Relations Between Natural Forest Stability and Pest Disturbance: to Control and to Be Controlled
LIANG Jun,SUN Zhiqiang,QIAO Jie,ZHANG Xingyao
2010-01-01
Abstract:How to evaluate the ecological functions of indigenous insect and pathogen in natural forest is vital for strategy makings on pest control.In this paper,we reviewed the latest research progress on the relations between forest ecosystem stability and pest disturbance,and discussed two main mechanisms: diversity-stability,and associational resistance hypothesis that acted to control pest from outbreak in natural forests.Association with taxonomically diverse plant species can reduce herbivory damage.Two hypotheses are proposed for associational resistance: the enemy hypothesis and the resource concentration hypothesis.The resource concentration hypothesis predicts that herbivores are more likely to be found in patches where their host plants are abundant,The enemy hypothesis can explain why herbivores are fewer in forest ecosystems with a more abundant and diverse community of natural enemies.This is consistent with the diversity-stability hypothesis,which predicts that the greater the diversity of a community,the greater its stability.Therefore the populations of both forest herbivores and their enemies should exhibit a lower degree of temporal variation in more diverse stands.Nonetheless,evidence from published studies suggests that mixed stands are not always less susceptible to herbivory disturbance than single-species stands for many forest ecosystems,depending on both the identity of herbivores and host tree species.The diversity-stability hypothesis has been shown to be partly true on basis of herbivore guilds.On the other hand,herbivore insect/disease disturbances play an important role in determining the overall structure,health,and sustainability of forest ecosystems.As decomposers,food source,dispersal agents of seeds and pathogens,and pollinators,herbivores can all affect the dynamics of plant density and community composition by creating gaps and patches,and even the pathway of forest succession.Forest ecosystems and their pathogens can be considered to be at quasi-equilibrium.Pathogens in forest ecosystem can slow nutrient flow,reduce competitions,create gaps and patches and even kill dominant trees like top predators in the food chain.In this case,both insects and pathogens can be considered as beneficial disturbances in forest management in many developed countries.There is a need to shift the objectives from pest control to pest management,and to place greater emphasis on ecological research and system approach in forest management.Shifting to pest management leads to the paradigm of 'ecologically based pest management'(EBPM),or managing pest without creating adverse environmental impacts.This paradigm complies well with new guidelines for biodiversity-oriented and sustainable forest management.Further,an alternative view on natural disturbances and mimicking natural disturbance regimes is proposed as a key component of an ecosystem-oriented approach to forest management.We point out that this alternative view on the biotic disturbances has been used in forest management in many developed countries,but is yet to be used in forest management in China until now.This new understanding of biotic disturbance in natural forest offers some guidance for managing forests in an ecologically sustainable way in China in the future.