Clinical effects of two kinds of silver agents on Pseudomonas aeruginosa wound infections in deep Ⅱ degree burn patients:a comparative study

Jing-mei DING,Wu-ping LI,Jiao-yue QIAN,Xiao-zhi BAI,Da-hai HU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11816/cn.ni.2014-142824
2014-01-01
Abstract:OBJECTIVE To observe the effects of the most commonly used silver agents such as aid antibacterial cream and SilverCare nano-silver antibacterial gel on the Pseudomonas aeruginosa wound infection in the deep Ⅱdegree burn patients so as to provide guidance for drug dressing in outpatient department .METHODS Totally 54 Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats with two consistent deep second degree burn were infected with P .aeruginosa on the back , the rats were randomly divided into three groups , the group A received BangerkangTM Burn-aid antibacterial cream ,the group B received SilverCare nano-silver antibacterial gel ,and the group C received nothing as the control group via the conventional dressing method .The reduction in content of bacteria in the burned tissues after drug dressing ,the contraction rate during the wound healing ,the epithelialization rate ,and the time of wound healing were recorded;the data were statistically analyzed by using SPSS19 .0 software .RESULTS There was significant difference in the bacterial quantitative difference between the three groups of SD rats before and after drug dressing ,the group A has the greatest difference (1 .67 ± 0 .294) × 108 CFU/g and the highest bacterial inhibition rate (83 .46 ± 1 .38 )% , there was statistically significant difference ( P< 0 .05 ) . There was no statistically significant difference in the contraction rate of wound in the early stage of burn between the two groups;with the increase of frequency of drug dressing ,the difference became greater and greater ;the difference in the contraction rate of wound narrowed in the late stage of wound healing .The epithelialization rate of the group B was (94 .84 ± 3 .34)% on day 16 of the burn wound ,significantly higher than (78 .99 ± 6 .56)% of the group A and (64 .88 ± 5 .78)% of the group C ,there was statistically significant difference (P< 0 .05);the epithelialization rate of the group A was higher than that of the group C ,with significant difference (P<0 .05) . The time of wound healing was the shortest in the group B (16 .88 ± 0 .834)days ,followed by the group A (20 .50 ± 1 .195)days and the group C (25 .88 ± 2 .100)days ,there was statistically significant difference in the time of wound healing between the three groups (P<0 .05) .CONCLUSIONS Both of the novel silver agents can achieve good effects on the antibacterial activity and promotion of wound healing but differ in the effects ;the combined drug therapy is recommended for the management of the burn wound ,the BangerkangTM Burn-aid antibacterial cream will achieve a better effect on prevention of wound infections in the early stage ,and the SilverCare nano-silver antibacterial gel can achieve better effect on promotion of wound epithelialization in the middle and late stage .
What problem does this paper attempt to address?