Understanding Space-Group

Yuexiang ZHU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3866/PKU.DXHX201811014

2019-01-01

University Chemistry

Abstract:Knowledge of space-group and symmetrically equivalent points as well as asymmetric unit was briefly introduced according to the International Tables for Crystallography.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Space groups – the final frontier: a tutorial guided tour of some entries in International Tables for Crystallography Volume A

William Clegg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0889311x.2024.2306557

2024-02-17

Crystallography Reviews

Abstract:After an introductory section providing some basic foundation, definitions, and terminology regarding space group symmetry in crystal structures, three particular examples are selected to demonstrate the information given for each space-group type in the standard reference book International Tables for Crystallography Volume A (current sixth edition). The format and layout of the information is explained, and the most important items of the content are described, together with some practical applications. This treatment should enable readers unfamiliar with the tables to use them confidently in understanding and interpreting crystal structures belonging to these and other space-group types.

crystallography
Discussion about Crystallography Teaching Content

ZHAO Shan-rong,WANG Qin-yan,XIAO Ping

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-985x.2007.01.051

2007-01-01

Abstract:In this paper,the concepts and ideas about the periodic lattice of crystal structure,the composition of symmetric elements and the relationship between geometric and crystallographic forms were discussed.Some basic problems which had not obtained enough attention of us in the past have been realized.This is important for the development of crystallography.
Enumeration and representation theory of spin space groups

Xiaobing Chen,Jun Ren,Yanzhou Zhu,Yutong Yu,Ao Zhang,Pengfei Liu,Jiayu Li,Yuntian Liu,Caiheng Li,Qihang Liu

2024-05-17

Abstract:Those fundamental physical properties, such as phase transitions, Weyl fermions, and spin excitation, in all magnetic ordered materials, were ultimately believed to rely on the symmetry theory of magnetic space groups. Recently, it has come to light that a more comprehensive group, known as the spin space group (SSG), which combines separate spin and spatial operations, is necessary to fully characterize the geometry and underlying properties of magnetic ordered materials. However, the basic theory of SSG has seldom been developed. In this work, we present a systematic study of the enumeration and the representation theory of SSG. Starting from the 230 crystallographic space groups and finite translation groups with a maximum order of 8, we establish an extensive collection of over 100000 SSGs under a four-index nomenclature as well as the International notation. We then identify inequivalent SSGs specifically applicable to collinear, coplanar, and noncoplanar magnetic configurations. To facilitate the identification of SSG, we develop an online program (

Materials Science
Unified Theory of Quantum Crystalline Symmetries

Y. X. Zhao,L. B. Shao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2009.07483

2020-09-16

Abstract:Symmetry groups are projectively represented in quantum mechanics, and crystalline symmetries are fundamental in condensed matter physics. Here, we systematically present a unified theory of quantum mechanical space groups from two complementary aspects. First, we provide a decomposition form for the space-group factor systems to characterize all quantum space groups. It consists of three factors, the factor system for the translation subgroup $L$, an in-homogeneous factor system for the point group $P$, and a factor connecting $L$ and $P$. The three factors satisfy three consistency equations, which are exactly solvable and can completely exhaust all factor systems for space groups. Second, since factors systems are classified by the second cohomology group, we show the (co)homology groups for space groups can be derived from Borel's equivariant (co)homology theory, which leads to an algorithm that can compute all (co)homology groups for space groups. To demonstrate the general theory, we explicitly present quantum wallpaper groups with the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ gauge group. Furthermore, as a primitive application, we find the time-reversal invariant quantum space groups with inversion symmetry can lead to a novel clifford band theory, where each band is fourfold degenerate to represent certain real Clifford algebras with topologically nontrivial pinor structures over the Brillouin zone. Our work serves as a foundation for exploring quantum mechanical space groups, and can find applications in spin liquids, unconventional superconductors, and artificial lattice systems, including cold atoms, photonic and phononic crystals, and even LC electric circuit networks.

Mathematical Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Other Condensed Matter,Strongly Correlated Electrons
Teaching Molecular Symmetry of Dihedral Point Groups by Drawing Useful 2D Projections

Lan Chen,Hongwei Sun,Chengming Lai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/ed500898p

IF: 3.208

2015-01-01

Journal of Chemical Education

Abstract:There are two main difficulties in studying molecular symmetry of dihedral point groups. One is locating the C2 axes perpendicular to the Cn axis, while the other is finding the σd planes which pass through the Cn axis and bisect the angles formed by adjacent C2 axes. In this paper, a method of learning to draw 2D projections has been proposed to identify symmetry elements. Molecules with similar projective polygons are also compared to discuss the differences in point groups.
Chemistry for Space Group Symmetry beyond Crystals

Takashiro Akitsu,Yuya Higashi,Rin Tsuchiya,Taiga Imae,Keishiro Komatsu,Daisuke Nakane,Dohyun Moon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/sym16030319

2024-03-08

Symmetry

Abstract:As a recent cutting-edge research target, the prediction of crystal systems or space groups using machine learning based on databases has been actively reported [...]

multidisciplinary sciences
Different Teaching Way to Space Group and Symmetry Operation: Polyhedral Vs Ball

J. Zhou,H. Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1107/s2053273314086100

2014-01-01

Abstract:To introduce the regulations of space group combining with a symmetry operation, put an orientation ball at a position shift away from the lattice tops is a good way [1]. However, based on the fundamental knowledge of "lattice", it often occurs that the tops of a lattice "should be" the positions of "atom balls" thought by most beginnings in teaching practice. This "thought" leads them never deduce out those regulations in symmetry operations and often misleads a wrong conclusion. As a beginning one wishes watching movies and pictures instead of mathematical deduction or vector calculation. It easily arises that a lattice has eight tops with atom balls. This "idea" lets the orientation balls shifting away from the lattice tops become difficult to understand. Nevertheless, the balls with a sign of "comma" in the middle are also difficult to understand that they can stand for a certain orientation because ball is circle. "Tops" and "directions" are two troubles in learning crystallographic symmetry and symmetry operations for those beginnings. How to guide them to overcome the two fences is an important step that will lead those beginnings to a never understanding status, on one hand, or let them understand throughout all regulations of space group(s) combining with a symmetry operation on the other. From teaching practice, a polyhedral at lattice tops could overcome both difficulties at position and in orientation. First, a polyhedral is always in orientation, even it is a cubic. This is easily understood. Secondly the centre of a polyhedral could easily meet with the tops of a lattice; it lets students easily understand "a lattice has eight tops occupied – a natural thought by beginnings". This way let them easily understand and deduce all regulations in crystallographic symmetry operations, such as a body-centred lattice combining with a symmetry plane (m) produces n symmetry operation at 1/4t, etc. see figures below.
Quantitative mappings between symmetry and topology in solids

Zhida Song,Tiantian Zhang,Zhong Fang,Chen Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-06010-w

IF: 16.6

2018-08-30

Nature Communications

Abstract:The study of spatial symmetries was accomplished during the last century and had greatly improved our understanding of the properties of solids. Nowadays, the symmetry data of any crystal can be readily extracted from standard first-principles calculation. On the other hand, the topological data (topological invariants), the defining quantities of nontrivial topological states, are in general considerably difficult to obtain, and this difficulty has critically slowed down the search for topological materials. Here we provide explicit and exhaustive mappings from symmetry data to topological data for arbitrary gapped band structure in the presence of time-reversal symmetry and any one of the 230 space groups. The mappings are completed using the theoretical tools of layer construction and symmetry-based indicators. With these results, finding topological invariants in any given gapped band structure reduces to a simple search in the mapping tables provided.

multidisciplinary sciences
General Theory of Momentum-Space Nonsymmorphic Symmetry

Chen Zhang,Z. Y. Chen,Zheng Zhang,Y. X. Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.130.256601

2023-06-26

Abstract:As a fundamental concept of all crystals, space groups are partitioned into symmorphic groups and nonsymmorphic groups. Each nonsymmorphic group contains glide reflections or screw rotations with fractional lattice translations, which are absent in symmorphic groups. Although nonsymmorphic groups ubiquitously exist on real-space lattices, on the reciprocal lattices in momentum space, the ordinary theory only allows symmorphic groups. In this work, we develop a novel theory for momentum-space nonsymmorphic space groups (k-NSGs), utilizing the projective representations of space groups. The theory is quite general: Given any k-NSGs in any dimensions, it can identify the real-space symmorphic space groups (r-SSGs) and construct the corresponding projective representation of the r-SSG that leads to the k-NSG. To demonstrate the broad applicability of our theory, we show these projective representations and therefore all k-NSGs can be realized by gauge fluxes over real-space lattices. Our work fundamentally extends the framework of crystal symmetry, and therefore can accordingly extend any theory based on crystal symmetry, for instance the classification crystalline topological phases.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Materials Science
Classification of Crystalline Topological Insulators and Superconductors with Point Group Symmetries

Eyal Cornfeld,Adam Chapman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.99.075105

2019-01-24

Abstract:Crystalline topological phases have recently attracted a lot of experimental and theoretical attention. Key advances include the complete elementary band representation analyses of crystalline matter by symmetry indicators and the discovery of higher-order hinge and corner states. However, current classification schemes of such phases are either implicit or limited in scope. We present a new scheme for the explicit classification of crystalline topological insulators and superconductors. These phases are protected by crystallographic point group symmetries and are characterized by bulk topological invariants. The classification paradigm generalizes the Clifford algebra extension process of each Altland-Zirnbauer symmetry class and utilizes algebras which incorporate the point group symmetry. Explicit results for all point group symmetries of three-dimensional crystals are presented as well as for all symmorphic layer groups of two-dimensional crystals. We discuss future extensions for treatment of magnetic crystals and defected or higher-dimensional systems as well as weak and fragile invariants.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity,Mathematical Physics
Spin Space Groups: Full Classification and Applications

Zhenyu Xiao,Jianzhou Zhao,Yanqi Li,Ryuichi Shindou,Zhi-Da Song

2024-05-18

Abstract:In this work, we exhaust all the spin-space symmetries, which fully characterize collinear, non-collinear, commensurate, and incommensurate spiral magnetism, and investigate enriched features of electronic bands that respect these symmetries. We achieve this by systematically classifying the so-called spin space groups (SSGs) - joint symmetry groups of spatial and spin operations that leave the magnetic structure unchanged. Generally speaking, they are accurate (approximate) symmetries in systems where spin-orbit coupling (SOC) is negligible (finite but weaker than the interested energy scale); but we also show that specific SSGs could remain valid even in the presence of a strong SOC. By representing the SSGs as O($N$) representations, we - for the first time - obtain the complete classifications of 1421, 9542, and 56512 distinct SSGs for collinear ($N=1$), coplanar ($N=2$), and non-coplanar ($N=3$) magnetism, respectively. SSG not only fully characterizes the symmetry of spin d.o.f., but also gives rise to exotic electronic states, which, in general, form projective representations of magnetic space groups (MSGs). Surprisingly, electronic bands in SSGs exhibit features never seen in MSGs, such as nonsymmorphic SSG Brillouin zone (BZ), where SSG operations behave as glide or screw when act on momentum and unconventional spin-momentum locking, which is completely determined by SSG, independent of Hamiltonian details. To apply our theory, we identify the SSG for each of the 1604 published magnetic structures in the MAGNDATA database on the Bilbao Crystallographic Server. Material examples exhibiting aforementioned novel features are discussed with emphasis. We also investigate new types of SSG-protected topological electronic states that are unprecedented in MSGs.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science
Enumeration of spin-space groups: Towards a complete description of symmetries of magnetic orders

Yi Jiang,Ziyin Song,Tiannian Zhu,Zhong Fang,Hongming Weng,Zheng-Xin Liu,Jian Yang,Chen Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.14.031039

2024-08-30

Abstract:Symmetries of three-dimensional periodic scalar fields are described by 230 space groups (SGs). Symmetries of three-dimensional periodic (pseudo-) vector fields, however, are described by the spin-space groups (SSGs), which were initially used to describe the symmetries of magnetic orders. In SSGs, the real-space and spin degrees of freedom are unlocked in the sense that an operation could have different spacial and spin rotations. SSGs gives a complete symmetry description of magnetic structures, and have natural applications in the band theory of itinerary electrons in magnetically ordered systems with weak spin-orbit coupling. Altermagnetism, a concept raised recently that belongs to the symmetry-compensated collinear magnetic orders but has non-relativistic spin splitting, is well described by SSGs. Due to the vast number and complicated group structures, SSGs have not yet been systematically enumerated. In this work, we exhaust SSGs based on the invariant subgroups of SGs, with spin operations constructed from three-dimensional (3D) real representations of the quotient groups for the invariant subgroups. For collinear and coplanar magnetic orders, the spin operations can be reduced into lower dimensional real representations. As the number of SSGs is infinite, we only consider SSGs that describe magnetic unit cells up to 12 times crystal unit cells. We obtain 157,289 non-coplanar, 24,788 coplanar-non-collinear, and 1,421 collinear SSGs. The enumerated SSGs are stored in an online database at \url{<a class="link-external link-https" href="https://cmpdc.iphy.ac.cn/ssg" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>} with a user-friendly interface. We also develop an algorithm to identify SSG for realistic materials and find SSGs for 1,626 magnetic materials. Our results serve as a solid starting point for further studies of symmetry and topology in magnetically ordered materials.

Materials Science,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons
SUBGROUPS: a computer tool at the Bilbao Crystallographic Server for the study of pseudo‐symmetric or distorted structures

Emre S. Tasci,Luis Elcoro,J. Manuel Perez-Mato,Gemma de la Flor,Mois I. Aroyo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1107/s1600576724008070

IF: 4.868

2024-10-03

Journal of Applied Crystallography

Abstract:Documentation is presented for the SUBGROUPS tool at the Bilbao Crystallographic Server for the exploration of all possible symmetries resulting from the distortion of a higher‐symmetry parent structure (provided that the relation between the lattices of the distorted and parent structures is known).SUBGROUPS is a free online program at the Bilbao Crystallographic Server (https://www.cryst.ehu.es/). It permits the exploration of all possible symmetries resulting from the distortion of a higher‐symmetry parent structure, provided that the relation between the lattices of the distorted and parent structures is known. The program calculates all the subgroups of the parent space group which comply with this relation. The required minimal input is the space‐group information of the parent structure and the relation of the unit cell of the distorted or pseudo‐symmetric structure with that of the parent structure. Alternatively, the wavevector(s) observed in the diffraction data characterizing the distortion can be introduced. Additional conditions can be added, including filters related to space‐group representations. The program provides very detailed information on all the subgroups, including group–subgroup hierarchy graphs. If a Crystallographic Information Framework (CIF) file of the parent high‐symmetry structure is uploaded, the program generates CIF files of the parent structure described under each of the chosen lower symmetries. These CIF files may then be used as starting points for the refinement of the distorted structure under these possible symmetries. They can also be used for density functional theory calculations or for any other type of analysis. The power and efficiency of the program are illustrated with a few examples.

chemistry, multidisciplinary,crystallography
Unconventional superconducting gap structure protected by space group symmetry

Shuntaro Sumita,Youichi Yanase

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.97.134512

2019-10-03

Abstract:Recent superconducting gap classifications based on space group symmetry have revealed nontrivial gap structures that were not shown by point group symmetry. First, we review a comprehensive classification of symmetry-protected line nodes within the range of centrosymmetric space groups. Next, we sh...
Enumeration of Spin-Space Groups: Toward a Complete Description of Symmetries of Magnetic Orders

Yi Jiang,Ziyin Song,Tiannian Zhu,Zhong Fang,Hongming Weng,Zheng-Xin Liu,Jian Yang,and Chen Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevx.14.031039

2024-08-30

Physical Review X

Abstract:Symmetries of three-dimensional periodic scalar fields are described by 230 space groups (SGs). Symmetries of three-dimensional periodic (pseudo)vector fields, however, are described by the spin-space groups (SSGs), which were initially used to describe the symmetries of magnetic orders. In SSGs, the real-space and spin degrees of freedom are unlocked in the sense that an operation could have different spatial and spin rotations. SSGs give a complete symmetry description of magnetic structures and have natural applications in the band theory of itinerary electrons in magnetically ordered systems with weak spin-orbit coupling. Altermagnetism , a concept raised recently that belongs to the symmetry-compensated collinear magnetic orders but has nonrelativistic spin plitting, is well described by SSGs. Because of the vast number and complicated group structures, SSGs have not yet been systematically enumerated. In this work, we exhaust SSGs based on the invariant subgroups of SGs, with spin operations constructed from three-dimensional (3D) real representations of the quotient groups for the invariant subgroups. For collinear and coplanar magnetic orders, the spin operations can be reduced into lower-dimensional real representations. As the number of SSGs is infinite, we consider only SSGs that describe magnetic unit cells up to 12 times crystal unit cells. We obtain 157 289 noncoplanar, 24 788 coplanar-noncollinear, and 1421 collinear SSGs. The enumerated SSGs are stored in an online database with a user-friendly interface. We develop an algorithm to identify SSGs for realistic materials and find SSGs for 1626 magnetic materials. We also discuss several potential applications of SSGs, including the representation theory, topological states protected by SSGs, structures of spin textures, and refinement of magnetic neutron diffraction patterns using SSGs. Our results serve as a solid starting point for further studies of symmetry and topology in magnetically ordered materials. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.14.031039 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society

physics, multidisciplinary
Classification of time-reversal-invariant crystals with gauge structures

Z. Y. Chen,Zheng Zhang,Shengyuan A. Yang,Y. X. Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-36447-7

IF: 16.6

2023-02-10

Nature Communications

Abstract:Abstract A peculiar feature of quantum states is that they may embody so-called projective representations of symmetries rather than ordinary representations. Projective representations of space groups-the defining symmetry of crystals-remain largely unexplored. Despite recent advances in artificial crystals, whose intrinsic gauge structures necessarily require a projective description, a unified theory is yet to be established. Here, we establish such a unified theory by exhaustively classifying and representing all 458 projective symmetry algebras of time-reversal-invariant crystals from 17 wallpaper groups in two dimensions-189 of which are algebraically non-equivalent. We discover three physical signatures resulting from projective symmetry algebras, including the shift of high-symmetry momenta, an enforced nontrivial Zak phase, and a spinless eight-fold nodal point. Our work offers a theoretical foundation for the field of artificial crystals and opens the door to a wealth of topological states and phenomena beyond the existing paradigms.

multidisciplinary sciences
Crystal Symmetry, Group Theory, and Band Structure Calculations

Allen Nussbaum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0081-1947(08)60349-5

1966-01-01

Solid state physics

Abstract:Publisher Translational symmetry is responsible for the existence of energy bands, and the point symmetries—rotation, reflection, and inversion—determine the nature of these bands. This latter type has associated with it the feature of degeneracy, which would be expected intuitively to arise in the following fashion: when a crystal is subjected to a symmetry operation, its structure is unaffected. From this, it follows that the energy associated with the formation of this structure from a group of isolated atoms is the same for any one of the set of equivalent configurations. In terms of the Schrodinger equation, there is a single eigenvalue for a set of eigenfunctions corresponding to the various equivalent positions, which is precisely what is meant by degeneracy. A decrease in the amount of symmetry in a system should then have a corresponding effect on the degree of degeneracy, and this chapter shows that this is indeed the case. The analytical method of taking advantage of the crystalline symmetries, and which also permits a simple determination of the degeneracies, is based on a branch of algebra known as group theory. Because the main purpose in this chapter is to make the results of group theory accessible to experimental physicists, it introduces only those concepts which are necessary for the systems to be discussed.

physics, condensed matter
Advanced implication theory. Symmetry tables

Frantisek Pavelcik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1107/s2053273324000846

2024-01-26

Acta Crystallographica Section A Foundations and Advances

Abstract:Symmetry tables of multiple implication function for all 230 space groups are tabulated, including Fourier units. These can be edited for International Tables for Crystallography. An accurate method for calculation of a symmetry minimum function is also presented.

chemistry, multidisciplinary,crystallography

Understanding Space-Group

Space groups – the final frontier: a tutorial guided tour of some entries in International Tables for Crystallography Volume A

Discussion about Crystallography Teaching Content

Enumeration and representation theory of spin space groups

Unified Theory of Quantum Crystalline Symmetries

Teaching Molecular Symmetry of Dihedral Point Groups by Drawing Useful 2D Projections

Chemistry for Space Group Symmetry beyond Crystals

Different Teaching Way to Space Group and Symmetry Operation: Polyhedral Vs Ball

Quantitative mappings between symmetry and topology in solids

General Theory of Momentum-Space Nonsymmorphic Symmetry

Classification of Crystalline Topological Insulators and Superconductors with Point Group Symmetries

Spin Space Groups: Full Classification and Applications

Enumeration of spin-space groups: Towards a complete description of symmetries of magnetic orders

SUBGROUPS: a computer tool at the Bilbao Crystallographic Server for the study of pseudo‐symmetric or distorted structures

Unconventional superconducting gap structure protected by space group symmetry

Enumeration of Spin-Space Groups: Toward a Complete Description of Symmetries of Magnetic Orders

Classification of time-reversal-invariant crystals with gauge structures

Crystal Symmetry, Group Theory, and Band Structure Calculations

Advanced implication theory. Symmetry tables