Treatment of calcifying tendonitis of shoulder with arthroscopy and comparison of efficacy
Jianhai Chen,Yichong Zhang,Dianying Zhang,Zhongguo Fu,Ming Yang,Yu Dang,Baoguo Jiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2015.02.006
2015-01-01
Abstract:Background Calcifying tendonitis of rotator cuff is a common disease that causes pain .It frequently occurs in people at 30‐50s ,especially in women .The acute calcifying tendonitis is characterized by persistent severe pain of shoulder joint of unknow n reason .In case of severe symptoms ,emergency treatment is needed .Most patients with acute phase diseases have good efficacy for conservative treatment .However ,patients who do not respond to conservative treatment or with symptoms unrelieved that severely influence work and life ,surgery that removes the calcifying lesion under the arthroscopy is recognized as the effective treatment .Recently ,with the development of arthroscopy ,removal of calcium compounds under the arthroscopy has become a common surgery and leads to good efficacy .This study was performed to assess the efficacy of removal of calcified lesion under arthroscopy for calcifying tendonitis of rotator cuff in patients with acute and chronic phases of diseases ,and to determine the difference in shoulder joint function between acute and chronic phases after surgery .Methods General data:Cases with calcifying tendonitis who received treatment from September 2009 to June 2014 were included in this study .The inclusion criteria included :(1) who had history of severe shoulder joint pain;(2) who did not respond to conservative therapy ;(3) who received arthroscopy .The exclusion criteria included :(1) who had complicated injury of rotator cuff ;(2) who received open surgery .28 cases who met inclusion criteria were enrolled .The patients were assigned to the acute group and the chronic group by the time from the acute onset to removal of calcified lesion under arthroscopy .The acute group received removal of calcified lesion within 3 months after the onset of shoulder pain .The chronic group received removal of calcified lesion 3 months after the onset of shoulder pain that limited range of motion .28 cases had different degrees of pain and limited range of motion in the affected shoulder joint .All patients received imaging examinations .The size ,shape of the calcified lesion in the shoulder joint and the shape of the acromion were determined based on the radiograph .Plain radiograph of the shoulder indicated oval or bar‐shaped high‐density cloudy calcification shadow in the rotator cuff below the acromion or inside the slightly lateral mucosal bursa .There were 10 cases with acute diseases in which the patients aged 38‐68 years with a mean age of 52 .6 years .In 5 cases ,the left shoulder was affected .In 5 cases ,the right shoulder was affected .The symptom was acute pain in the last 3 months .They had no previous history of obvious pain limited range of motion .The patients had acupuncture‐similar feeling ,increased temperature on regional skin , markedly tenderness of the shoulder and limited range of motion that severely influenced daily life before surgery .The preoperative radiograph indicated high‐density calcification shadow in rotator cuff below the acromion .There were 18 chronic cases ranged from 40‐73 years with a mean age of 55 .5 years .7 cases had left shoulders affected and 11 cases had right shoulders affected .All patients had a history of severe pain .The pain relieved after persistence for a certain time but did not disappear .The shoulder pain was sometimes slight and sometimes severe .The range of motion of the shoulder joint was substantially limited ,which influenced daily life .Surgery method :All surgeries were performed by chief or senior physicians at the Peking University Peoples’ Hospital .The cases were subject to general anesthesia on beach chair position .The bony marks were made before surgery .The arthroscopy was inserted through posterior approach to examine the glenohumeral joint .Severe inflammatory synovial hyperplasia of congestion was often observed on the wall inside the joint capsule .Some patients with limited range of motion had contracture in the rotator interval and thickened middle glenohumeral ligament .The structure of rotator cuff remained complete .The synovial tissue in the articular cavity was removed .The rotator interval and middle glenohumeral ligament were released .A needle was used to puncture the supraspinatus tendon and infraspinatus tendon through the outer edge of acromion to position the location of calcified lesion .If the calcified lesion was detected with the needle ,there was calcium compound on the needle tip .After positioning of calcified lesion ,it was marked with a PDS suture placed through the needle .The arthroscopy located in the subacromial space often observed obvious hyperplasia and congestion in the synovial membrane under acromion . Sometimes calcium compound was observed on the synovial membrane .The synovial membrane under the acromion was removed using shaver .The bleeding was stopped using radiofrequency coblation .The structure of rotator cuff was clearly revealed .The locations of calcified lesion were marked using sutures .The tendons were dissected along the direction of tendon fibers using blade to expose the lesion .The calcified lesion was removed with shaver .The toothpaste shaped calcium substances were observed .After complete removal of calcified lesions ,the tendon of rotator cuff was observed for defectiveness .For big calcified lesions that involved 50% depth of the tendon or footprint bone surface of rotator cuff revealed ,a 4 .5 mm suture anchor was used to repair the rotator cuff .9 cases received repair of the rotator cuff .The osteophyte was thoroughly removed if any under the acromion .8 cases received combined acromioplasty .Postoperative rehabilitation and assessment :The affected extremity was slinged in a shoulder immobilizer .The cold pack was appropriately used within 1 week after surgery .The passive shoulder joint motion was assisted with the normal hand .The range of motion increased gradually .1 week later ,the active motion was started gradually .6 weeks later ,the resistance exercise and extension treatment were applied to the shoulder joint .3 months after surgery ,the range of motion returned to normal and daily living activities returned to normal .For patients with combined rotator cuff repair ,active exercise should start 6 weeks after the surgery to avoid loosening or another tearing on the repaired site .Each patient was assessed for Constant score ,simple shoulder test (SST ) score ,range of motion of the shoulder joint and VAS pain score before and after surgery .Statistical method:Paired data before and after surgery was analyzed with t test .SPSS 15 .0 software was used forstatisticalanalysis.P<0.05indicatedhestatisticalsignificance.Results 28caseswereincludedin the retrospective study .The patients were subject to follow‐up ranged from 6‐33 months (with a mean of 18 .8 months) .The regular follow‐up radiograph after surgery showed removal of calcified shadow . All patients were assessed for Constant score ,VAS pain score ,range of motion of the shoulder joint and simple shoulder test (SST) score before and after surgery .For 10 cases with acute phase diseases , the mean scores of Constant scale were 51 .36 before treatment and 88 .16 after treatment ,increased by an average of 36 .80 .The anteflexion and uplift angle increased by about 77 .00° .The external rotation increased by about 18 .50° .SST questionnaire:The mean number of answers “Yes” was 5 .02 before treatment and 9 .32 after treatment ,increased by an average of about 4 .30 .The mean scores for VAS were 9 .12 before treatment and 4 .62 after treatment ,decreased by average of about 4 .50 .For 18 cases with acute phase diseases ,the mean Constant scores were 63 .70 before treatment and 88 .03 after treatment ,increased by an average of about 24 .33 .The mean number of answers “Yes” was 6 .33 before treatment and 9 .66 after treatment ,increased by an average of about 3 .33 .The mean scores for VAS were 7 .30 before treatment and 4 .19 after treatment ,decreased by an average of about 3 .11 .In this study ,28 cases with calcifying tendonitis underwent removal of calcified lesion under arthroscopy and presented different degrees of function improvement in shoulder joint .The patients with calcifying tendonitis in the acute group had significantly better Constant score ,SST growth and anteflexion and uplift angle and pain relief than the patients in the chronic group ( P <0 .05) .In this study ,9 cases received repair of rotator cuff ,including 2 cases in the acute group ,accounting for 20% of patients with acute phase diseases ,and 7 cases in the chronic group ,accounting for 38 .9% of patients with chronic phase diseases .Discussion Calcifying tendonitis of rotator cuff is a common disease that causes acute shoulder pain .When the symptom severely influences daily life and conservative therapy is not effective ,early removal of calcified lesion under the arthroscopy is effective for calcifying tendonitis and leads to good prognosis .