Meta Analysis of the Therapeutic Effects on Xerostomia Treated with Chi-nese Herbal Medicine
Yang DING,Jian-min HAN,Mei HAN,Geng LIU,Wei LI,Yang XIAO,Meng MENG,Sheng-sheng ZHANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13935/j.cnki.sjzx.170909
2017-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate systematically the therapeutic effects on xerostomia treated with Chinese herbal medicine. Methods The literatures were retrieved from PubMed,Cochrane Library,CNKI, Chinese Biomedical Literature Database and China Science and Technology Journal Database. The manual re-trieval was done for TCM journals. The literatures on randomized controlled trials(RCTs)with TCM were in-cluded. The Cochrane bias risk assessment tool was used to evaluate the literature quality included. Review Manage(version 5. 3)statistical software was used for the meta - analysis. Results Totally,18 RCTs were included,involved 1318 patients. Meta - analysis result showed that the clinical therapeutic effects of Chinese herbal medicine were apparently better than the control group in the treatment of xerostomia[MH = 4. 40, 95% CL(3. 23,600),P < 0. 00001],dry mouth[MD = - 1. 40,95% CL(- 1. 47,- 1. 34),P < 0. 00001], dry eyes[MD = - 1. 13,95% CL(- 1. 19,- 1. 07),P <0. 00001],salivary secretion under normal condition [IV=2. 35,95%CL(1. 95,2. 75),P<0. 00001],salivary secretion under stimulation[IV=5. 28,95%CL (3. 78,6. 78),P<0. 00001],the improvement in sleep disorder[IV= -1. 06,95%CL(-1. 28,-0. 84), P<0. 00001],the improvement in oral pain[IV= -0. 82,95%CL(-1. 00,-0. 64),P<0. 00001],the improvement in motor limitation[IV-0. 28,95%CL(-0. 48,-0. 07),P=0. 008]and the improvement in social capacity[IV= -1. 15,95%CL(-1. 39,-0. 92),P<0. 00001]were all better than those in the con-trol group. The differences were not significant as compared with the control group in the improvements in e-motional impairment[IV= -0. 12,95%CL(-1. 69,1. 46),P=0. 88],behavior problems[IV=0. 02,95%CL(-0. 14,0. 18),P=0. 80]and mental health[IV=0. 15,95%CL(-0. 28,0. 57),P=0. 50]. Conclu-sion The Chinese herbal medicine has the therapeutic effects on xerostomia. But,more multi-central,large-scale sample and high quality RCTs are required for further verification.