Chinese Literature