Diagnostic value of multiply biopsies and endocervical curettage on cervical lesions

Ling Zhang,Hui Du,Wei Zhang,Bin Yang,Chun Wang,L Jerome,Ruifang Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.0529-567x.2015.04.005
2015-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the value of multiply biopsies and endocervical curettage (ECC)on diagnosing cervical lesions. Methods For the detection of cervical lesions, Shenzhen cervical cancer screening trial Ⅱ(SHENCCAST Ⅱ) program combined methods of HPV screening with liquid-based cytology(LBC), any positive indicators was then performed multiply biopsies and ECC under colopscopy. A total of 2 558 clear colposcopic images and pathological diagnoses were reviewed. To analyse the pathological results and primary screening results of the negative colopscopic images for discussing the value of multiply biopsies and ECC. Results Overall 2 558 women′s colposcopic images and sampling results were completed and validated. 69.98% (1 790/2 558) women had normal colposcopy appearances. Among them, 2.23%(40/1 790) were diagnosed as cervical intraepithelial neoplasiaⅡor worse (CINⅡ+). The odds ratio of high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion(HSIL) was 28.37 (P=0.000) and atypical squamous cell cannot exclude HSIL(ASC-H)was 15.07 (P=0.001). HPV types 16,52,58,31,33 and 18 were related to high-grade cervical lesion with the odds ratio of 3.11(P=0.017). Hybrid captureⅡ(HC-Ⅱ)DNA test results shown that women with HPV positive were 3.58 times more risky than those of HPV negative, which was related to high-grade cervical lesion (P=0.025). Among the 2 558 women, CINⅡ+detective rate from ECC were 40.7%(44/108) in older group (≥40 years) were higher than that of 19.2%(24/125) in younger group(<40 years;χ2=13.01, P=0.000). CINⅡ+detective rate from multiply biopsies were 90.7%(98/108)in older group(≥40 years)were higher than that of 88.8%(111/125)in younger group (<40 years;χ2=0.24, P>0.05). The highest risky items of detecting CINⅡ+were as follows:(1)HSIL or ASC-H;(2)HPV types 16,18,52 and 58 positive(either one);(3)HC-ⅡHPV positive, at least 2 of the 3 items were included among 32 cases of the 40 CINⅡ+ with normal colposcopy appearances. Conclusions The results shown that only performed multi-site biopsies with abnormal colposcopy appearances may be missed some high-grade cervical lesion. For the positive indicators during screening should be performed randomly multi-sites biopsies and ECC under colopscopy, which may be helpful to reduce miss diagnosis.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?