Comparative Study on Therapeutic Effects of Ultra Thin-Flap LASIK and LASEK on High Myopia with Thin Corneal of Critical Thickness
LI Wei-tao,WEI Jing,WANG Fang,QIAO Peng,WANG Hao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13480/j.issn1003-9430.2012.04.012
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the visual and refractive outcomes of ultra thin-flap LASIK and LASEK in treating high myopia with thin corneal of critical thickness(central corneal thickness≤520 μm). Methods High myopia patients with thin corneal of critical thickness were selected randomly and divided into two groups.In Group A,30 patients(60 eyes) whose preoperative spherical values ranged from-6.00 D to 10.00 D(averaged at-7.25 D) and astigmatism diopter from 0 D to 2.50 D(averaged at-0.96 D) were treated with ultra thin-flap LASIK.In Group B,30 patients(60 eyes) whose preoperative spherical values ranged from-6.00 D to 10.00 D(averaged at-7.35 D) and astigmatism diopter from 0 D to 2.75 D(averaged at-0.90 D) were treated with LASEK.The uncorrected visual acuity(UCVA),best corrected visual acuity(UCVA),SE,Haze degree,high wave front aberration and complication were examined and compared respectively on the 1st and 7th day and 1,3,and 6 months after the operation. Results The postoperative UCVA was 1.11±0.37 in Group A at 1 week,significantly higher than 0.76±0.36 in Group B(P0.01).The postoperative UCVAs were 1.13±0.26,1.12±0.34,1.12±0.25 in Group A and 1.08±0.26,1.11±0.25,1.10±0.21 in Group B respectively at Month 1,3 and 6,showing no statistical difference(for all,P0.05).The postoperative BCVAs of the two groups were unchanged or improved at Month 6 and no declination was found in either case.Haze did not appear in Group A.Mild Haze,below degree Ⅱ,was found in Group B.At Month 6 postoperative,refractive regression occurred to some extent in both groups.The regressive degree stood at(-0.16±0.53) D in Group B and(-0.14±0.49) D in Group A(P0.05).The postoperative root mean square values of higher order aberrations,vertical comas,horizontal comas and spherical aberrations at Month 1,3 and 6 were higher than those obtained preoperatively in both groups(for all,P0.05).At Month 1,3 and 6 postoperative,the increase of high order aberration in the LASEK group was smaller than that in the LASIK group(for all,P0.05).No obvious complication was found in both the groups. Conclusions Both ultra thin-flap LASIK and LASEK are safe and effective in treating high myopia eyes with thin corneal of critical thickness.Ultra-thin flap LASIK features faster visual recovery.For patients with higher myopia,better visual quality may be achieved with LASEK than with LASIK.