Abstract:One‐dimensional site response analysis (1D SRA) remains the standard practice in considering the effect of local soil deposits and predicting site‐specific ground motions, although its range of applicability to realistic seismic wavefields is still in question. In this 1D approach, horizontal and vertical ground shaking are assumed to be induced by vertically propagating shear and compressional waves, respectively. A recent study based on analytical two‐dimensional (2D) plane waves and simple point source earthquake simulations has shown two mechanistic limitations in this 1D modelling technique for general inclined seismic waves, that is, systematic over‐prediction of the vertical motion and wave trapping in the 1D soil column. In this article, we evaluate in detail the applicability of this 1D modelling approach to realistic three‐dimensional (3D) simulated seismic wavefields in shallow sedimentary basins. Linear‐viscoelastic 1D SRA predictions using two types of input motions that are commonly used in practice—rock outcrop and in‐column motions, are compared with the reference true site response results from 3D earthquake simulations in terms of various measures in the frequency and time domain. It is shown that the horizontal motion in the 3D seismic wavefield exhibits dominant shear wave propagation phenomenon, while the vertical motion is a combined effect of compressional and shear waves and can be over‐predicted by the 1D approach when the incident seismic waves are inclined. Direct evidence of the wave refraction process that leads to the vertical motion over‐prediction is provided. 1D SRA with in‐column inputs can yield motions that have significantly longer duration compared to the true 3D site response solution due to trapped waves, casting in doubt the frequent need for increased soil damping in existing site studies to compensate for wave attenuation due to scattering alone. Sensitivity investigation on the increase of soil profile damping by a multiplier Dmul shows Dmul values compatible with those found in the literature for both horizontal and vertical motions. It is shown that the level of Dmul optimized for a best match of the spectral acceleration is dependent on the characteristic of the input motion and a larger Dmul is typically required for the vertical component. In contrast, 1D SRA with outcrop motions predicts motions with shorter significant duration due to its inability to capture the basin‐edge generated surface waves. A suite of ground motion simulations was performed to assess the sensitivity of the observations to the basin geologic structure including the velocity gradient, rock‐basin impedance contrast and basin depth. The analysis results show that the accuracy of the simplified 1D procedure is dependent on the wavefield composition of both the input motions and the true 3D site response solution. While the horizontal motions in shallow sedimentary basins can, to the first order, be reasonably captured by the simplified 1D approach, 1D SRA for the vertical component is in general not reliable and contributions from inclined shear waves should be accounted for in site‐specific evaluation of the vertical design ground motion.

Study of the Effect of Surface Sediment Characteristics on Earthquake Ground Motion

Surface Sediment Effects on Teleseismic P Wave Amplitude

Seismic Ground Motion Amplification in a 3D Sedimentary Basin: the Effect of the Vertical Velocity Gradient

Effect of Vertical Velocity Gradient on Ground Motion in A Sediment-Filled Basin Due to Incident Sv Wave

Large-scale simulation of ground motion amplification considering 3D topography and subsurface soils

A centrifuge study on the effect of the water cover on the ground motion of saturated marine sediments

Centrifuge Test Of Dry Sand And Saturated Sand Ground Seismic Response Under Earthquake Sequence

Parametric models for ground motion amplification considering 3D topography and subsurface soils

An Analytical Solution to the Scattering of Cylindrical SH Waves by a Partially Filled Semi-Circular Alluvial Valley: Near-Source Site Effects

The influence of seabed on offshore ground motion

Study of Ground Vibration Site Effects on Substation in Inhomogeneous Strata

Resolving near surface S velocity structure in natural earthquake frequency band: A case study in Beijing region

Investigation and Use of Surface-wave Characteristics for Near-surface Applications

Amplification Effect of Ground Motion in Offshore Meandering Sedimentary Valley

Applicability of 1D site response analysis to shallow sedimentary basins: A critical evaluation through physics‐based 3D ground motion simulations

Parametric Models for 3D topographic amplification of Ground Motions Considering Subsurface Soils

Effect of Nearby Ground Structures on the Seismic Response of Underground Structures in Saturated Sand

Seismic Amplification of Soil Ground with Spatially Varying Shear Wave Velocity Using 2D Spectral Element Method

Investigation of the effects of different layering characteristics on the response of semi-sine hills

Observations and analyses of site amplification effects of deep liquefiable soil deposits by geotechnical downhole array

Effects of Canyon Topography and Geological Conditions on Strong Ground Motion