Abstract:Background: The successful application of randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled studies requires maximum blinding. Organoleptic properties of the placebo should be similar to the drug, making it difficult to distinguish between the two. The uniqueness of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) preparations makes it challenging to prepare placebo. Evaluation of the TCM placebo simulation effect can determine whether the preparation of placebo can be genuinely blind in clinical trials. There is still a lack of well-established methods to evaluate TCM placebos. Hence, this study aimed to explore the evaluation methodology of TCM placebo simulation. Methods: An independent evaluation method and three comparative evaluation methods were proposed, and three dosage forms (oral liquid, capsule, and granule) were tested. The independent evaluation, in which each person was given an experimental drug or a placebo, gave an overall assessment of organoleptic properties in a blind state. We comparatively evaluated the similarity in organoleptic properties between the experimental drug and placebo. According to different distribution methods, we divided comparative evaluation methods into three. In method 1, the evaluator was given the experimental drug and placebo and was told that there must be a placebo among them. In method 2, each evaluator was randomly assigned to the combination group or two investigational drugs group. In method 3, the evaluator was assigned to a set of three coded samples, numbered by random three-digit numbers, each different, two of which were identical, and the two samples were equally frequent. Results: In the independent evaluation, there was no difference between TCM placebo and experimental drugs in a blind state at the level of p = 0.05. Even though the comparative evaluation methods enabled identification of potential differences between the two samples, methods 2 and 3 were better than method 1 in eliminating psychological factors. Also, in method 3, the completely random method combined with the blind method eliminated the subjectivity and objectivity bias and improved the experiment’s credibility compared with the previous two methods. Conclusion: Regardless of the methods that could evaluate the placebo’s simulated effect in actual clinical trials, we suggest that independent evaluation and comparative evaluation (method 3) should be combined to reflect better whether the placebo is truly blind.

Prospective analysis for application of functional magnetic resonance imaging technology in masking evaluation of Chinese materia medica preparations

An in Vivo Bioelectronic Nose for Possible Quantitative Evaluation of Odor Masking Using M/T Cell Spatial Response Patterns.

Basic Taste Intensity Recognition Based on Semg and EEG Signals

An in Vivo Bioelectronic Tongue for Sweetness Detection Using Rat Gustatory Perception Based on Brain-Computer Interface

Developments in Taste-Masking Techniques for Traditional Chinese Medicines

Discovery of active ingredients in Traditional Chinese Medicine based on odor and flavor compounds analysis.

New strategies for identifying and masking the bitter taste in traditional herbal medicines: The example of Huanglian Jiedu Decoction

[Main spicy components, mechanism and masking technology for spicy flavor of Chinese medicine: a review]

Discrimination and chemical composition quantitative model of Raw Moutan Cortex and Moutan Cortex Carbon based on electronic nose and machine learning

Recent Advances in Investigating Odor-Taste Interactions: Psychophysics, Neuroscience, and Microfluidic Techniques

A Novel Critical Control Point and Chemical Marker Identification Method for the Multi-Step Process Control of Herbal Medicines Via NMR Spectroscopy and Chemometrics.

Decoding Taste Information in Human Brain: A Temporal and Spatial Reconstruction Data Augmentation Method Coupled with Taste EEG

[Current evaluation situation and research strategies on enhanced immune function of health food containing Chinese materia medica].

Experiment design and feasibility of BOLD and MRS multimodal fMRI in analysis of brain effect induced by acupuncture

Progress in the design and quality control of placeboes for clinical trials of traditional Chinese medicine

Insights into Brain Perceptions of the Different Taste Qualities and Hedonic Valence of Food Via Scalp Electroencephalogram

A STUDY ON THE VISUAL STIMULATIONS TASK MODALITIES FOR THEFUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING TO THE HUMANBRAIN RESPONSE TO FOOD

Functional Compounds Rapid Screening Strategy for Health Food Function-Formula-component Integrated Quality Control by Syndrome Correlation-Network Analysis

Developing Placebos for Clinical Research in Traditional Chinese Medicine: Assessing Organoleptic Properties of Three Dosage Forms (Oral Liquid, Capsule and Granule)

Effective strategy for distinguishing raw and vinegar Schisandrae Chinensis Fructus based on electronic eye and electronic tongue combined with chemometrics

[Quantification of astringency for traditional Chinese medicine based on animal preference index and electronic tongue]