Abstract:OBJECTIVE For providing evidences for further modification of China Infectious Diseases Automated-alert and Response System (CIDARS) by comparing the early-warning performance of the temporal model and temporal-spatial model in CIDARS. METHODS The application performance for outbreak detection of temporal model and temporal-spatial model simultaneously running among 208 pilot counties in 20 provinces from 2011 to 2013 was compared; the 16 infectious diseases were divided into two classes according to the disease incidence level; cases data in nationwide Notifiable Infectious Diseases Reporting Information System was combined with outbreaks reported to Public Health Emergency Reporting System, by adopting the index of the number of signals, sensitivity, false alarm rate and time for detection. RESULTS The overall sensitivity of temporal model and temporal-spatial model for 16 diseases was 96.23% (153/159) and 90.57% (144/159) respectively, without significant difference (Z = -1.604, P = 0.109), and the false alarm rate of temporal model (1.57%, 57 068/3 643 279) was significantly higher than that of temporal-spatial model (0.64%, 23 341/3 643 279) (Z = -3.408, P = 0.001), while the median time for detection of these two models was not significantly different, which was 3.0 days and 1.0 day respectively (Z = -1.334, P = 0.182).For 6 diseases of type I which represent the lower incidence, including epidemic hemorrhagic fever,Japanese encephalitis, dengue, meningococcal meningitis, typhus, leptospirosis, the sensitivity was 100% for both models (8/8, 8/8), and the false alarm rate of both temporal model and temporal-spatial model was 0.07% (954/1 367 437, 900/1 367 437), with the median time for detection being 2.5 days and 3.0 days respectively. The number of signals generated by temporal-spatial model was reduced by 2.29% compared with that of temporal model.For 10 diseases of type II which represent the higher incidence, including mumps, dysentery, scarlet fever, influenza, rubella, hepatitis E, acute hemorrhagic conjunctivitis, hepatitis A, typhoid and paratyphoid, and other infectious diarrhea, the sensitivity of temporal model was 96.03% (145/151), and the sensitivity of temporal-spatial model was 90.07% (136/151), the number of signals generated by temporal-spatial model was reduced by 59.36% compared with that of temporal model. Compared to temporal model, temporal-spatial model reduced both the number of signals and the false alarm rate of all the type II diseases;and the median of outbreak detection time of temporal model and temporal-spatial model was 3.0 days and 1.0 day, respectively. CONCLUSION Overall, the temporal-spatial model had better outbreak detection performance, but the performance of two different models varies for infectious diseases with different incidence levels, and the adjustment and optimization of the temporal model and temporal-spatial model should be conducted according to specific infectious disease in CIDARS.

Seasonality of infectious diseases towards early warning threshold selection of outbreak detection algorithms

Influence of Infectious Disease Seasonality on the Performance of the Outbreak Detection Algorithm in the China Infectious Disease Automated-alert and Response System

Optimized Outbreak Standard Selection based on China Infectious Disease Automated-alert and Response System(CIDARS)

[Evaluation of the Effect of Varicella Outbreak Control Measures Through a Discrete Time Delay SEIR Model].

Adjusting outbreak detection algorithms for surveillance during epidemic and non-epidemic periods.

[A study of early detection for 8 communicable diseases by control graph method in Songjiang district of Shanghai, China]

'Outbreak Gold Standard' Selection to Provide Optimized Threshold for Infectious Diseases Early-Alert Based on China Infectious Disease Automated-alert and Response System

Improving the Performance of Outbreak Detection Algorithms by Classifying the Levels of Disease Incidence.

The study on the early warning period of varicella outbreaks based on logistic differential equation model

[Comparison on the Different Thresholds on the 'moving Percentile Method' for Outbreak Detection].

The Application of Integrated Surveillance System for Symptoms in Surveillance of Influenza among Children

[Comparing the Performance of Temporal Model and Temporal-Spatial Model for Outbreak Detection in China Infectious Diseases Automated-alert and Response System, 2011-2013, China].

Estimating the Effectiveness of Early Control Measures Through School Absenteeism Surveillance in Observed Outbreaks at Rural Schools in Hubei, China.

Exploring the seasonality and optimal control strategy of HIV/AIDS epidemic in China: The impact of seasonal testing

Effect of narrowing scan area on performance of China Infections Diseases Automated-alert and Response System on hand, foot and mouth disease cluster detection

Epidemiologic characteristics and prediction of influenza-like illness in Huangpu District,Shanghai City

The Comparison of Two Different Types of Baseline Data Regarding the Performance of Aberration Detection Algorithm for Infectious Disease Outbreaks

Spatial Dynamics of Chickenpox Outbreaks in Rapidly Developing Regions: Implications for Global Public Health

How to Select A Proper Early Warning Threshold to Detect Infectious Disease Outbreaks Based on the China Infectious Disease Automated Alert and Response System (Cidars)

Seasonal Characteristics and Etiologic Features of the Cluster of Fever in Pudong New Area of Shanghai in 2013-2021

[Analysis of Effect on Infectious Diseases Outbreak Detection Performance by Classifying Provinces for Moving Percentile Method].