The Application and Comparison of Three Toxicity Models for Predicting the Cadmium Toxicity to Wheat (Triticum aestivum)

Yan Zheng,Xueyuan Gu,Yang Jiang,Jian Xu,Liangyan Chen,Xiaorong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7524/AJE.1673-5897.20160715002
2017-01-01
Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology
Abstract:Some toxicity models based on metal speciation,have been widely applied in aquatic and terrestrial ecosystem,such as Free Ion Activity Model (FIAM),Biotic Ligand Model (BLM),and Gouy-Chapman-Stem Model (GCSM).However,the systematic comparison of these models was deficient.In this study,cadmium (Cd) toxicity to wheat root elongation was tested using hydroponic experiments.The three models were developed by nonlinear firing of the experimental data.The models were compared using three different endpoints:relative root elongation (RE),Cd concentration on the root surfaces,and the uptake of Cd in wheat roots.In addition,citric acid (CA) and malate acid (MA) were used to investigate the effect of organic ligands to Cd toxicity.Results showed that Ca2+ and H+ were competitive cations to Cd2+,while Na+,K+ and Mg2+ were not.BLM performed the best prediction for the three endpoints because it considered both free ion activity and competition effects in the solution.FIAM and GCSM only considered the free ion activity and ignored the effect of competitive effect of Ca2+ and H+,thus their prediction was worse than BLM.Results also showed that despite the presence of organic ligands (CA or MA) lowered the activity of free Cd,the toxicity remained the same.It suggested that Cd toxicity to wheat was mainly controlled by the diffusion process rather than internalization,which might be why the FIAM and GCSM performances were not as good as BLM.Results found in this study can provide better understanding of Cd toxicity model in terrestrial system.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?