The Efficacy and Safety of the First Cesarean Section Single-layer Closure and Double-layer Closure: A Meta-analysis

苏秀梅,陈新,罗新,叶家卓,周娟

2017-01-01

Abstract:Objective:To assess the efficacy and safety of different sutures (Single-layer Closure and Double-layer Closure) for the first cesarean section.Methods:The databases such as CENTRAL,PubMed,SCIE,Embase,CNKl,VlP and WANFANG between 2005 to 2016 were searched to collectthe randomized control trials (RCTs) about the efficacy and safety of the first cesarean section single-layer closure and double-layer closure,the meta-analysis was performed by using the Revman 5.2 software.Results:A total of 15 references involving 10929 patients were included,of which 6778 cases of cesarean section used a single-layer closure,4151 cases used a double-layer closure.The Meta-analysis showed that compared with single-layer closure,the double-layer closure had longer operation time(Z=2.46,MD-4.01,95％CI-7.22 ～-0.81,P=0.01),more intraoperative blood loss(Z =85.49,M D 69.97,95％ CI 68.36 ～ 71.57,P ＜ 0.00001),higher incidence of irregular menstruation (Z =3.52,OR 2.41,,95 ％ C I 1.48 ～ 3.93,P =0.0004),lower incidence of scar diverticulum (Z =2.20,OR 1.5,95％ CI 1.05 ～ 2.15,P =0.03),higher incidence of poor healing of uterine incision (Z =3.03,OR 2.62,95％ CI 1.40 ～4.88,P =0.002).There was no significant difference of incidence of postpartum hemorrhage(Z =1.27,OR 1.54,95％CI 0.79 ～2.98,P =0.20) and secondary pregnancy with threatened uterine rupture or uterine rupture(Z=1.63,OR 2.02,95％ CI 0.87 ～ 4.72,P =0.10)between the two sutures.Conclusions:For the different closure of cesarean section,double-layer closure can increase the operation time and intraoperative blood loss,but can decrease the rate of irregular menstruation,poor healing of the uterine incision and scar diverticulum.Since the meta-analysis included in the literature is retrospective study,and the quality of the literature is not high,which may have some influence on the authenticity of the conclusion.It is suggested that the clinical gynecologist should make their choice carefully.