Abstract:Objective: The relationship between patient satisfaction and surgical quality is unclear for US hospitals. Using national data, we examined if hospitals with high patient satisfaction have lower levels of performance on accepted measures of the quality and efficiency of surgical care. Background: Federal policymakers have made patient satisfaction a core measure for the way hospitals are evaluated and paid through the value-based purchasing program. There is broad concern that performance on patient satisfaction may have little or even a negative correlation with the quality of surgical care, leading to potential trade-offs in efforts to improve patient experience with other surgical quality measures. Methods: We used the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems survey data from 2010 and 2011 to assess performance on patient experience. We used national Medicare data on 6 common surgical procedures to calculate measures of surgical efficiency and quality: risk-adjusted length of stay, process score, risk-adjusted mortality rate, risk-adjusted readmission rate, and a composite z score across all 4 metrics. Multivariate models adjusting for hospital characteristics were used to assess the independent relationships between patient satisfaction and measures of surgical efficiency and quality. Results: Of the 2953 US hospitals that perform one of these 6 procedures, the median patient satisfaction score was 69.5% (interquartile range, 63%-75.5%). Length of stay was shorter in hospitals with the highest levels of patient satisfaction (7.1 days vs 7.7 days, P < 0.001). Adjusting for procedural volume and structural characteristics, institutions in the highest quartile of patient satisfaction had the higher process of care performance (96.5 vs 95.5, P < 0.001), lower readmission rates (12.3% vs 13.6%, P < 0.001), and lower mortality (3.1% vs 3.6%) than those in the lowest quartile. Hospitals with high patient satisfaction also had a higher composite score for quality across all measures (P < 0.001). Conclusions: Among US hospitals that perform major surgical procedures, hospitals with high patient satisfaction provided more efficient care and were associated with higher surgical quality. Our findings suggest there need not be a trade-off between good quality of care for surgical patients and ensuring a positive patient experience.

Establishment and evaluation of surgical quality system

Practice and Lessons Learnt from Building The“surgeon Qualification Admittance System”

Establishment of the Evaluation System for Information Quality Control in Hospitals

Study on Operation Service Quality and Safety Management Standard

Key Issues in the Development of an Evidence-Based Stratified Surgical Patient Safety Improvement Information System: Experience from a Multicenter Surgical Safety Program

Establishment of evaluation index system using analytic hierarchy process for perioperative nursing quality of minimally invasive treatment through digestive endoscope

Enlightenment from the practice of surgical quality control in shanghai

Discussion of the effect of establishing the long-term mechanism of high-quality care in operating room

[Compilation and Evaluation of Perioperative Nursing Quality Assessment Scale].

System Design of Enhanced Sugery Management Based on Information Governance

High Standard Surgical Quality Control Will Maintain the Continuous Development of Surgery

Establishment and Empirical Evaluation of a Quality Indicator System for Postoperative Pain Management

Impact of intelligent information-based perioperative care on postoperative rehabilitation, complications, and quality of life of patients undergoing gastrointestinal surgery

Discussion on Revision and Implementation of Surgical Grading Management System

Construction of Nursing Quality Evaluation Indexes System of Gastrointestinal Surgery in General Hospitals

Establishing Index System to Evaluate Medical and Nursing Quality in Military Hospitals

Construction and Management of Standardized Patients of Surgery

Preliminary Study of Surgical Outcome Assessment System of Cervical Spondylosis

Construction of evaluation index system for perioperative nursing quality minimally invasive treatment of digestive endoscopy

Patient satisfaction and quality of surgical care in US hospitals

Construction and Empirical Study of Nursing Quality Evaluation Index System of Hepatobiliary Surgery Based on ERAS Concept