Wrist partial arthrodesis versus arthroplasty for the treatment of distal radius giant cell tumor with proximal fibular graft

朱忠胜,张春林,何志敏,薛锋,董扬
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3977/j.issn.1005-8478.2017.17.09
2017-01-01
Abstract:[Objective] To compare the clinical outcomes of the wrist partial arthrodesis versus arthroplasty for the treatment of distal radius giant cell tumor with proximal fibular graft.[Method] Between February 2006 and May 2012,16 grade Ⅱ,Ⅲ giant cell tumor of distal cases were treated with tumor resection and autologous proximal fibular graft transplantation to reconstruct the wrist in our hospital,including 8 males and 8 females with an average age of 35.4 years (range;19-55 years).The course of disease ranged from 1 month to 2 years,and the main symptoms were joint pain,swelling,and limitation of activity.Of them,9 patients received partial wrist arthrodesis,and the remaining 7 patients were treated with wrist arthroplasty.[Result] All patients were followed up for 4.0-10.2 years with an average of 6.4 years.Non-union at interface of fibula-scapho-lunate was found in 1 case who was excluded from functional assessment in this study.All incision achieved primary healing,and no tumors recurrence was observed during follow-up.In arthrodosis group,the average range of motion of the wrist at total flexion-extension and at total pronation-supination were 55.63±6.78 degrees,126.25±14.58 degrees respectively.The average grip strength was accounted for (75.14±5.74) % compared with the contralateral side,and MSTS score averaged 25.5±0.76.Meanwhile,those parameters in arthroplasty group were 72.86± 15.24 degrees,140± 14.72 degrees,(60.62± 11.83) %,as well as 25.86± 1.46,respectively.The difference of forearm rotation was not statistically significant.The wrist flexion-extension activities was better in arthroplasty group than that in arthrodesis group,and the wrist grip strength was fouad less than that in arthrodesis group,the differences were statistically significant (P<0.05).However,MSTS score was not significantly different between two groups (P>0.05).[Conclusion] After tumor resection and autologous fibular graft transplantation for treatment of distal radius giant cell tumor,partial arthrodesis and arthroplasty both can retain some wrist function,and are proved to be safe,effective procedure of reconstruction.Personalized selection should be applied based on the actual situation of the patient.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?