RELAX and FIRMNESS: The Combination of Muscle Relaxation with Botulinum Toxin and Collagen Biostimulation with Calcium Hydroxyapatite for the Treatment of the Cervical Region
Gladstone E L Faria,Juliana S Palo,Andre R Torres,Ana C H R Machado,Ricardo F Boggio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ccid.s430762
2023-10-07
Clinical Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology
Abstract:Gladstone EL Faria, Juliana S Palo, Andre R Torres, Ana CHR Machado, Ricardo F Boggio Cosmiatry Department, Instituto Boggio, São Paulo, SP, Brazil Correspondence: Gladstone EL Faria, Cosmiatry Department, Instituto Boggio, Rua Cincinato Braga nr 37. 8 floor, São Paulo, SP, 01333-011, Brazil, Email Introduction: There are several therapeutic modalities for neck rejuvenation, especially calcium hydroxylapatite. Botulinum toxin, by relaxing the mm. platysma, also provides improvement in facial contour. Combination treatments for this region are usually recommended as they offer better results. Objective: This study evaluated the efficacy and safety of the joint dilution of both products (Relax and Firmness – RF), applied in the same device, based on the treatment in the topography of the platysma muscle, ie, starting from the lower third of the face and extending to the neck. Methods: Prospective, blinded, controlled study with 10 participants randomly assigned to RF and 5 in the control group (treated with CaHA only). Results were recorded through the Vectra platform and subjectively evaluated through the GAIS scale by participants and blinded evaluators. Objective analysis was performed using corneometry. Times evaluated: pre-treatment, 30 and 90 days. Considered statistically significant when p< 0.1. Results: 100% of the RF group reported "excellent improvement" at D30 and 30% at D90. In the control group, 100% reported "very improved" at D30 and 20% rated "excellent improvement" at D90. A higher and earlier satisfaction rate was observed in the RF group. No difference in corneometry was found between the groups at D30. At D90, the control group had a mean increase of 0.24 versus 5.17 in the RF group (p-value=0.089&ast). When we analyzed the percentage variation from baseline, the control group was stable, while the RF showed a mean increase of 8.89% (p-value=0.062&ast). Discussion: We demonstrated the safety and effectiveness of the association of both products, diluted and applied together through microcannulas. Minimization of punctures, patient comfort, and technique based on the anatomy of the platysma muscle underlie the technique. High rates of early satisfaction due to botulinum toxin (Relaxation) and late satisfaction due to CaHA (Firmness). Keywords: calcium hydroxylapatite, botulinum toxin, rejuvenation, neck, platysma muscle Skin aging of the cervical region is a common complaint of patients, evolving with skin laxity and atrophy, loss of mandibular contour, hyperactivity of the platysma muscle, and formation of platysmal bands. 1–3 The skin of the region, characteristically quite thin, is subject to the effects of gravity, as well as to the intense activity of the platysma muscle, whose contraction favors the depression not only of the lower third but of the entire face. Given the multiple factors related to aging of the region, combined therapies provide better results. The subdermal application of calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA) induces an increase in the synthesis of collagen and elastin, increases the production of components of the extracellular matrix such as proteoglycans, improves dermal elasticity, allows skin retraction in the submental region, and increases the thickness of the local skin, desirable for this anatomical topography. 4–6 Several techniques are described for the use of botulinum toxin in the treatment of the muscles of the cervical region, especially in the platysma muscle, either to improve mandibular contour or to relax the platysmal bands. The application is usually done with needles, requiring multiple punctures and is usually performed at a different time from the application of calcium hydroxylapatite. 7–12 Addressing different targets of neck aging by combining techniques simultaneously, such as collagen biostimulation with calcium hydroxylapatite and botulinum toxin for muscle relaxation, would provide advantages to the applicator and the patient. To the applicator, ease of technique and agility. To the patient, comfort by avoiding multiple punctures and multiple visits to the doctor's office, as well as an improvement in the perception of the therapeutic result. The improvement in the perception of results is related to the combination of early and late effects provided by the technique. The earliest effect is related to muscle relaxation with botulinum toxin, being noticed about 5 to 7 days after the application. The latter effect is related to collagen biostimulation, thus increasing the satisfaction rates with the treatment. We evaluate the efficacy and safety of the joint application of calcium hydroxylapatite associated with botulinum toxin, in the same device, using microcannulas, for the treatment of tissue -Abstract Truncated-
dermatology