Comparative study on muscle texture profile and nutritional value of channel catfish(Ictalurus punctatus)reared in ponds and reservoir cages
MA Lingqiao,QI Chenglong,CAO Jingjing,LI Dapeng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3724/SP.J.1231.2014.48963
2014-01-01
JOURNAL OF FISHERIES OF CHINA
Abstract:In order to understand the muscle nutritional value and texture profile of I. punctatus reared in ponds and reservoir cages,the nutritional composition,the w ater holding capacity and texture profile of muscle in I. punctatus w ere investigated. The crude protein,crude fat,crude ash,and moisture of muscle in I. punctatus w ere assayed by biochemical analysis methods. The muscular contents of mineral elements w ere measured by inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry( ICP-AES). The parameters of muscular texture profile,including hardness,springiness,cohesiveness,gumminess,chew iness,and resilience, w ere analyzed using a texture analyzer. Double compression w as applied to construct the texture profile analyses( TPA) of raw fillets. The results show ed that the rate of flesh content in I. punctatus reared in either pond or reservoir group w as more than 65%. Flesh leaching loss increased significantly in the pond group( 3. 96%) compared with those in the reservoir group( 3. 35%). Compared to the I. punctatus in the pond group( 1. 73% and 17. 19%,respectively),a significantly low er value in either drip loss or liquid loss w as observed in the I. punctatus in the reservoir group( 2. 37% and 27. 16%,respectively). The I. punctatus exhibited higher contents of crude protein and crude ash in the reservoir group( 18. 78% and 1. 03%, respectively) than those of the pond group( 16. 69% and 0. 90%,respectively). A significantly higher crude fat( 3. 90%) w as found in the I. punctatus in the pond group. The I. punctatus reared either in pond or in reservoir had rich mineral elements content in muscle. Compared to the pond group( 3 184,1 787,78. 8,246, 4. 19 and 3. 58 mg / kg,respectively),a significantly higher content of potassium( K),phosphorus( P), calcium( Ca),magnesium( Mg),zinc( Zn),and iron( Fe) w as observed in the reservoir group( 3 951,2 325, 110,312,5. 15 and 4. 94 mg / kg,respectively). How ever,there w ere no significant differences in sodium( Na),copper( Cu),manganese( Mn),and chromium( Cr) between the pond group and the reservoir group. No selenium( Se) w as detected in fish muscle of both groups. The calcium-phosphorus ratios of muscle in the pond group and the reservoir group w ere 1 ∶ 22. 6 and 1 ∶ 21. 1,respectively. The hardness,gumminess,and chew iness of muscle enhanced significantly in the I. punctatus in the reservoir group( 2 721,1 209 and 397 g,respectively) compared w ith those in the pond group( 4 552,1 738 and 578 g,respectively). The pond group( 0. 45 and 0. 31,respectively) had significant higher resilience and cohesiveness than those of the reservoir group( 0. 38 and 0. 24,respectively). Given the results,the muscle of I. punctatus show ed higher w ater holding capacity in the pond group,w hereas the I. punctatus muscle in the reservoir group contained higher protein,low er fat,richer mineral elements content,and higher hardness.