Comparison of Outcomes Between Sublobar Resection and Lobectomy for T1 Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

Ma Qianli,Liu Deruo,Guo Yongqing,Shi Bin,Tian Yanchu,Song Zhiyi,Liang Chaoyang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-8773.2016.01.029

2016-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the outcomes between sublobar resection and lobectomy for T1 non-small cell lung cancerNSCLCtumor diameter ≤3 cm.Methods The clinical data of 278 patients with T1 NSCLC undergoing surgery in Department of Thoracic Surgery in China-Japan Friendship Hospital between January 2007 and December 2014 were collected.The mean age of these patients was60.7 ± 10.4 years. Sixty-one patients received sublobar resectionwedge resectionn = 35segmentectomyn = 26 and the other 217 underwent lobectomy. There was 81.7% of adenocarcinoma12.9% of squamous cell carcinoma and 5.4% of cancer of other types. High differentiatedmoderate differentiated and poor differentiated cancer accounted for 8.6%27.0% and 20.5%respectivelyand there were 43.9% cases with undermined differentiation status.In cases of adenocarcinomathere were 4.0% preinvasive lesions7.5% minimally-invasive lesions and 88.5%invasive adenocarcinoma.There were 86.7% cases with T1N0M01.1% cases with T1N1M0 and 12.2% cases with T1N2M0.Results Compared with lobectomy grouppatients were much elderthe duration of operation was much shorterand the percentage of lesion≤2 cm was significantly larger in sublobar resection groupt=0.496P =0.009t =8.082P =0.029χ2 =2.105P =0.002.There was no significant difference in forced expiratory volume in one secondFEV1FEV1 %surgical procedure and incidence of postoperative complications between two groupst =0.065P =0.713t =2.12P =0.085χ2 =0.399P =0.274χ2 =0.438P =0.490.For NSCLC patients with T1N0M0the 5-year survival of sublobar resection group and lobectomy group were 73.9% and 83.5%respectivelywith no significant differenceP =0.883.In sublobar resection groupthe 5-year survival of patients undergoing wedge resection and segmentectomy were 79.4% and 70.6%respectivelywith no significant differenceP =0.979.Multivariate analysis indicated that only age and mediastinal lymph node metastasis N2 were risk factors for poor prognosisHR=1.07P =0.048HR=5.56P =0.011. There was no significant difference in 5-year survival between sublobar resection group and lobectomy groupHR = 1.38P = 0.552.Conclusions For NSCLC patients with T1N0M0though sublobar resection can not totally substitute lobectomyit may become a main surgical procedure for senior patients with poor pulmonary reserve.