First Successful Double Lung Transplantation from Brain Death Donor in China
Wei Dong,Fei Gao,Jingyu Chen,Mingming Zheng,Shugao Ye,Feng Liu,Tao Bian,Yinsu Zhu,Bo Wu,Ji Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/tp.0b013e3182247b28
2011-01-01
Transplantation
Abstract:Lung transplantation has been established as an appropriate ultimate treatment strategy in end-stage lung diseases. In China, the first lung transplantation was performed on a patient with pulmonary tuberculosis in 1979. However, it was an unsuccessful attempt. In September 2002, a single-lung transplantation was successfully performed on a patient with emphysema in our center. Since then, our center has performed approximately 100 lung transplantations on patients with both chronic and acute end-stage lung diseases. During the development of surgical techniques, there were controversies on legality and morality all the time. Our center conducted the first three bilateral lung transplantations from donors after brain death to three recipients had bronchiectasis, silicosis, and idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, respectively. Herein, we report a case of bilateral lung transplantation conducted to treat silicosis. A 34-year-old miner with 15-year history of inhalation of crystalline silica dust was registered as a candidate for lung transplantation after multidisciplinary assessment and discussed by the Lung Transplant Evaluation Committee. The preoperative chest radiograph showed bilateral conglomerate nodules with interstitial infiltrates. A 28-year-old male donor who was a car accident victim had multiple traumatic intracranial hematomas and basilar skull fracture. He was diagnosed as brain death in No. 1 hospital of Nanjing based on deep coma, complete absence of brain stem reflection, nonspontaneous breathing, two isoelectric (flat-line) electrocardiograms 24-hr apart, and brain death figure under cranial Doppler ultrasound. After the diagnosis, he underwent 16 days mechanical ventilation until consent for the organ donation was obtained from his family members. During this period, we adopted protective ventilatory strategy, routine endotracheal suction every 8 hr, and intravenous antibiotics to prevent infection. The lungs were evaluated, harvested, flushed, and packaged on ice for transportation to our institution. After anesthesia induction for the recipient, the SpO2 could not be maintained above 90% with one lung ventilation, and then extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) was initiated. After the donor lungs arrived, bilateral sequential lung transplantation through bilateral anterolateral thoracotomy without sternal division was performed with ECMO support. Total operating time for the recipient was 8 hr, the cold ischemia time was 4.5 hr for the right lung and 6.5 hr for the left. The ECMO was successfully weaned 1 hr postoperatively. Normal immunosuppressive regimen that is based on the use of cyclosporine, mycophenolate mofetil, and steroid administration was used. The patient had a satisfactory postoperative convalescence and was dismissed from the hospital on postoperative day 43. Since the brain death criteria was published in 1968, organ retrieval from brain dead donors almost completely replaced organ donations from cardiac dead donor in most countries (1). However, there was an obstacle to the wider application of the concept of brain death in China, because of the traditional Chinese view that dedicates that life goes on until the heart stops beating. The lung donor pool was diminished largely by people's resistance to the concept of brain death. According to our vice minister of Ministry of Health Huang Jiefu, most organ donations in China come from death-row prisoners (2). Despite the rights of death-row prisoners to donate is respected and written consent from them is required before their organs can be used, this strategy is not supported by the World Health Organization and is long condemned by the global transplantation community (3). However, China is changing. In 2003, the Ministry of Health issued official criteria for defining brain death which indirectly promoted the transplantation from brain dead donors. In early 2006, the number of qualifying hospitals for transplantation was reduced by three quarters to 164. In 2007, banning organ trafficking and “transplant tourism” came into force. In addition, in August 2006, Zhonghua Klaus Chen, the vice chairman of the Chinese Organ Transplantation Society, set up the Chinese Organ Procurement Organization, 40 hospitals including our center took part in the organ sharing project. Until 2007, 282 organs had been harvested from 63 donors who were certified brain dead according to international accepted standards (4). In this case, the donor was diagnosed as brain death by nontransplant doctor according to Diagnostic Standard of Brain Death (adult edition) and Diagnostic Technological Specification of Brain Death in China (5). Although legislation of brain death has not been realized in China yet, the medical definition of brain death has been adopted. Our case suggested that we can use the brain dead donor in lung transplantation on the basis of international standard. So far, China has an expert team of more than 100 people capable of handling brain death-related issues. We believe that prisoners' organs will be gone sooner or later. Dong Wei1 Fei Gao2 Jing-yu Chen1 Ming-feng Zheng1 Shu-Gao Ye1 Feng Liu1 Tao Bian2 Yan-hong Zhu1 Bo Wu1 Ji Zhang1 1Lung Transplantation Group Wuxi People's Hospital Nanjing Medical University, Wuxi Jiangsu, China 2Department of Respiratory Wuxi People's Hospital Nanjing Medical University, Wuxi Jiangsu, China