Evaluation and meta analysis of randomly controlled trail primary sature and T tube drainage after laparoscopic choledochotomy with exploration and choledocholithotomy
Yin Zi,Xu Kang,Sun Jian,Xiao Zhiyu,Zhang Jianlong,Ye Hua,Zhang Heyun,Mao Kai,Wang Jie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-976X.2011.06.002
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate and compare primary duct closure and T-tube drainage placement in patients without severe inflections choledocholithiasis after laparoscopic common bile duct exploration.Methods Literature search included domestic and foreign large-scale databases:Pubmed,Embase,Springerlink and CNKI,screened for randomized controlled trials comparing primary closure and T-tube drainage in laparoscopic common bile duct exploration.A systematic review and meta-analysis based on the included studies was performed,and relevant evaluations comprised operative time,postoperative complications,residual stones,postoperative hospital stay and hospital expenses between the arms of primary closure and T-tube drainage.Results By screening the literature,seven RCTs with a total of six hundred and fifteen patients (primary closure:310,T-tube drainage:305) were analyzed.Six RCTs were performed on simply primary closure versus T-tube drainage,one RCT was performed on primary duct closure combined with endoscopic nasobiliary drainage versus T-tube drainage placement in laparoscopic common bile duct exploration.The incidence of main postoperative complications and biliary tract associated complications in primary closure arm were statistically lower to T-tube drainage arm,the pooled estimates of odds ratio were 0.49 (95%CI:0.31,0.76),0.51 (95%CI:0.29,0.91) respectively.There was no significant difference regarding the residual stones,incision infection and abdominal collections.Besides,primary closure was significant lower compared to T-tube drainage in terms of operative time,postoperative hospital stay,hospital expenses and abdominal drainage time.Conclusions In non-critical patients as without severe acute cholangitis,acute severe biliary pancreatitis or acute suppurative cholangitis,primary duct closure is safe and effective in laparoscopic common bile duct exploration,compared with traditional methods of T-tube drainage placement,can reduce postoperative complications,operative time,postoperative hospital stay and operation costs,thus reducing patient sufferings and economic burdens.In strictly controlled indications,primary duct closure is better than T-tube drainage placement.