Comparative study of two methods of tracheal extubation for persistent vegetative state with tracheotomy and intubation

黄丛萍,倪莹莹,章良翔,吕晓,燕铁斌,邓碟霞,李芳,刘飞平,陈文香
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-1242.2017.07.013
2017-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To compare the effects of two methods of tracheal extubation for persistent vegetative state (PVS) with tracheotomy and intubation.Method:One hundred and twenty-three PVS patients with tracheotomy and intubation were recruited from Guangdong 999 Brain Hospital.They were randomly assigned to observation group and control group.Observation group was given self-made sealing sleeve to plug the endotracheal intubation completely.If patients breathed normally in 48 hours,the tracheotomy cannulas would be extubated.Control group was replaced with metal tracheal cannulas that would be plugged directly after 1 week.If breathing normally in 48 hours,patients would be given extubation.The heart rate,respiration,blood oxygen saturation and different gender,the course of disease,the tracheal tube indwelling time,extubation time,extubation success rate and complication rates of two groups were recorded.Result:Extubation time:①The difference in extubation time between the two groups was statistically significant (P<0.05);②When the course of disease was 4-12 weeks,the difference of extubation time was more obvious(P<0.05);③For the patients with traumatic brain injury or cerebral hemorrhage,extubation time also showed more obvious difference(P < 0.05).For extubation success rate and complication rates,there was no statistical difference between the two groups (P > 0.05).Conclusion:There was no statistical difference in safety,success rate,complication rate between two groups.At the same time,observation group had the shorter extubation time,especially in the patients with 4-12 weeks of course of disease,or with traumatic brain injury,cerebral hemorrhage or ischemia anoxic encephalopathy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?