Report Quality Assessing of case Reports on Purtscher's Retinopathy

Rong-rong CUI,Si-qi FU,Pei-yu ZHANG,Wei DENG,Tian-yun CHEN,Nan YANG,Liang YAO,Yao-long CHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-2809.2016.04.006
2016-01-01
Abstract:Background: Case reports(CRs)play an important role in finding new cases, rare diseases, new therapies and unanticipated adverse events, also exploring pathogenesis, and medicine education.Purtscher's retinopathy is a rare disease. Case report is an important method for studying the disease.Objectives: In this study we sought to assess the quality of CRs about Purtscher's retinopathy by international reporting standards.Methods: Such databases as PubMed/Medline, EMBASE, Web of Science; CNKI, CBM, VIP and WANFANG were electronically searched. CRs about Purtscher's retinopathy were included. Six researchers were divided into three groups. According to inclusive and exclusive criteria, they screened literature and extracted data. We assessed the quality of included CRs in turns referring to the 23 items of international reporting standards.Results: A total of 76 CRs(which include 98 cases)were included. Of the 23 items of international reporting standard, clinical findings(item 6), diagnostic method and diagnostic basis(item 8a and item 8c), follow-up and outcome(item 10)and case discussion(item 11)were adequately reported well. Of the 76 CRs, none provided the information of all the 23 items; 41% ofCRs didn't report CRs-related information in the title(item 1); 62% ofCRs didn't adequately report the details of intervention providing(frequency, dose and course of treatment)(item 9); 67% ofCRs didn't report keywords(item 2); over 70% ofCRs didn't adequately report key points in the abstract(item 3a,3b,3c); 90% ofCRs didn't assess the diagnosis(item 8b,8d).Conclusion: It's urgent to improve the report quality of CRs about Purtscher's retinopathy, currently. And the difference in report quality between Chinese and English CRs is not obvious. More measures should be taken to improve the report quality of CRs.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?