The Identification and Discrimination of Tone2 and Tone3 in Mandarin:The Influence of Experimental Design on Categorical Perception of Tones

Yunjia Wang,Xihang Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7509/j.linsci.201504.029558

2015-01-01

Abstract:This paper aims to investigate two questions by categorical-perception experiments. The first question is if identification and discrimination of Tone2 and Tone3 are all categorical,and the second is how stimuli design and experimental task influences perceptual results.The stimuli consist of four continuums of falling-rising tones with different falling magnitudes and different ending pit-ches,and the independent variable is the pitch turning position on a falling-rising pitch curve.The re-sults demonstrate two facts:1 )Identification of Tone2 and Tone3 is categorical under the condition of small falling magnitude and high ending pitch,or large falling magnitude and low ending pitch;2 ) The results of discrimination in the two experiments are all unrelated to those of identification,and the discrimination is slightly categorical or non-categorical when the corresponding identification is strongly categorical.We hold that pitch decay in memory,allophones of Tone2 and Tone3 in continu-ous speech,and response bias of subj ects in discrimination tasks probably have effects on discrimina-tion results.We hypothesize that the perceptual pattern of two tones that have similar but not totally identical contours is between typically categorical and non-categorical.