Abstract:In recent years, protein structure problems have become a hotspot for understanding protein folding and function mechanisms. It has been observed that most of the protein structure works rely on and benefit from co-evolutionary information obtained by multiple sequence alignment (MSA). As an example, AlphaFold2 (AF2) is a typical MSA-based protein structure tool which is famous for its high accuracy.As a consequence, these MSA-based methods are limited by the quality of the MSAs. Especially for orphan proteins that have no homologous sequence, AlphaFold2 performs unsatisfactorily as MSA depth decreases, which may pose a barrier to its widespread application in protein mutation and design problems in which there are no rich homologous sequences and rapid prediction is needed. In this paper, we constructed two standard datasets for orphan and de novo proteins which have insufficient/none homology information, called Orphan62 and Design204, respectively, to fairly evaluate the performance of the various methods in this case. Then, depending on whether or not utilizing scarce MSA information, we summarized two approaches, MSA-enhanced and MSA-free methods, to effectively solve the issue without sufficient MSAs. MSA-enhanced model aims to improve poor MSA quality from the data source by knowledge distillation and generation models. MSA-free model directly learns the relationship between residues on enormous protein sequences from pre-trained models, bypassing the step of extracting the residue pair representation from MSA. Next, we evaluated the performance of four MSA-free methods (trRosettaX-Single, TRFold, ESMFold and ProtT5) and MSA-enhanced (Bagging MSA) method compared with a traditional MSA-based method AlphaFold2, in two protein structure-related prediction tasks, respectively. Comparison analyses show that trRosettaX-Single and ESMFold which belong to MSA-free method can achieve fast prediction (similar to 40s) and comparable performance compared with AF2 in tertiary structure prediction, especially for short peptides, alpha-helical segments and targets with few homologous sequences. Bagging MSA utilizing MSA enhancement improves the accuracy of our trained base model which is an MSA-based method when poor homology information exists in secondary structure prediction. Our study provides biologists an insight of how to select rapid and appropriate prediction tools for enzyme engineering and peptide drug development.

The applicability of predicting protein structures with residue substitutions using homology modeling

Prediction of Functional Class of Proteins and Peptides Irrespective of Sequence Homology by Support Vector Machines.

Structure-based Prediction of the Effects of a Missense Variant on Protein Stability.

Parallel Model for Computational Prediction of Protein Point-mutation

Assessing computational tools for predicting protein stability changes upon missense mutations using a new dataset

Predicting non-neutral missense mutations and their biochemical consequences using genome-scale homology modeling of human protein complexes

STRUM: structure-based prediction of protein stability changes upon single-point mutation

Progress in Protein Structure Prediction

High-accuracy protein structures by combining machine-learning with physics-based refinement

Homology modeling in drug discovery: Overview, current applications, and future perspectives

Combining Network Topological Characteristics With Sequence And Structure Based Features For Predicting Protein Stability Changes Upon Single Amino Acid Mutation

Prediction Of Function Changes Associated With Single-Point Protein Mutations Using Support Vector Machines (Svms)

Improved Structure-Related Prediction for Insufficient Homologous Proteins Using MSA Enhancement and Pre-Trained Language Model

Effective High-Accuracy Prediction of Protein Structures from Easily Obtainable Artificial Homologous Sequences by Structure-Stability-Based Selection

Comparing Supervised Learning and Rigorous Approach for Predicting Protein Stability upon Point Mutations in Difficult Targets

PROTEIN STRUCTURE PREDICTION: AN IN-DEPTH COMPARISON OF APPROACHES AND TOOLS

Low Homologous Protein Structure Prediction

Missense mutations: Backbone structure positional effects

A comparative study of available software for high-accuracy homology modeling: from sequence alignments to structural models

Homology modeling in the time of collective and artificial intelligence

Drsp: A Structural Database for Single Residue Substitutions in Pdb