A biomechanical study on medial collateral ligament reconstruction for terrible triad of the elbow

Ning MA,Feng YUAN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-252X.2015.10.013
2015-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the effects of medial collateral ligament ( MCL ) on the stability of the elbow and to evaluate the results after the reconstruction of MCL by measuring the biomechanical indexes of the elbow with or without terrible triad injuries before and after the reconstruction.Methods The elbow specimens from 6 fresh-frozen male adults were adopted to establish an elbow model with terrible triad injuries. The digital speckle correlation method ( DSCM ) was used. The following angles were measured when the valgus and internal rotation moments were 1.5 N·m and the elbow lfexion angles were 0°, 30°, 60° and 90° respectively. ( 1 ) The valgus and internal rotation angles of the ulnohumeral joint of the normal elbow were measured ( control group ). ( 2 ) In the elbow model with terrible triad injuries, the valgus and internal rotation angles of the ulnohumeral joint were measured with the coronoid process and radial head ifxed and lateral collateral ligament ( LCL ) but not MCL repaired ( repair group 1 ). ( 3 ) In the elbow model with terrible triad injuries, the valgus and internal rotation angles of the ulnohumeral joint were measured with the coronoid process and radial head ifxed and LCL and MCL repaired ( repair group 2 ). All the experimental data were statistically analyzed by using SPSS 17.0 software.Results The valgus angles were ( 3.3±0.7 ) °, ( 3.4±1.3 ) °, ( 3.6±0.9 ) ° and ( 3.7±1.5 ) ° in the control group when the elbow lfexion angles were 0°, 30°, 60° and 90° respectively, which were ( 4.7±1.7 ) °, ( 5.0±1.9 ) °, ( 6.1±2.0 ) ° and ( 6.9±2.2 ) ° in the repair group 1 and ( 3.9±0.9 ) °, ( 4.1±0.8 ) °, ( 4.2±1.2 ) ° and ( 4.4±1.6 ) ° in the repair group 2. The internal rotation angles were ( 6.0±2.0 ) °, ( 5.8±1.8 ) °, ( 6.2±1.2 ) ° and ( 8.3±1.1 ) ° in the control group when the elbow lfexion angles were 0°, 30°, 60° and 90° respectively, which were ( 6.5±1.9 ) °, ( 7.1±2.2 ) °, ( 8.2±1.8 ) ° and ( 12.3±2.1 ) ° in the repair group 1 and ( 6.2±1.2 ) °, ( 6.0±1.6 ) °, ( 6.5±1.3 ) ° and ( 8.4±1.5 ) ° in the repair group 2. The stability of valgus and internal rotation of the elbow was signiifcantly increased after the repair of MCL, and the differences between the repair group 1 and 2 were statistically signiifcant (P<0.05 ). The differences were not statistically signiifcant in the stability of valgus and internal rotation of the elbow when the repair group 2 and the control group were compared (P>0.05 ).Conclusions MCL injuries will lead to instability of the valgus and internal rotation of the elbow in the patients with terrible triad injuries. The elbow stability may be improved by repairing the MCL in treatment of terrible triad of the elbow.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?